Compare how the strength of feeling is built up in both “ The Barn” and Midterm Break”

Authors Avatar

Karim Auf

19-11-‏2002‏‏-‏

Compare how the strength of feeling is built up in both “ The Barn” and Midterm Break”

These two poems are very different yet very similar, the two poems have a strange bond holding them together although both have a different theme. This could be easily showed, both of them revolve around two of the strongest emotions in the world, which are fear and grief. One thing lots of people will notice that usually these feelings are associated with childhood especially fear. This does not mean that adults are never scared or they never grieve but it means that as people grow in size they also out grow many of their fears. With grief it is not the same because actually both children and adults have moments of grief and misery except they show it in different ways.

The titles are very misleading and especially “ Midterm break” because people usually associate happiness and joy with a midterm break. Also it could be referring to the heartbreak caused by the death of Heaney’s younger brother. The title is very clever it shows Heaney’s genius in poetry. “ the Barn” is a very straightforward title with little play on the words and very little feeling. People associate “ the barn” with animals and farms, this does not link to any feelings. When the reader first reads the title it will intrigue him and he will want to read it to answer questions like, what happens in the barn? Who is in the barn? Before reading the poem the reader has no sense of what the poem could be about other than a barn.

An obvious similarity is the structure and layout, both are written in three or four line stanzas very much like a nursery rhyme. Using such a layout  has two reasons, first it means that young children could understand it, so it is a very appropriate form. Also writing it in short nursery-rhyme stanzas are good for reflecting a child’s feelings, movements and memories. Also there is a shift between the stanzas although they flow very well into each other most of them are very different. For example the first stanza in “ Midterm Break” describes him waiting in school, the second describes his arrival at home and they go on like this, developing the theme and feelings. There is a very important shift in “ the Barn” it is in the setting, we suddenly move from the barn to the boys’ dreams and his own imagination. This is the reason why the third and fourth stanzas are split because of the huge shift between the both.

Join now!

The shift between the third and fourth stanza shows a contrast in Heany’s mental state while he is in bed. His dream (last two stanzas) resemble and reflect his fears. This shows that he did not overcome his fears yet, and that his subconscious cannot over come them either.

“ The Barn” gives a lot of detail about the settings

The floor was mouse-grey, smooth, chilly concrete.

There were no windows, just two narrow shafts

This gives the reader quite a vivid image of the barn, also the description would make you feel like you are ...

This is a preview of the whole essay