• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare Hardys presentation of women in An Imaginative Women and On the Western Circuit

Extracts from this document...


Compare Hardy's presentation of women in two short stories Thomas Hardy's presentation of women is quite highlights the typical Victorian attitude towards women . In particular, 'An Imaginative Women' and 'On the Western Circuit' produce some interesting comparisons. The two leading characters are women, Ella Marchmill ('An Imaginative Woman') and Edith Harnham ('On the Western Circuit'). The first and probably the most obvious similarity between the two women is the way Hardy has presented their marriage. This was at a time when men still exerted their power over women, and a woman divorcing a man was unheard of. In both of these stories, Hardy has portrayed both of them as passionate, yet unhappy wives. William Marchmill, Ella's husband, is mention quite frequently in the story and plays an integral part, so we get a more accurate picture of him. However, Edith Harnham's husband only appears near the start, yet in that one glance, we get a good idea of the relationship between the two. "Oh? Horrid nuisance every year! I wish it could be put a stop to." "I like it." ...read more.


The consequences of the act of deception became severe when Anna became pregnant with Raye's child. Still though, her infatuation with Raye continues; "I wish his child was mine-I wish it was! Yet how can I say such a wicked thing." Eventually, Raye and Anna end up married, with Raye only finding out the truth when it is too late. A man of Raye's integrity and position was expected to marry a woman of similar status, not an 'illiterate peasant', so the marriage would have been very damaging to Raye's reputation and social position, and as a result, the final act of deception had been carried out and Mrs Harnham and seen it out to the bitter end. Ella Marchmill, the protagonist in 'An Imaginative Woman', is also sexually unfulfilled by her husband William Marchmill. Due to his prosperous job in the gun trade, he is away for much of the time, and Ella ends up with an infatuation for a poet, Robert Trewe. Ella is described as having a lack of maternal instinct, which becomes evident within the first page. She is walking on the beach with her children 'considerably far ahead with the nurse'. ...read more.


Mrs Harnham also felt similar regret, as if she told the truth from the very beginning, she may have found happiness. Ella later goes onto die from childbirth in what can only be assumed as unhappy circumstances. Both women in the stories felt a high level of guilt for their dishonesty, with Ella even admitting to her husband that she was 'wicked', whilst Mrs Harnham broke down into tears. Despite the evidence that both women feel responsible and guilty for their crimes, it still doesn't give them the extra bit of integrity needed for the reader to feel sympathetic towards them. The weak relationship between husband and wife in both stories, builds up a certain degree of sympathy for the female protagonists; however, any respect that the reader may have held for them[, would most likely have vanished after their web of deceit and deception. Neither stories produce a clear-cut villain or heroine and despite the quite depressing ending, sympathy is more likely to be given to the potential lovers. The moral of the two stories is that deception, whether intended or not, inevitably leads to unhappiness for all concerned. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Other Titles section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Other Titles essays

  1. English coursework. Analysing 4 short stories

    The way in which Mrs Callender receives personal, not physical compliments shows that she is not judged by her appearance, but she is judged by her personality. I think that the compliments she receives are used purposely by the author to create independence and respect for Mrs Callender, "You are a noble woman".

  2. Thomas Hardy has been praised for the strength of his narrative in The Wessex ...

    This then gave Hardy control as to how much the reader knew and gave them chance to interpret how things would occur, he also did this by giving 'hints' as to what would happen. For example in 'The Withered Arm' Hardy tells us that the boy who was to be

  1. Discuss Thomas Hardy(TM)s Portrayal of Women

    As she grew more and more distanced form her husband she began to desire for an execution as a result of her visit to conjuror Trendle. I think Hardy portrays Gertrude like this to demonstrate the Hardship caused to women is Hardy's lifetime and how they were treated by their Husbands.

  2. Explore how women are presented by Thomas Hardy in The Sons Veto, The Withered ...

    Sophy begins to take back some control as to the direction of her life by taking a wagon trip with Sam. She is starting to recognise that everyone deserves to be happy. 'I am so lonely in my house, and this makes me so happy.'

  1. thomas hardy comparing women character

    However, even though Rhoda and her son lives in poverty, they remain strong throughout the story, trying to convince the villagers that they are doing fine. They do not complain about their lack of wealth, but suffer in silence. From the conversation between Gertrude Lodge and Rhoda's son, we can

  2. Consider how Thomas Hardy explores and presents his views on relationships between men and ...

    "This pretty young woman had rendered impossible any reparation which Lodge might have made Rhoda for his past conduct". Rhoda and Framer Lodge love each other and want to make their relationship with each other genuine, but understand that

  1. Thomas Hardy Essay

    When Humphrey suddenly returns again, he tells her that he has married another woman and wants her help in not letting his father get too angry. Phyllis feels surprised but also relieved by the unexpected news. Meanwhile Matth�us and his friend Christoph are shot for desertion, leaving a lonely and grief-stricken Phyllis.

  2. What is Hardy saying about the treatment of women by society through the medium ...

    This could be due to the fact that she had worked there for a long period of time and was subsequently on better terms with the family. Another reason why Sophie was treated considerably better than many servants was because she had taken care of Twycott when he was ill.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work