• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare how the authors present and use the concept of the island setting in the extract from 'Robinson Crusoe' and 'Lord of the Flies' (particularly chapters 1-3).

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Alexandra Kennedy. November 2002 Compare how the authors present and use the concept of the island setting in the extract from 'Robinson Crusoe' and 'Lord of the Flies' (particularly chapters 1-3) William Golding's 'Lord of the Flies' is a novel about good and evil, along with innocence and experience within society. Golding uses the boys' innocence, and gives them time on the island to gain experience, then shows us how people react and change if they are left fully to their own devices. Daniel Defoe's 'Robinson Crusoe' shows that you have to have a strong sense of belief in something to make anything work. Both authors, writing at different times, reflect situations and actions they are familiar with to enhance their novels. 'Lord of the Flies' is a novel which may lead you to believe one thing, and then leads you in a totally different direction to explain it is, in fact the opposite. "Perspectives of palm and beach water drew to a point near infinity". This is a good example of how Golding leads the reader to believe and imagine one thing, while he means something different. The description leads you to believe the island is like a paradise, it is difficult to imagine how a paradise could change so dramatically. He shows that you have to look farther than the surface to understand and grasp the truth. Golding uses the island to show that you have to look at the whole picture to understand what is happening. You have to see the good and the evil in everything in order to make sense of it. 'Robinson Crusoe', written in the first person allows the reader to empathise and understand the character. By using the first person Defoe can show exactly how Crusoe is feeling, it also makes Crusoe seem more isolated; the use of the first person promotes the isolation Defoe wants the island and Crusoe to feel. ...read more.

Middle

Crusoe uses a practical destination for his camp rather than a lazy, fearless place, like the boys. The boys waste the few resources they have. When they set fire to the top of the island, they destroy the island in an act of laziness. The boys aren't committed to making their society work. Some of them are lazy and care about having fun more than being rescued. The hunters seem only interested in bringing food to show their strength and in attempt to belittle someone else. The boys seek pleasure at the beginning in having the power to punish rule breakers, "We'll have rules! Lots of rules! Then anyone who breaks them-" "Whee-oh" Here the only reason the boys seem to want to punish anyone is so they can have fun having authority. They don't seem bothered about the principle of rule breaking, or the problems it may cause. Island life was very different for the boys, than their previous lives. They have all been thrown together into a very bizarre situation. Stuck on an island, they had no civilising influences like teachers or parents. We can see this when the boys are throwing stones and destroying a perfectly adequate habitat. No one is there to control their actions, and it isn't surprising that later in the novel conflicts between different characters occur. Such an intense situation brings out people's inner feelings and instinctive behaviour. The boys' now primitive existence allows them to do whatever they want. They can be whoever they want to be. When the hunters dress themselves up and paint their faces, we see them create what they see as a license to kill. They disguise themselves with the face paints and become barbaric, using the disguise as an excuse for this. The boys show little remorse about brutally killing the animals on the island, whereas Crusoe feels bad about this act of survival. ...read more.

Conclusion

In conclusion I feel that 'Lord of the Flies' uses the island to help the story and to develop the plot more than 'Robinson Crusoe'. I feel that a modern audience would react better to 'Lord of the Flies' and the messages within the novel than 'Robinson Crusoe'. Although 'Robinson Crusoe' would be impossible without an island I believe many modern readers would find it difficult to empathise with a lonesome man on an island, attempting to impress God. While Defoe's island is portrayed as penitence it is difficult to understand, within today's culture, why God forces repentance upon Crusoe. The characters in 'Lord of the Flies' are easier to empathise with for a modern audience because people can relate to good and evil. The islands help to create the correct atmospheres for both the novels; the description of the islands allow the reader to see what they want to see and offers them the freedom to make their own assumptions and additions to the novels. The genre of 'Robinson Crusoe' is similar to the original adventure genre of 'Lord of the Flies'. Golding however, twists his adventure genre into a sinister adventure story and a physiological study of the behaviour of boys in an extreme situation. Golding's adaptation of the genre allows the reader to see the different elements of the book and the significance of the island setting. Defoe tries to teach the reader about religious morals. It is instructional whereas 'Lord of the Flies' allows the reader more freedom to make their own conceptions. I feel Golding presents and uses the concept of the island setting the most effectively because 'Lord of the Flies' is more descriptive of the island and the island play a more significant role in the plot of the novel than the island in 'Robinson Crusoe'. Our knowledge of Defoe's island is limited compared with that of Golding's. Golding allows us to explore all the different areas and environments of the island whereas Defoe restricts the reader to a small section of his island setting, suggesting the island is less significant in 'Robinson Crusoe'. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE William Golding section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE William Golding essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Compare and contrast Defoe's Robinson Crusoe with Golding's Lord of the Flies.

    4 star(s)

    The gradual control of the seas, the establishment of trading posts in exotic lands, and the policy of taking overseas territories as booty from successful wars enabled Britain to gain commercial benefits and to build the world's largest empire. Inside Britain, the Industrial Revolution was under way.

  2. Analysis of Lord of the Flies.

    As they argue, each boy tries to give voice to his most basic conception of human purpose, as Ralph advocates building huts and Jack champions hunting. Ralph, who thinks about the overall good of the group, deems hunting frivolous; Jack, drawn to the exhilaration of hunting by his bloodlust and

  1. Lord Of The Flies and Robinson Crusoe - A Comparison

    However, when the cannibals came, he had to defend himself, using the guns and gunpowder he had also salvaged from the wreck. There is a similarity here because the boys had to defend their island from the beast but didn't have any guns, so made spears from wood they found.

  2. Ralph is changed by his experiences on the island. How does Golding show this?

    Early on he and Piggy discover a conch, which is blown to attract the others; this is the first moment when we are able to appreciate the difference in character. Piggy sees it and realises it is "ever so valuable" and has a knowledge of such things from his childhood,

  1. How do the boys organise themselves in chapters 1 & 2 of "Lord of ...

    (Page 21) "S'right, It's a shell! I seen one like that before. On someone's back wall. A conch he called it. He used to blow it and then his mum would come. It's ever so valuable." The finding of the conch is a very important event in the book and

  2. How does William Golding present aspects of human nature in the first four chapters ...

    Are they really so responsible after all, or do they just act childish to have fun and hold meetings when they feel there are problems? Maybe they just like to suit themselves as children normally do. In chapter three; "Huts on the Beach" it shows us the two totally different personalities of Jack and Ralph.

  1. Comment on the role of nature in Chapters 1 to 5 of Lord ...

    the time in "Lord of the Flies" play a major role in representing the attitudes, behavior and mood of the boys throughout the novel, affecting the readers? response. The weather foreshadows evil. At the beginning of the story, the boys crash on the island during a storm, ?That storm dragged

  2. How Does Golding Use The Island As A Character In Lord Of The Flies?

    Lifting the conch, ?sends a sudden breeze that scatters light? this is full of meaning and reflects the democracy over the platform and within us all.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work