• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Three Proposals that Elizabeth Receives

Extracts from this document...


Compare and Contrast the Three Proposals that Elizabeth Receives Jane Austen's novel, Pride and Prejudice, contains many opinions given by the narrator about the characters, but the true personalities are shown in the way their feelings and words are portrayed. Austen uses dramatic irony to allow the reader to appreciate the hidden feelings of the characters. The unseen feelings of Elizabeth, Mr Darcy and Mr Collins are revealed to others in the novel during the three proposals that occur. There are a number of similarities between the first two proposals that Elizabeth receives. When Mr Collins made his "declaration of form" he expects Elizabeth to say yes, as did Mr Darcy. He "had no doubt of a favourable answer." This shows that they are both bad judges of character, because Elizabeth has no intention of marrying either of them. In fact, at the point in the novel when Mr Darcy proposes, she holds the biggest grudge against him. In both proposals they do not respect Elizabeth's feelings and insult her and her family. Mr Collins believes that "it is by no means certain that another offer of marriage may ever be made to her". He thinks this will make her want to marry him, but it has the opposite affect. Austen uses irony to make what Mr Collins says more effective. He emphasizes the fact that she is poor and that nobody else will want to marry her because of it, when actually he has said previously that he will be "uniformly silent" about how much money she will inherit. ...read more.


Elizabeth knows about his speeches and made herself miss her chance to interrupt it because she was "so near to laughing." On the other hand when Mr Darcy proposes he immediately tells her "how ardently he admires and loves her." Austen confirms his true love for Elizabeth by making his proposal disorganized and spontaneous, to show that it comes from the heart. The first proposal, from Mr Collins, is expected and Elizabeth does everything she can to avoid it. She even "begs" her mother not to leave her alone with him. On the other hand, when Mr Darcy arrives "to her utter amazement" she cannot even try to avoid the proposal because she has no idea that is going to happen. When the proposals take place Elizabeth is prepared for Mr Collins, but when Mr Darcy proposed, "she stared, coloured, doubted, and was silent." Austen uses her speechlessness to prove that she had no knowledge of any love Mr Darcy had for her, because she is usually quick thinking whatever happens, but on this occasion she is too shocked to make a clever response. When he proposes she dislikes him the most because he split up her sister and Mr Bingley. Austen emphasizes this hatred by the fact that Elizabeth is reading Jane's letters on his arrival. She, at this point in the novel, believes that Mr Darcy does not like her as much as she does not like him him, so is extremely shocked when he proposes. ...read more.


He shows during his proposal to be selfish, pompous and arrogant. It also shows that he lacks perception, and his pride in himself leads him to believe that he is more important than he actually is. When he is refused the reader is not made to feel sorry for him, but made to feel happy for Elizabeth in her successful refusal. When Mr Darcy first proposes his pride makes him be disrespectful to Elizabeth, and makes him seem rude. He shows that he believes he is superior to her and he should be respected. However, when Elizabeth informs him about how his pride has made him act improperly, he tries to change. In his second proposal he is a lot more thoughtful in the way he behaves, and is shown as a much more likeable character, resulting in the acceptance from Elizabeth. Austen uses irony throughout the novel but it is very clearly noticeable during Mr Collins' proposal to Elizabeth. Austen satirizes Mr Collins during the novel, and informs the reader of his character prior to the proposal to let the reader appreciate his language and actions. On the other hand when Mr Darcy proposes for the second time Austen uses the way in which Mr Darcy and Elizabeth act to let the reader be aware of his, and Elizabeth's feelings. After the proposals the reader is not made to feel sorry for Mr Collins, but is made to feel pleased for Mr Darcy. Throughout the novel Austen satirizes the characters that marry for money, and uses the marriage of Elizabeth and Mr Darcy to show that she thinks the most successful marriage is when they marry for love. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Jane Austen essays

  1. Pride and Prejudice - Both Darcy and Mr Collins propose to Elizabeth. Compare and ...

    When Mr Darcy finishes his proposal he is very angry and so is she. They are both struggling to compose their feelings. They ask direct questions . A lot of tension builds up here. Elizabeth is very accusatory. As Elizabeth gives her last and fierce speech he accepts her feelings towards him and apologizes to her for wasting her time.

  2. The ideas of marriage and the roles of women are very closely linked, compare ...

    Mrs Stanhope tries to have power, tries to make the decisions, but it just doesn't come over. Yes, Mary did fulfil Mrs Stanhope's wish, but Mary did it for her own gain not because her mother told her to. The person that makes the decisions and has the power is Mr Watts.

  1. Compare and contrast the marriage proposals made to Elizabeth by Collins and Darcy, and ...

    The readers' first impression of Mr Collins is based on the presumptuous letter he writes to Mr Bennet, inviting himself to stay at Longbourne for slightly under a week. The letter is formal and pompous and in it he apologies for his being next in the entail of Longbourne and

  2. Compare and contrast the two proposals to Elizabeth Bennet.

    angry that Mr Collins could be vein enough to believe himself worthy of Elizabeth's hand in marriage, not for a moment anticipating her refusal. Mr Collins approaches the proposal when Kitty, Mrs Bennet and Elizabeth are in the dining room, Mrs Bennet and Mr Collins almost cornering her, guaranteeing Mrs

  1. Compare the Proposals Elizabeth Receives From Mr Collins and Mr Darcy and Her Reactions ...

    They are two reckless individual who have been forced together to save their families reputation. There is also no way they can support themselves. However, the marriage of Mr Darcy and Lizzy is a marriage model of an ideal match.

  2. How do pride and Prejudice affect the relationship between Darcy and Elizabeth - Compare ...

    Mr Bennett intended on having a son to inherit the Longbourn estate, as this did not; Mr Collins is next in line to inherit the estate after Mr Bennet dies. In order for the estate to stay in the family, Mr Collins and particularly Mrs Bennet thought it would be

  1. Elizabeth receives three proposals of marriage in Pride and Prejudice. Why does she ...

    Women had few rights. The Bennet girls had the unfortunate coincidence of being five girls in their family. This meant that they would only have a small dowry, as all money had to be split five ways. Extra pressure was mounted on the Bennet girls' shoulders through Mr Collins.

  2. Elizabeth receives three proposals of marriage in 'Pride and Prejudice'. Why does she reject ...

    Lady Catherine De Bourgh was if the aristocracy and though she was very rich she wanted her daughter to marry Darcy so her daughter would continue living a pleasant and comfortable life as she was living. Throughout the novel we see the necessity of marriage especially to lower class people like the Bennets as they have all female children.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work