Compare and Contrast the ways in which Charles Dickens and Ray Bradbury create Tension and Suspense in "The Signalman" and "The Crowd".

Authors Avatar

20. March. 2002

Compare and Contrast the ways in which Charles Dickens and Ray Bradbury create Tension and Suspense in “The Signalman” and “The Crowd”

Both “The Signalman” by Charles Dickens and “The Crowd” by Ray Bradbury create a brilliant feeling of tension and suspense. Each story is worked around events that seem inexplicable. The protagonist characters and the reader becomes unsettled as these events unfold. Each story contains accidents, death, the supernatural, and an underlying sense of an unresolved mystery.

        Charles Dickens, writing in the nineteenth century, uses fear of modernization, mechanization and the belief in ghosts to his advantage, appealing to the fear of the unknown and the future. With the Industrial Revolution, and its new developments in science and technology, Dickens introduces the fascination with supernatural phenomenon.

        Ray Bradbury, writing in the middle of the twentieth century, uses a different pace, and a change in lifestyle to incite fear rather than addressing his own personal views through literature as Dickens does. However the impact of cars and television are aspects of modernization and are used to extend the sense of fear about the misunderstood. Making a later impact, the Cold War and its general political climate of suspense involving different countries and different leaders can easily be compared to the confusion and tension of this short story.

        Both of the stories through the reader right into the action. “The Signalman” begins strangely and grasps the reader’s attention straight away. The narrator, in direct speech, cries out, “Halloa! Below there!” and the signalman gives no verbal reply, only looks back down the railway line to the tunnel, not up to where the cry came from. The suspense begins as confusion and intrigue set in. After another cry from the narrator implying about a way to get down to where the signalman is, there is again no verbal answer. This suggests that there is something wrong and no quite normal here. “Deep down in a trench” is where the signalman is described as being. “Deep down” implicates lower than the earth, a desolate place of ruin and despair. “The crowd” begins also in mid action with Mr. Spallner, the protagonist character, putting his hands over his face, a natural instinct reaction in this first matter-of-fact sentence. Then in an explanatory first paragraph the extraordinary situation is revealed, but in a puzzling manner as the protagonist wonders how the crowd got to the scene of the accident so quickly. This is very confusing for the reader as it drops you right into the climax of the protagonist’s traumatic experience as the first signs of suspense are established by the mysterious appearance of the crowd.  

Join now!

        The setting and the weather are key factors in creating the senses of tension, fear and suspense. For example in “The Signalman” the weather is used to make matters unclear and leave a sense or emotion upon the reader, “I had shaded my eyes with my hand before I saw him.” This suggests there is something amiss gently leading the reader in a sense of confusion. “Angry sun” is again using the weather to demonstrate the mood, however, this time the mood is one of anger. In “The Crowd” weather is also used, in much the same way, to help ...

This is a preview of the whole essay