• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the two stories "The Signalman" and "The Red Room" explaining which one you enjoyed the most and why.

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the two stories "The Signalman" and "The Red Room" explaining which one you enjoyed the most and why. The stories, "The Red Room" written by H.G wells and, "The Signalman" by Charles Dickens were both written in the Victorian era. "The Signalman" is a short story about a man who works in the railway tracks. We find out the man is being visited by a spectre that warns him of great atrocities that are going to happen the trains that pass him. "The Red Room" is the story of a young naive character that believes that he can spend the night in a haunted room. There are some common themes in both the stories. Both seem to use darkness, dark places and shadows to create atmosphere. They also contrast old superstitions with new, progressive or rational ideas. I am now going to judge the two stories on a number of different elements including characters, plot, introduction, conclusion and typical ghost story conventions and give my opinion on which I believe is the better story and why. In "The Signalman" by Charles Dickens, the story starts out with the line "Halloa! ...read more.


I believe that the narrator makes the signalman feel relaxed because he represents the outside world that the signalman is not apart of because of the isolation of his place of work. We find out that the signalman is very conscientious and precise about his work. It is said, "no man in England knew his job better" and that "one of the safest men to be employed in that capacity." He gets used to the monotony and loneliness of his job and passes the time learning a language and experimenting with algebra. In his youth he had been well educated although he had "run wild, misused his opportunities, gone down, and never risen again. The narrator gives the impression that the signalman is very trustworthy and believable. We also hear that after the signalman starts to become more confident with the narrator and relieves a ghost that predicts train crashes before they actually happen is visiting him. The man is clearly in distress by the visions, which the narrator explains are caused by " the mental torture of a conscientious man, oppressed beyond endurance by the unintelligent responsibility involving life." In "The Red Room" we are presented with a completely different type of character. ...read more.


This could also represent the light at the end of the tunnel for the man with all the visions he is receiving. In my opinion "The Signalman" is the better of the two stories. It has a mysterious character that the reader can identify with and feel sorry for. In "Red Room" the character is much more arrogant and boastful which makes the reader not care as much as to what might happen to him. I think that the true meaning of "The Signalman" is the effect of modern technology and industrialisation on the human soul. The signalman is driven to the point of insanity by the monotony and, at the same time, the awful responsibility involved in his work. He is alienated from his environment: he is an intelligent and imaginative man that is deprived of sunlight, with very little to occupy himself and always knowing that the smallest mistake could lead to a terrible loss of life. The super natural element reflects the era that the story was written in. Many Victorians were very suspicious of the rapid advance in technology in the 19th century. The story is a true mystery has it can have a number of different true meanings and shows that it is about the impossibility of knowing what is real. ?? ?? ?? ?? English Coursework ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Signalman section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Signalman essays

  1. How is language used to create atmosphere in The Red Room and The Signalman

    As readers, we will continue to read the story because we will want to know what happened in the end. It helps create atmosphere as it is his own choice something may possibly happen, as well as this, in the story the characters are old which also helps build up tension.

  2. Compare and Contrast the two following short stories: 'The Signalman' by Charles Dickens and ...

    when the light is on it creates shadows, yet as soon as these shadows are created, they disappear quicker than lightening. Nothing is what it seems in 'The Red Room', this generates an eerie mood of mystery. "...examined the fastenings of several windows before closing the shutters, leant forward and looked up the blackness of the chimney".

  1. "The Signalman", "The Red Room" and "The Man with the Twisted Lip"

    At the end there is no "tangible" ghost. This shows a twist to the end of the story and subsequently would hold the reader in suspense. As for the characters, there are three old people and the hero. The hero is a 28-year-old man, does not believe in ghosts and "will relieve you from the task of entertaining" him.

  2. Pre 1914 Literature

    Repetition is also used again in the room when the candles keep being extinguished. This builds suspense and panic all the way to the final climax. "The flame vanished" In a way the old people are red herrings as they really try to scare off the narrator by telling him not to go to the room.

  1. ‘The Red Room’ by H.G. Wells and ‘The signalman’ by Charles Dickens.

    As if we knew how he felt. When the narrator was knocked out, we never quite know had happened to him. How exactly he was knocked out. If he knocked himself, or if someone did; a spirit or person. But he finalizes this story showing that all that haunted the

  2. Explain what makes a good mystery story, based on your understanding of 'The Red ...

    haunted room of yours" This shows that he is very eager to find out the truth about the room and is very arrogant, feeling that he is not afraid of any ghosts. When he reveals at the end that he has been in contact with fear it shows that even

  1. The Monkey's Paw" by W. W. Jacobs, "The Clubfooted Grocer" by Sir Arthur Canon ...

    The only thing which we know for sure is that Herbert, their son, is dead and he is not coming back. Throughout the story, Jacobs builds up and drops the suspense, creating a wave-like rhythm. This is effective because as soon as one revelation is made, suspense is being built

  2. Compare The Red Room, The Signalman and The Ostler.

    only discovered in 1999 were it was published for the first time. Collins exotic and gripping stories - often involving strong heroines, sinister locals, charlatans, and physical or psychological afflictions - became hugely popular with the reading public. Unafraid to question Victorian social morals, Collins never married but maintained two families.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work