• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the two sonnets "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?" and "Sonnet 130".

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the two sonnets "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?" and "Sonnet 130" This essay is based on two sonnets, "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day" and "Sonnet 130", both of which are written by William Shakespeare. Although the poems are different to each other, they both come across as having the same meaning. "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day" is a traditional, romantic love poem of the seventeenth century. The purpose behind the poem is to flatter women. In the poem, Shakespeare compares his love to a summer's day. The way he does this is by highlighting all the negative points about summer and saying that she is much better. He beguiles her into thinking that in comparison to a day of summer she is much more extravagant. On the other hand "Sonnet 130" contradicts this poem. In "Sonnet 130" Shakespeare mentions all the bad points about his mistress in comparison with the small beauties in the world. This may sound as though he is unromantic towards his mistress, but he says that despite his mistress not being perfect, he still loves her as she is 'rare'. In this poem he is very critical towards other sonnets, for being over exaggerated and unrealistic to flatter women, as he feels it doesn't do women any justice. The irony about this is that, "Shall I compare thee..." is written by Shakespeare in a traditional form as well as "Sonnet 130"but this is written to exploit poets, who misguide women into believing they are love goddesses, but "Shall I compare thee..." ...read more.


It may be said that Shakespeare wrote this poem to his love at the time, or he may have wrote it through the perspective of another man writing to his love that is either alive or dead. Although both the sonnets appear to be different, they do have many similarities. Firstly, both of the poems carry the same purpose; to flatter women, but the techniques they use to do this, are different. In '' Shall I compare thee'' Shakespeare uses the downsides to summer, to contrast his love with. Whereas in ''Sonnet 130'' he uses the good qualities of materialistic things and compares them to his mistress, to show that even though she doesn't have a perfect exterior, he says she is original and special to him. The structures of the sonnets also have a great similarity. An example of this is that the concluding lines of both the sonnets carry an important meaning and message to convey to the reader. The finishing lines summarise the importance of the poem, for example in "Shall I" the ending verses emphasize the fact that, as long as the poem exists so does the lady that the poem is talking about. In "Sonnet 130" the ending lines justify why the poet is speaking negatively of his mistress, it is so that the poet can explain that his love does not have to be beautiful to be loved. Another similarity that the poems contain, are the inclusion of things like nature and colours, to build a creative image inside the reader's mind. ...read more.


However 'Sonnet 130' uses a wider range as it uses the senses; seeing, smelling and hearing, 'music hath a far more pleasing sound'. Out of the two poems I most enjoyed "Sonnet 130". This is because I found 'Shall I...' to be typically romantic and quite old fashioned, as I thought it was over exaggerated and too serious. However, I found "Sonnet 130" to be extremely enjoyable. This is because it was very humorous and sarcastic and I though it was quite a unique love poem compared to others that I have studied. I think that it would really appeal to a young, modern female audience due to its criticism of poets' stereotyped image of women. Along with being humorous it is also very romantic as it basically sends the message that no matter how a person looks on the outside it is what they are like on the inside that makes them special. It also shows that being unique does not mean that you have to be beautiful it's just your inner qualities that make you beautiful; these sorts of messages that are sent through the poem are very romantic. "Shall I..." is a poem that sort of indoctrinates women, into thinking that they are better than natural beauties, but it is well known that this is being quite untrue. It is being unfaithful to women by making all these false promises. Both of the poems are very effective in different ways due to the literal devices that are used by Shakespeare. These two sonnets are a perfect example of Shakespeare's versatility in writing love poems but with totally different approaches. ?? ?? ?? ?? Siddiqa Jeebhai 11JR ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Shakespeare's Sonnets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Shakespeare's Sonnets essays

  1. Sonnets 18, 116 and 130 all express ideas about love, but in different ways. ...

    'Love alters not with his brief hours and weeks'. Shakespeare is so sure he is right about true love that in the ending couplet he says if he is wrong he has never written any thing and no man has ever loved.

  2. Comparison of Shall I compare thee? and My mistress eyes are nothing like the ...

    The overall feel to this poem is tender and thought provoking and the thoughts and feelings of Shakespeare are clearly communicated throughout the sonnet. My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun... 1 My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun; Coral is far more red than her lips red:

  1. Sonnet 130: The Meaning Analysis

    Shakespeare also shuns other aspects of her physical beauty such as her hair, her cheeks and her breasts, while also writing down her breath and her voice. These suggest that Shakespeare could even be questioning why he may be with his mistress.

  2. The Presentation of Women in Shakespeare's Sonnet 130 and Griffin's Sonnet 39

    it cannot be gold and he have seen roses "damask'd" but never seen roses blooming from his mistress's cheeks. Shakespeare is very strong and definite when speaking and stating the truths of his mistress. It is also because of his decisive characteristic that makes the mistress real in nature.

  1. Looking at Sonnet 12 by William Shakespeare and I Look into my Glass by ...

    This links in with the theme, time, and suggests that different things get affected differently and at different speeds.

  2. Compare and contrast Christina Rossetti 'remember' and William Shakespeare's sonnet 71 in detail, considering ...

    3) and has a future planned with them. Shakespeare also is speaking of someone he loves. However in both of them, the factor of death is going to make the speaker in each sonnet the unattainable people, thus I think this theme is a refracted angle on the tradition which is different but also is linked with it.

  1. Sonnet 130 analysis - William Shakespeare satirises the convention of a traditional love poem

    These stock clichés or conventions for praising a woman’s beauty are a kind of charming way to tell your lover how much they mean to you, taking a woman’s features one by one, and then praising their loveliness. Yet, even as a graceful as it is, Shakespeare seems unhappy with such conventions.

  2. Love in Romeo and Juliet and Sonnets 18, 29 and 130.

    The poet is saying that despite all the bad things he has said about his mistress, he still finds his mistress beautiful in her own way and is unique. She isn?t some sort of dream like creature, rather her natural look is superior, unblemished by cosmetics, both physical and literal.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work