• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the way in which the War is presented in Regeneration and Journey's End.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast the way in which the War is presented in Regeneration and Journey's End. Regeneration and Journey's End provide us with two contrasting views on the same subject; namely World War One. In Regeneration we have the stereotypical conception of early 20th century war - a heroic young officer leading his men to glory with no regard for himself. In contrast to this, Journey's End is a less traditional World War One text, with many characters and scenes included for nothing more than comic relief. It is fair to say that Regeneration deals with the war in a head on manner rather than dodging the subject of it, whereas in Journey's End, the matter of the war is somewhat disguised - fleeting references to combat amid the humour of Stanhope in his drunken stupor, and the farce of Mason's nature in the trench. ...read more.

Middle

The other side of the argument is that Journey's End is actually a very accurate and descriptive account of World War One. Being bored waiting for the orders to march to your own death could represent the characters situation, and that the comedy element of the text is there simply because the characters are bored with waiting for senseless orders, as seen when *CHARACTER* is counting down the hours until the attack by shading circles on a piece of paper. Whichever side of the argument I decide to support, there is always the feeling that Regeneration is simply the more accurate and descriptive text. I think the reason for this is the way in which we are allowed into the characters psyche, another element of descriptive literature that we do not see in R.C Sherrif's text. ...read more.

Conclusion

One is born, one fights for their county, and one dies. Regeneration on the other hand, is a slightly more sinister title, and conveys that no matter how hard you fight for your country, you are just a cog in a machine, and it can function without you, as your space will be regenerated and filled as soon as it becomes vacant. This message is certainly more firmly delivered in Regeneration, mainly because there are so many more characters, not just the soldiers, but the hospital staff, officials at home and on the front line, etc. In Journey's End, in contrast to this, the only characters we know of are the soldiers, and that creates the effect of the war being much more localised, and that the characters in the text are central to the novel, when this is not the case. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE RC Sheriff section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE RC Sheriff essays

  1. Journeys End

    As the play a progresses, the faint rosy glow of the dawn sky deepens into an angry red reflecting the culminating and never ending bloodshed during the war. The personifying adjective 'angry' increases the intensity of the colour and the atmosphere it creates distressing the audience as it allows them

  2. Journey's End - How do the key scenes present a dramatic demonstration of R.C ...

    Stanhope doesn't want to mention anything because he doesn't want to upset Raleigh. This is an act of comradeship as Stanhope could have upset Raleigh as it was a sad moment. Stanhope informs Raleigh about the German offensive and Raleigh starts to worry about the injury, "It - it hasn't gone through, has it?

  1. Act one of Journey's End.

    doctor, as it is obvious to us and the characters that Hibbert is faking it "no proof, as far as I can see" - Stanhope, this also shows us the purpose of a character like Hibbert, as a lot of soldiers faked illness in order to be sent away to

  2. Journey's End

    He is used as some sort of narrator before leaving to do his duties. They talk briefly about the "big German attack" which is basically what the play is structured around: Hardy: By the way, you know the big German attack's expected any day now?

  1. Journeys End Drama Studies

    why Stanhope is not happy to see Raleigh standing in the dug out. Stanhope is worried about Raleigh as he is a link back home and this alone could ruin what he has set up in the lack of home contact, in order to hide all his problems.

  2. Journeys End Coursework

    sort of behaviour before and has regretted letting men go because they wanted to get out of going to war, certainly tries to throw off everything Hibbert is trying to say. Hibbert: This neuralgia of mine. I'm awfully sorry. I'm afraid I can't stick it any longer - Stanhope: I know, rotten, isn't it?

  1. How does Sherrif explore and develop different attitudes to war?

    This is not just Hibbert this play is trying to explore the typical responses of the soldiers that go to war - not just Hibbert and Stanhope. Another character explored in this scene is Stanhope, but this time Sherrif makes use of italics to show that the characters are alive

  2. Robinson Crusoe - Analytical Paper.

    He is a sailor of the Cinque Ports galley. He was shipwrecked and lived alone the island for years. Robinson Kreutzner was born in the year 1632 in a certain city of York. He was the third son of his parents who have a very good name.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work