• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the ways in which the writer presents the supernatural in the short stories: The Signal Man and the Red Room!

Extracts from this document...


Sarah Rayner 10SH Thursday 28th Nov 2002 Compare and contrast the ways in which the writer presents the supernatural in the short stories: The Signal Man and the Red Room! There are many different ways in which the supernatural are interpreted in the two short stories. In the openings of the stories, the first similarity was that they both open with direct speech. This shows apprehension which makes the reader read on. Most stories have an introduction so these seem very different already. As soon as you read on you see that both of the stories will be focusing on the theme of the supernatural. This is shown by the word 'Tangible ghost' (The Red Room) and is also shown by the actions of the signal man looking the opposite way to which the original noises were first heard. This creates a sense of something abnormal. In the Red Room, the attitude of the old people set the tension and suspense due to them insisting that there is some sort of supernatural being, living and haunting under their roof. The guest calms the tension when, by the way he phrases his words, he tells them that he is not scared and will never be scared of any non-living creature. The tension is brought up to a higher level when the old people mention that they will accept no blame if anything happens to him whilst he is alone upstairs; however, in The Signal Man, the tension and suspense is created with an entirely different approach. ...read more.


The way that he didn't answer at first made us wonder what he was focusing on or whether he just didn't want to answer. In a way this builds suspense by the actions of the man. Referring to the red room again, when the guest leaves the old people, one of the old people continues to use repetitive phrases but this time it is a different phrase. "It's your own choosing!" The description of the hall way he is about to walk down creates tension because the way that it is described, you wouldn't really want to walk down there on your own especially after sitting through a lecture, well not when the old people told you things like that. Whilst walking up to his room his room he ponders over how odd the three pensioners are. So far through both of these stories, they show that they are very similar in the way that they both open with direct speech and how similar they are with raising the tension and suspense. They are both good as far as the first pages go, however you will have to read on to see how much more the tension can build up to. The signal man tries to accuse the other man of being seen earlier down the track. The man said he looked familiar and that was his excuse for not answering the first question the man asked him. The signal man describes himself as having worked so much that he has formed into the way he lives. ...read more.


It makes the narrator quite angry because he would like to help him but there is no way he can do this. When they see another figure (the one that is sent to symbolise the end of the Signal man's life), this creates the most tension in the story, but even more so because it involved the main character and the readers will want to know if he survives. The narrator knows there is something wrong and so does the signal man in his own way, when they see the light... "With an irresistible sense that something was wrong..." The narrator cannot believe it when he finds out that the man is dead. Being annoyed with himself, he takes a walk to the first place he ever saw the signal man. He recalls the other times he had spoken to him and the times the man had told him about the figures. He thought he was stupid for not believing him but he didn't want to believe it. The tension and suspense is created in the last few scenes when he recalls the phrases the signal man said, he then realises what they meant and wondered if there was anyway in which he was able to prevent this from happening. The signal man was my favourite out of all of the stories. It gave me more of a sense as to what was happening and in my opinion; it had more suspense and tension but also had a much better story line! By Sarah Rayner 10SH ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Signalman section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Signalman essays

  1. Charles Dickins the signal man

    Automatically this provokes a fear as at night there is dark, both of these are two common fears, also the idea that he goes for walks at night as slightly disturbing and puts a "?" over the character. As well as a disturbing sense that night gives, most people are

  2. Examine the settings which the writers have chosen for their stories in 'the signal ...

    The word 'violent' hints that it is hostile. This is a good example of how reality is twisted and distorted in the tunnel. This has the effect of creating suspense and fear for the reader. The description of the setting is desolated and cold.

  1. Dickens ghosts. Malevolent or Benevolent

    "It was not!" said a deep voice. "Gabriel started up, and stood rooted to the spot, with astonishment and terror, for his eyes rested on a form that made his bloody run cold". This suggests that Grub may have another side to his nasty characteristic as we presume from the previous quotes that

  2. The signal man and the Red Room are both pieces of unique gothic literature

    emphasises to the old setting. After wandering around the hallway the narrator finally reaches the red room. When he enters the red room, we notice that he starts to analyse his surroundings carefully and distinctively. We learn that in the red room, the duke died along with his wife.

  1. 'Examine the settings which the writers have chosen for their stories in ''The Signalman'', ...

    A full solution was reached at the end. ''The Red Room''- this story like the others, is written in the first person. Our narrator here is an unnamed 28 year old sceptical about ghosts.

  2. Suspense - The Signal Man

    rational entity runs out of explanations, which greatly adds to the suspense. Alliteration is a device widely used this genre of story. It can be used to create a spookier atmosphere, especially when describing the scene, i.e. "Down in the deep".

  1. Review three of the short stories you have read and say how they were ...

    The narrator had been so concerned for the signalman's state of mind that he had tried to calm him down by making him focus on the importance of his job and that they would, on the next night gain medical opinion of his state of mind.

  2. Using a selection of short stories written before 1914, compare and contrast their authors' ...

    Again, the supernatural visitation was in human form, and yet, in parallel to the vision of Mrs Lodge, it is warped: "A figure inexpressibly thin and pathetic, of a dusty leaden colour." The visitor disturbs both characters, although Rhoda's vision does a lot more damage to Rhoda than the figure

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work