• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast Two Short Stories From Different Time Periods, But From the Same Genre

Extracts from this document...


Compare and Contrast two short stories from different time periods, But from the same genre In this essay I will compare the pre 20th Century text "The Black Cat" (1843) by Edgar Allen Poe and the post 20th Century text "Hell's Event" (1984) by Clive Barker both of which are horror stories. Edgar Allen Poe was born in Boston, USA in 1809. He had a brother, Henry, and a sister, Rosaline. In December of 1812 the children were orphaned and the family was split up. Henry stayed in Baltimore with his grandparents. Edgar and Rosaline Poe were taken in by wealthy Richmond families, Rosaline by the Mackenzies and Edgar by the Allans. In 1827 prior to enlisting in the army Edgar wrote his first two poems known as "To Margaret" and "To Octavia". By 1833 Edgar had begun to write stories and in 1835 he married his cousin, Virginia but she died 12 years later. On 7 October 1849 at about 4.30pm Poe died. The actual cause of death at the relatively young age of 40 has never been confirmed. Poe was buried in his grandfather's lot in the Westminster burying ground. Throughout his life Poe had been victimised and taken advantage of and I think this may have influenced some of his texts. Clive Barker was born near Penny Lane, Liverpool in 1952. ...read more.


the fact that Burgess is a bad and un-sympathetic character, a good character would be very unlikely to wear this sort of coat. Clive Barker has tried to make burgess more horrifying by describing the coat in detail, he says 'He wore a coat apparently made of several goat-skins. The hooves and the horns still hung from it. The blood on its fur was brown and gummy." On page forty-five about halfway through the story Burgess admits that he works for hell. The very fact that he works for hell will tell the reader that he is an evil character. Although Burgess is an evil character some of the things Barker writes, which Burgess says are quite witty and funny. In The black cat there are also three main protagonists The two cats and the man who tells the story, which is told in first person whereas Hells Event is written in third person. You never actually learn of the mans name, so for the purpose of this essay I will refer to him simply as 'The man'. Also you never learn of the second cats name and so I will refer to him as 'The cat'. The man who tells the story is a good character at the beginning, but as the story goes on he gets more ill tempered and violent until at the end of the story he is a violent character. ...read more.


For example in the 1800s Poe used 'I suffered myself to use intemperate language to my wife.' Which means the man swore at his wife, but in Hells Event barker just simply uses the actual words, which express his characters feelings more, for example, "Shit, said Cameron as he was plunged into darkness." Shorter words are now used instead of longer more difficult ones like intoxicated which means drunk and felons cell, which means prison. There is no open speech in The Black Cat; instead there is reported speech. In this story there are lots of things that would not be written today, e.g. 'Pluto - this was the cats name - was my favourite pet.' Would be written today as 'Pluto (this was the cats name) was my favourite pet.' I preferred hells event to The Black Cat because there was a bit more detail which made it more horrific, like the part where Joel is killed, 'Joel felt the last of his strength falter: his arm could keep the mouth at bay no longer. Despairing, he felt the teeth at his brow and at his chin, felt them pierce his flesh and his bone, felt, finally, the white night evade him, as the mouth bit off his face.' Also The Black Cat is harder to read because a lot of words in it are no longer used. Both story's were good and I like the horror genre in general anyway so I enjoyed reading the story's. By James Barker-Grimshaw ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Edgar Allan Poe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Edgar Allan Poe essays

  1. The Creative Destroyer: An analysis of Poe's The Oval Portrait.

    He uses words like "wounded" and "delirium" to describe his condition. His incapacity to remain conscious for long periods is also highlighted in various parts not least when he first catches sight of the portrait. These descriptions of the character act as a subtle warning to the reader not to take the events that unfold for granted.

  2. Compare and contrast the narrative techniques used in three or more of Edgar Allan ...

    no one would discover his plans, we can also tell of his intelligence by what he spoke to Fortunato. He asked for assistance in wine tasting, but says if he is busy he will ask Luchesi , this causes Fortunato want to help even more as Montresor is now using

  1. 'How are nineteenth century short stories traditional short stories?'

    Another reason for why he is an outsider is because he is deformed and ugly. The first line in the story is, "I never knew any one so keenly alive to a joke as the king was." This line isn't really effective as it doesn't engage the reader immediately by using dramatic or humorous words.

  2. The Mystery of Edgar Allan Poe's Works

    After staying in England more than thirteen years, Edgar was more sophisticated and cosmopolitan, and far better educated than his mates in Richmond (Meyers 14). The education of Edgar in England had a great effect on him as this education widened his horizon of writing, as he read in his childhood many books and novels to great writers.

  1. Choose two of the pre-20th century short stories that you have studied. Compare and ...

    It may be a coincidence, but it is unnerving to note that both are disabled. In "Hop-Frog", the main character is described in great detail, and we find out that he is physically disabled, being a cripple and a dwarf, and this in itself brings about tension for Hop-Frog is

  2. By comparing‘The Yellow Wallpaper’ with ‘Hop Frog’ discuss the ways in which the writersportray ...

    It is described as having 'barred' windows and the bedstead as 'iron', 'heavy' and 'nailed to the ground' representing her being tied down. The fact that the room was 'a nursery first', is very ironic; Firstly because she has no contact with her own baby and secondly because she has literally been reduced to the position of a child.

  1. Edgar Allan Poe's The Raven

    Both are, in truth, the natural results of the predominating quality of his mind, to which we have before alluded, analysis. It is this which distinguishes the artist. "The Tell-Tale Heart" was first published in 1843 in the Boston Pioneer, and revised into its current form for an 1845 edition of The Broadway Journal.

  2. Explore the techniques used by pre-twentieth century authors to build fear and tension for ...

    Once again, we see that this cat, from beyond the grave has managed to produce itself. It summons terror in the reader and insecurity fills Poe. One night, as the write stood, "absolutely stupefied," he sees a black object, and it turns out to be a large black cat, almost

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work