The relationship between Jennings and her grandmother is clearly weak. This is evident as she “refused to go out with her” because she was “afraid” to go out with her, as she feared her grandmother would treat her the same way she treated antique objects. This also indicates that the bond between them was not strong because she bluntly ‘refused’ to go out with her, showing her decisiveness. The same distance between the author and family can be seen in Long Distance as Harrison manages to avoid the same emotional trap his father fell into, and only calls “the disconnected number” which shows the “Long Distance” between him and his parents. It is also ironic because he fell into the same predicament as his father, almost in denial that his parents were gone. Although Harrison keeps his distance from his parents, he still is connected with his father and has a good relationship; however, no sign of a relationship is apparent with Jennings and her grandmother.
In addition, Jennings also uses words such as “long narrow room” to create a negative imagery of death. This quote has an ambiguous meaning to it, one being the room in which her grandmother put “All her best things” in. The quote could also refer to a coffin, and it also tells the reader that the grandmother’s death is soon to follow. The use of imagery is quite opposite in the first stanza of Harrison’s poem when he first mentions death. While referring to his father’s obsession, he uses words such as “warming” and “hot water bottle” so that the reader is not too affected by the negative use of death, while giving the poem a story and a feeling that makes the reader want to carry on reading. This creates a positive atmosphere to lighten the situation. However, by the time we reach the end of the poem, Harrison changes the mood and it becomes sad and depressing with the use of words such as “alone” and “rusted lock” to show that not only was Harrison’s father lonely, but he had not left his house after the death of the mother because his father felt that he “knew she’d just popped out to get the tea”. The use of italics on “knew” shows his father’s absolute certainty of the fact but in reality, it only showed that he was in a state of denial and desperation for the mother. Harrison also creates a depressing atmosphere by describing his new phone book “black”, the colour to signify death.
Elizabeth Jennings’ poems often focused on the difficult personal experiences of her life. She suffered mental breakdown by the age of forty, and recovered by writing poems based on many themes. Family, suffering and loneliness are some of the main themes in ‘My Grandmother’. Her sad, depressing life is reflected in the poem through the life of her grandmother, as she would often watch “her own reflection in the brass” showing that she was lonely, and received no business. Harrison grew up in Leeds, and there are some examples in the poem that show his Yorkshire dialect. Aside from the rhyming of “gas” and “pass”, another example is the use of “popped out” which is a colloquial use of language in Yorkshire. . He also grew up in a working-class childhood which is evident because he uses colloquial language such as “dad” to refer to his father. This could also show that Harrison had a better relationship to his father than Jennings did to her grandmother, as Jennings quite simply calls her “My Grandmother” and not names such as “Gran” or “Grandma” which would show that the child has a strong relationship with their grandparent.
The use of language in ‘My Grandmother’ creates a sad and depressing atmosphere. Jennings uses words such as “old” and “frail” to describe the vulnerability of her grandmother. She also uses dark, mysterious words like “shadows” and “absences” which also create negative imagery in the readers’ minds.
The rhyme scheme in Long Distance follows ABAB for the first 3 stanzas and ABBA for the last. The first three talk about his past and we learn about his emotional state, while the final stanza concludes that he suffers from the same dilemma as his father. The rhyme scheme of My Grandmother is ABABCC and has 4 stanzas, starting by setting the scene, then becoming personal in the next stanza with her regret and guilt, while the last two talk about the retirement & the death of her grandmother.
Throughout ‘Long Distance’ Harrison tells the story of how his father was obsessed with his deceased mother. Harrison then becomes obsessed after his father’s death which shows the irony as he becomes the same man he used to describe his father. Even though both his parents had passed away, he still kept their numbers which he “still calls”. This shows that he has become just like his father, and the use of “new black leather phone book” creates a sad mood as ‘black’ is associated with death, and also creates a sense of pathos in the reader, as we feel sorry for Harrison for falling into the same emotional state. The irony is also evident in ‘My Grandmother’ as Jennings felt guilty when she “once refused” to go out with her, however she based her whole poem on her grandmother, perhaps showing that somehow, she did have some attachment to her. However, unlike Harrison, she does not fall into the same emotional trap as she “felt no grief at all” when she died. The use of “no” and “at all” adds conviction to her statement, as if it was her final decision.
In conclusion, the themes of family and death linked in both poems. Each poem is about a family member who died, and how they felt after. The authors also include similar emotions, such as obsession, however the obsession is focused on different topics. They also share the same feelings towards the members of their family because both authors stayed distanced from them; however it could also be argued that Harrison still felt a slight obsession to the “disconnected number” of his parents. The difference between the authors’ is that they have different views towards death. Harrison clearly states he “believes life ends with death” perhaps showing us that he is an atheist. In contrast, Jennings is not an atheist, as many of her poems talk about religious experiences. Because of the points above, I believe that both these poems shared similar views on family and death, but they were expressed in different ways.
Word Count: 1500