• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare, contrast and evaluate the 5 screen interpretations of Othello's Final Speech - cross-comparing throughout, under different headings.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

COMPARE, CONTRAST and EVALUATE the 5 SCREEN INTERPRETATIONS of Othello's Final Speech - cross-comparing throughout, under different headings. Include references to (and comments on): * Key moments and evidence from Othello's key speeches from across the play, as you try to come to terms with his "tragic fate" * Your reactions to T. S. Eliot's interpretation * Your reaction to A. C. Bradley's interpretation * Use the Greer and Ryan interpretations * Reference to the Robeson Production * Relevant context material - from the articles and from your notes * Some evaluation of language Othello's emotional final scene contains the deaths of three major characters in the play: Othello, Desdemona and Emilia. There have been many disagreements over the meanings of these deaths and how they relate to other events in the play, but Othello's appears to be the most controversial of the three. This scene, most importantly Othello's final speech, has been interpreted in many different ways, including articles, paintings, and film and stage productions. Two main ideas which have arisen from these different interpretations are the portrayal of Othello as either Bradley's "romantic figure" or Leavis's "egotistic" character. Five different illustrations of Othello's final speech have been done by Welles, Olivier, Hopkins, White and Fishbourne, all playing Othello in feature films or stage productions of the play. Welles's black and white feature film cuts the speech dramatically, but produces and powerful and emotional scene. ...read more.

Middle

Similarly, Othello dies lying with his wife, after kissing her. "Killing myself, to die upon a kiss." V.ii.355. Othello is portrayed as more emotional than the previous three, as he is shown as truly distraught and crying. He also shows signs of feeling bitter for the loss of Desdemona, and for being betrayed by Iago. However, he is still shown as having authority over Desdemona, as he is shown in the end of the final scene, lying on top of her, which also suggests how she was always submissive to him, even at the end of her life. However, she is still portrayed as innocent, as she is clothed in white and surrounded by white sheets. It seems almost contradictory, then, that Othello is clothed in white as well, but this simply demonstrates his love for Desdemona, and implies the portrayal of a "romantic figure". Due to the colour of his clothing, then, he is shown to walk into the shadows or away from the light to commit suicide, so that the idea that he is condemned to Hell is still enforced. Similarly to the White and Olivier illustrations of Othello in V.ii., Fishbourne plays a romantic, noble character, who is emotional but relatively calm, although still noble and hedonistic. However, his emotions are still clear, as he, too, cries during his final speech, and speaks at almost a whisper. Like White's portrayal, Fishbourne appears bitter, making threatening moves before climbing on top of Desdemona "to die upon a kiss". ...read more.

Conclusion

Kiernan Ryan believes that Othello is between the interpretations Bradley and Leavis gave, saying that "insofar as Othello is a black outsider, he is the tragic victim of the poisonous racist mentality embodied in Iago". However, he then progresses to comment that "inasmuch as he is a man, acting in unconscious obedience to the norms of patriarchy, he is also the complicit agent of his own derangement and demise". Paul Robeson's revolutionary portrayal as Othello also illustrated the character as "noble", and "magnificence personified". Words such as "power", "majesty", "grandeur", "sweet simplicity" and "innocence" are frequently used in contemporary reviews, once even being described as showing "radiant bliss" when reunited with Desdemona in II.i. This implies that Robeson played the "romantic figure" Bradley spoke of in 1904. I agree with T. S. Eliot's interpretation of Othello in his final speech, and across the play, as a "pathetic character", as he has shown signs of being untrusting towards Desdemona, having very little faith in her, and decided his opinion and feelings were more important than any others, including the justice system. Othello felt, throughout V.ii., that he was just in his actions, stating that Desdemona could "almost persuade Justice to break her sword", implying that he believes that what he is about to do is just and fair, but her sweet breath and face could "almost persuade" him to not kill her. This is clearly ignorance and arrogance, in my opinion, and fortifies the interpretation of Othello as "a pathetic figure". Charlotte Greene 12A ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Othello section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Othello essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How does Shakespeare use language and stagecraft to show Othello's changing feelings towards Dedemona ...

    4 star(s)

    "This fellow's of exceeding honesty, and knows all qualities, with a learned spirit, of human dealings. If I do prove her haggard, though that her jesses were my dear heart-strings, I'd whistle her off, and let her down the wind to prey at fortune" Othello says that Iago is honest, and is beginning to believe him.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Give a detailed analysis of Othello's final speech,

    3 star(s)

    up a spotlight focused on his face looking up as if addressing higher powers. T. S. Eliot produced an article in 1927 titled "Shakespeare and the Stoicism of Seneca", in this piece a key section "what Othello seems to be doing is cheering himself up" this can be seen in

  1. Is Othello a 'noble hero' brought down by 'a devil of motiveless malignity' or ...

    things in a way that benefits him and allows him to move closer towards his goals. He tries to present himself as a friend to Othello in an attempt to gain his trust, in the line 'you were best go in' (1.2.29)

  2. How Is Othello Viewed By Others And How Does He View Himself

    Even after he has been the subject of confusing and malicious actions by the changed Othello, he still speaks of him well- 'For he was great of heart.' This highlights one of Othello's "tragic flaws". He is unable to make a good judge of character, and seems to be enormously

  1. Directing a Othello- Symbolism of Final Scene

    The audience has to grasp the hate and sympathise with Othello. The audience had to sympathise with Othello because we want them to experience Catharsis. Othello, in theory, the pays the price of his mistake- he kills his wife and gets demoted.

  2. The film Revolutionary Road and the play Othello both exhibit conflicting marriages.

    The greater conflict is ideological. This conflict is revealed when April speaking to Frank and says, "It's unrealistic for a man with a fine mind to go on working year after year at e job he can't stand, coming home to a place he can't stand, to a wife who is equally unable to stand the same things."

  1. How do the different critical readings of the play inform our understanding of the ...

    When Emilia stops being subservient to Iago, as she says, 'no I will speak as liberal as the north' which is a metaphor of her rebellion because the north wind is strong, bitter cold and chilling, Othello sees the truth and realises that Iago was lying.

  2. Compare and contrast a feature film and an original theatre performance, concentrating on the ...

    However the image, which Othello describes, is different to that which Brabantio presents and is further represented by Desdemona herself when she appears on stage. Othello's love for Desdemona is passionate, true and genuine. This is represented particularly at the end of the Act 1 Scene 3 as Othello has

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work