• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare how each author presents attitudes towards marriage in "The Three Sisters" by Jane Austen, and "Teresa's Wedding" by William Trevor

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare how each author presents attitudes towards marriage in "The Three Sisters" by Jane Austen, and "Teresa's Wedding" by William Trevor Although 'The Three Sisters' is believed to be written before 1792 and 'Teresa's Wedding' was published in 1993, being two hundred years apart does not have such a significant effect as would have been expected. As the themes, ideas, societies, and views are similar, they are extremely alike. However, they also have very apparent contrasts due to the periods in which they were set and written in. The most significant contrast between the two is their narrative style and this is important because it affects the way in which marriages of the time are perceived. 'The Three Sisters' is set and was written in the Regency Period and is presented in an epistolary style, which was very popular at this time. It is also very subjective, writing from the point of view of alternate narrators and characters. 'Teresa's Wedding' in contrast, is very objective, for example when Trevor says, "In know way did Teresa love him". This is very powerful because it is very impassive and he is stating her feelings rather than relating them. This makes the readers aware of her feelings at all times instead of them trying to understand her feelings, thus making it easier to show the motive behind getting married and how she was forced. 'Teresa's Wedding' is set in the 1960's, in Ireland. At this time they were very religious and life revolved around the moral principles and teaching of Catholicism. In 'The Three Sisters', Austen uses unusual syntax, which might seem archaic in comparison to the contemporary style of today, which Trevor uses. In Austen's "novel" she says, "Mr Watt's figure is unfortunately extremely vulgar and his Countenance is very heavy". Whereas when Trevor describes a character he says, "The bride, who had been Teresa Atty and was now Teresa Cornish, had a round pretty face and black, pretty hair, and was a month and a half pregnant". ...read more.

Middle

The loveless marriage of Teresa is similar to Mary in 'The Three Sisters', as she does not love Mr Watts but actually hates him, yet she is forced by her erratic temperament. As is apparent from her second letter, when her mother is actually introduced into the story instead of referred to. Mary's mother is very astute in her ways and says, "I am not going to force you" however she then goes on to say that if Mary doesn't accept him then "Sophy may", psychologically compelling her to marry Mr Watts, because, as she said before, she "could not bear either of them to be married before" her, meaning Sophy and Georgiana. Mary then says to her mother that she "shall certainly marry him". In this way Father Hogan is similar, he is cunning as well, as Teresa said that "she didn't love him or feel anything for him one way or the other" and "Father Hogan had replied that in the circumstances all that line of talk was irrelevant", and he could make her believe she had to marry Artie because of the power he had in the town. He demonstrates this power with Teresa and Artie and proves that religion has a bigger influence on their lives than love. Just as in 'The Three Sisters', money and status has a bigger influence than love. In Austen's "novel", Mary's mother appears to be extremely determined to have her daughter's married, because even if Mary is not to be married to Mr Watts, one of her daughters will, as she says, "I am determined not to let such an opportunity escape of settling one of my Daughters so advantageously". This is perhaps because she needs the money for when she is older, and cannot support her daughters as well as herself, so she must have them married before they are too old because otherwise they will not be taken for a wife. ...read more.

Conclusion

Mary, however, was extremely materialistic and this may be because she is the eldest and was more liable to be spoilt before Georgiana and Sophy were born. She is self-obsessed and ostentatious, so expects more than what Mr Watts is willing to offer, this is the main reason for her hatred against him. Georgiana is not materialistic and does not expect as much as Sophy. She wants a husband who is the complete opposite of Mr Watts. Mr Watts in her description is "So deficient in every respect. Hideous in his person and without one good Quality to make amends for it. His fortune is good. Yet not so very large! Three thousand a year. What is three thousand a year? It is but six times as much as my Mother's income. It will not tempt me" Mrs Stanhope wants society to remain as it is, because if it does not than she will not be supported in her old age, and so she tries to force her daughters to marry for money instead of love, as she feels this is their duty. This shows that times were changing during the Regency period, Austen's era, and she was an early feminist. In 'The Three Sisters', the motivation behind Mary's marriage was to surpass the Duttons and her sisters, and gratify her mother, and in 'Teresa's Wedding', Teresa and Artie also married to satisfy, but were pleasing the community. Although society was different in 'The Three Sisters' compared to 'Teresa's Wedding', the attitudes towards marriage are the same. In both, life was lived by what was expected of them, rather than what they dreamed of doing. In 'Teresa's Wedding', marriage could be seen as an escape from parental dominance, as it was with Agnes. Segregation was evident in both, as marriage is to raise status in Austen's "novel", and there was separation amongst the guests at the wedding. Overall, the stories were very similar in theme, however, they contrasted strongly in style and address, but both were as effective giving good historical evidence and an excellent account. Dominique Briggs- English- Ms Stokes 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Jane Austen essays

  1. A Comparison of Charles Dickens and Jane Austen

    Darcy's pride in his position in society leads him initially to become prejudice and scornful against anyone outside of his own social circle. Elizabeth's vanity clouds her judgment, making her prone to think ill of Darcy and to think well of Wickham.

  2. Examine the different marriage relationships and attitudes towards marriage presented in 'Pride and Prejudice'. ...

    amends I shall not be the person to discourage him" Elizabeth's mother and father really only want to keep the house in the family as Mr Collins will take possession of it if Mr Bennet dies. When Mr Collins first proposes to Elizabeth she is highly annoyed and does not

  1. 'Pride and Prejudice' by Jane Austen as my pre-1914 novel and 'Bridget Jones's Diary' ...

    no longer considered to hold great importance, the main emphasis is now placed on the cities. The two main characters in 'Pride and Prejudice' would have to be 'Elizabeth Bennet' and her future love 'Mr.Darcy'. We first hear of Elizabeth in the opening passage, through the words of her father.

  2. From a reading of Jane Austen's short stories what do we learn about women's ...

    Today people fall in love then marry, money is usually second. Only some part is arranged marriages happen. At first Mary is flattered by the marriage proposal, she is excited about her status and image. Until Mr Watts says he will marry any of the sisters, as they are not that attractive.

  1. Charlotte Lucas says, "Happiness in marriage is entirely a matter of chance." With close ...

    Bennet's constant blabbering about Mr Bingley and could be seen as showing how Mr. Bennet is not at all interested. The shortness of lines compared to the long sentences that Mrs. Bennet uses, could be interpreted as showing how contrasted Mr and Mrs Bennet's personalities are.

  2. How does Jane Austen present love and marriage in

    The first line in chapter twenty is very ironic and shows how ridiculous he is: "Mr Collins was not left long to the silent contemplation of his successful love" Though sincerely refused by Elizabeth numerous times, he still considers his proposal to be successful, thinking her denial is merely encouragement.

  1. The late eighteenth century, through to the early nineteenth century, I have discovered, was ...

    He was actually described to have a; '...forbidding, disagreeable countenance,' and unworthy to be compared to his friend, Mr Bingley. He only danced once and declined being introduced to any other lady. 'His character was decided. He was the proudest, most disagreeable man in the world, and everybody hoped that he would never come there again.'

  2. Explore in detail how Elizabeths views and actions are not of a Typical Regency ...

    Darcy full of pride. Mr. Darcy states that "There is not another woman in the room whom it would not be a punishment to me to stand up with." Elizabeth hates his pride and lack of respect for others. She thinks he is the most unagreeable man unlike his friend Bingley.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work