Compare and contrast the way that the directors interpret the transition from Dr Jekyll to Mr Hyde in John S. Robertson's 1920 and Maurice Phillips' 2003 films.

Authors Avatar

Compare and contrast the way that the directors interpret the transition from Dr Jekyll to Mr Hyde in John S. Robertson’s 1920 and Maurice Phillips’ 2003 films.

The strange case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson is one of the greatest stories of all time and a literary classic which has been adapted into countless movies . One of the first adaptations of the film was in 1920, directed by John S Robertson and one of he latest adaptations was made in 2003, directed by Maurice Phillips .  The adaptation of 1920 was a very high budget film, one of the biggest films of the time. The film starred John Barrymore, one of the best actors of the time , as well as Martha Mansfield and Brandon Hurst. The cast was a high profile one and the film tagline was ‘The worlds greatest actor in a tremendous story of man at his best and worst’. This shows that money was spent on the film and the film is still available today.

The second, more recent adaptation has been directed by Maurice Phillips in 2003 and stars John Hannah and David Warner. The movie was not shown in cinemas, unlike the 1920 film and is a low budget film which was made for  television  but nevertheless has many special effects .

Both films are based on the literary classic , which is about Dr Jekyll, a mild mannered, good Christian doctor who at night takes a potion and turns into the evil, horrendous Mr Hyde. The book is about how man is not one but truly two and that every person has a good side as well as a bad side. The book also highlights the hypocrisy of Victorian society . The book shows that Dr Jekyll turns himself into Mr Hyde because he wants to do the darker things in life but because he wants to maintain a good reputation, he turns himself into Mr. Hyde to do such dark deeds.  He then is addicted to turning himself into Mr Hyde and commit such deeds.

Join now!

Both transitions of Jekyll turning into Hyde are shown in different , but very effective ways. The scene in the 1920 version starts with Dr Jekyll making the potion.  There are a number of camera shots that have been used, which were very advanced for the time. A fusion of two shots has been used, which involves Jekyll consuming the potion as well as Jekyll’s   face superimposed over the top in close up. There is a close up on the face of  Barrymore and there is a wide shot  which has no effects.  The 2003 version has  different s ...

This is a preview of the whole essay