Compare how "Nettles" and "Upon my Son" Show Love for their Child

Authors Avatar

Compare how “Nettles” and “Upon my Son” Show Love for their Child

        

In “Nettles” the parent shows that he loves his son by protecting him when he is hurt and then fights on his behalf whilst he still can. Also the parent shows love by making his son as comfortable as possible whilst he still can, and letting his anger show all his emotion. Furthermore the writer, Vernon Scannell, shows the fathers love by using punctuation to highlight certain feelings. In comparison, in ‘Upon my Son’ the poet shows the mother love for her son by using a triadic structure to emphasise her want for the child. Another way in which the mother shows love for her son by expecting someone above herself to protect him and being very unrealistic due to herself being blinded by love for him. Finally the mother uses words with connotations of love.

Firstly in “Nettles” the father shows love for his son by protecting him when he is hurt. ‘And went outside’ implies that inside: the little world they have created is safe. However the father is going outside into the world to attempt to destroy some of the things his son may need protecting from. Therefore if his son needs protecting from nettles, that is what he’ll protect him from. On the other hand in “Upon My Son” the mother shows herself to be selfish as she expects someone else to protect her son. ‘Thou heard’st mer then, and gav’st him me’ implies that it is Gods son aswell because he gave the son to her. Furthermore because God gave the son to her, she must be a follower therefore so is the son, probably, the mother is trying to exploit God’s protection of his followers so that she does not have to worry about protecting her son. Also the word ‘me’ suggests that the mother believes she is special because the child was given to her and not another mother so she is using the generous heart of this person who gave her the child to try and suppress him into protecting his child. Later on, however, the mother does prove that she may have some love for her child, as any mother willing to die for their child rather than have him hurt must care for their child. ‘If otherwise I go to rest’ therefore, implying that the mother does not really want to see her son grow up because he is going to get hurt a lot in his lifetime. This is a very selfish act as he would be even more hurt if she killed herself.

Join now!

Secondly in “Upon my Son” the poet, Ana Bradstreet, uses a triadic structure to emphasise how much she wanted the child. ‘The son of prayers’ of vows of tears’ the use of repetition enforces the desperation and pleading she did to get her child. She may have been desperate for her child but this, unfortunately, does not show that she loves him. However in “Nettles” the writer uses a semi-colon. ‘Behind the shed’, this make the reader pause before the next line therefore the reader takes a breadth highlighting that the father has just realised that he may not be ...

This is a preview of the whole essay