• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare how the opening scene of Romeo and Juliet is portrayed in Luhrmanns 1997 film and Zefferelis 1968 version, which version is more successful?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare how the opening scene of Romeo and Juliet is portrayed in Luhrmanns 1997 film and Zefferelis 1968 version, which version is more successful? The purpose of the opening scene in many of Shakespeare's plays was to settle and involve the audience. The audience would be standing and would need a good opening scene to keep their attention from straying. For example in Shakespeare's Macbeth the opening scene is three witches which would almost certainly grab and involve the audience as witches were very controversial and feared of in the 17th century. The prologue is another way in which Shakespeare attracted the audiences attention. The prologue which summarizes the play makes the audience want to see more. In both film versions of Romeo and Juliet the prologues adapt to their audience. In the Zeffereli version the prologue is a slow rendition. It is read like a fairytale and lulls the audience in to a full sense of security. This would settle the audience. In the Luhrmann version the prologue is interpreted in three different ways. The first is a news broadcast which shows the importance of the feud. ...read more.

Middle

While in Luhrmanns scene the camera moves dramatically between fighters, not showing all the fighting at once but close up on each character individually, their faces, guns or reactions. Zefferelis fight scene is more like an enormous brawl, lots of people join in as the scene develops, involving a longer build up and the arena for the fight is vast. When the fight starts the camera stays as a long shot. The fighting is very fast with little groups of Capulets fighting little groups of Montegues spread across the town square. Only one person is killed in this version. There is less dramatic tension in Zefferelis version because the fight is a shorter traditional fight. The fight with swords is close, hectic and skilful, the clashing of the swords add to the dramatic affect. There are twenty or more people involved in the close physical combat of sword fight. In contrast Luhrmanns account of the fighting is choreographed intensely to make it fast, which is emphasized by the operatic music and the quick editing. There are lots of almost dance like movements; it imitates the swords in Zefferelis version the word sword is even written on the guns. ...read more.

Conclusion

After that there is no more music but there are lots of loud voices and animals to show the busy market place. Loud bell chimes create chaos during the fight. I don't think the music is successfully used in this film; it doesn't give it an edge like Luhrmanns version. At the start and during the prologue the music is operatic with voices over the orchestra that seems old fashioned yet modern. The music tells the viewer that something dramatic is going to happen and when the music crescendos the fight starts. The gunshots are synthesised and loud for dramatic effect. The music is loud and stops abruptly as the fight stops. Zefferelis version is successful because it's a good historical film, as it was set in Verona in the 17th century- when Shakespeare set the original play, but I don't think the opening scene served the purpose Shakespeare's play would have- it wasn't very gripping for me. So I think Luhrmanns version is more successful. It appealed to me because it has a contemporary setting which makes it easier to relate to. I think Luhrmanns version is more successful because it's aimed at a modern audience and portrays the universal themes of love and violence in current culture rather than in a historical setting. Sonia 11E ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. How successful is Baz Luhrmann's adaptation of Romeo and Juliet in Representing William Shakespeare's ...

    Also, the taking of hallucinogenic drugs and the drag act appear convincingly with the original dialogue as they were always supposed to be there. The guns are inscribed with the names sword or dagger, so when asked to "draw thy sword" they stay cleverly true to the Shakespearean dialogue.

  2. Baz Luhrmann's Romeo and Juliet.

    A gas station is much like a town square as it's used as a meeting, central point where people cross over each other. This makes it clear to the audience that the film isn't a copy of Shakespeare's 'Romeo and Juliet' but Baz Luhrmann's modern day interpretation.

  1. Analysis of Baz Luhrmann's romeo and juliet

    When the camera zooms up on something like this it helps the audience to make connections. The whole point in zooming up on Tybalt and Benvolio's faces is so the audience will realise that they are both important characters. An example of a mid angle shot is when Tybalt pulls

  2. Baz Luhrmann's 'Romeo and Juliet': Cinematography

    Juliet will be unable to understand that their relationship would be futile under the circumstances, as we later find out, and I believe that the water represents purity and innocence, her own misunderstanding of the degree of violence between the Capulets and Montagues.

  1. In Luhrmann's version of Romeo and Juliet, the commencement of the Capulet Ball is ...

    Romeo he is melancholy, lonely and nursing a broken heart over another love, Rosaline. However, when Romeo later meets Juliet at the Capulet Masque Ball he is transformed from a lovesick, moody teenager to a young man driven with over-whelming love.

  2. Romeo and Juliet - a simplified version of the classic love story by Charles ...

    "O Romeo, Romeo!" said she, "wherefore art thou Romeo? Deny thy father and refuse thy name, for my sake; or if thou wilt not, be but my sworn love, and I no longer will be a Capulet." Romeo, having this encouragement, would fain have spoken, but he was desirous of

  1. Discuss Baz Luhrmann's depiction of the characters in the opening scene of the 1996 ...

    However, Benvolio is seen as the peace-maker in this scene, as does not want to fight Tybalt. "I do but keep the peace" were Benvolio's words. Here, Tybalt talks of the word "peace" and says "I hate the word", which he then realtes towards his hatredness of "hell, all Montagues, and thee", referring to Benvolio.

  2. Comparing how Themes are represented in Baz Luhrmann's Production of Romeo and Juliet and ...

    suggest the suicide is more to do with desperation than love, suggesting love is more dominant in Luhrmann?s film. Shakespeare also links death to love, by linking the banquet where Romeo and Juliet fall in love to the death scene.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work