Compare Duncan’s Murder and the Banquet scene

Authors Avatar

Macbeth

After reading Macbeth, I watched videos of two very different adaptations of Shakespeare’s play, a BBC theatre production and a low budget movie. The BBC production was filmed on stage, was traditional and true to the play, the movie, “Macbeth on the Estate” was a modern interpretation along the lines of the recent film “William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet”. It was set, not in Scotland, but on Birmingham's Ladywood estate; The characters were all members of street gangs, drug dealers and criminals, not Scottish nobility;

The weird sisters became weird children; Although most of the principal characters were played by professional actors, over a hundred local people from the estate took part, some in speaking roles;  The director was a documentary film-maker, not a theatre or even a TV drama director ant the play was cut to an hour and twenty minutes in length.  Although I enjoyed the BBC version I preferred the modern film. I thought that its setting in an urban estate worked very well and helped me to understand the play and the roles of the characters more easily.

The two scenes I have to compare are Duncan’s Murder and the Banquet scene.

Duncan’s Murder

In the traditional play, we find Macbeth and his wife plotting to kill the king. Macbeth is obviously scared of committing murder and it is Lady Macbeth who proves to be stronger, persuading him to hide his fear,  

“Your hand, your tongue, look like the’ innocent flower, but be the serpent under’t, and take Duncan’s life”.

When Duncan and the other thanes arrive Macbeth provides a feast in their honour. Duncan is a nice old man but is naive in believing that Macbeth will protect him. This contrasts with the wicked plotting of Macbeth and his wife.

Join now!

Duncan goes to bed shortly after the feast is over. Macbeth starts to doubt about whether killing Duncan is the right thing; and wrestles with his conscience:

“Bloody instruction which being taught return to plague the inventor”.  

Macbeth thinks if he kills Duncan his mind will be tortured by guilt.  By the time lady Macbeth comes to find him, Macbeth has changed his mind.

“We will proceed no further in this business”.

Lady Macbeth is scornful of her husband.  She accuses him of cowardice and a lack of love for her.

“When you durst do ...

This is a preview of the whole essay