• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the beginning of the novel and Sinise’s film version “Of Mice and Men”

Extracts from this document...


Philip Errington Media Assignment Compare the beginning of the novel and Sinise's film version "Of Mice and Men" The opening of the novel and the film differ from each other in many ways. The film has a tense and dramatic start where as the novel is set in a quiet and peaceful woodland area as Steinbeck sets the scene in clear detail. The film opens with a haunting, chilling melody lingering in the background of a black screen with white credits appearing for several minutes. Sinise puts the credits at the beginning rather than at the end so that he adds to the drama at the beginning and doesn't ruin the ending with them. As the music fades the black background remains with the occasional, faint beam of moonlight, streaming through the open cracks in the wagon of a train. The camera shot focuses on a lonely figure, crouched in the corner, looking by the expression on his face as if he has the weight of the world on his shoulders, as the frequent train whistles drown out his thoughts. This makes the audience curious about who the man is, which makes them want to watch on to find out the identity of this mysterious character. ...read more.


The camera focuses on them for several seconds to emphasise this aspect of their relationship and to show how close the two men are. In the novel the two men are not in the water when they cuddle and there is no indication that George is bigger than Lennie. They are both on the banks near to the water. Sinise just adds this part in to the film to make it look as if Lennie has just fallen over emphasising his helplessness. In the novel Lennie asks George to tell him the story of 'how it is gonna be', and after several attempts George shoots him in the head and helps him die painlessly and with a certain amount of dignity. At the sound of the shot the men appear and surround George. They think there has been a struggle and George has shot Lennie in self-defence, only Slim realises what has really happened. Although George is left all alone there is the possibility that Slim and he will develop a closer friendship. Many changes were made from this original ending in the film version. When George was telling Lennie the story of 'how it was gonna be' he shoots him first time after Lennie says "and I get to tend the rabbits". ...read more.


This results in her need to lust for the other men on the ranch, as this may be her only chance to find the happiness she secretly yearns for. This tone that she speaks to people in is exempt from many parts of the film as the director tries to make the audience feel sorry for her, whilst in the novel you are made to think that she deserved to be killed due to the way she threatened Crooks. I feel Sinise did this to make you feel sorry for her when she dies and to bring George's killing of Lennie into a deeper prospective. The age of Curley's wife also differs in both the novel and the film. In the novel Curley's wife is merely the tender age of fifteen/sixteen, whilst in the film she is portrayed as a much older and more mature age. My personal favourite between the novel and the film, is the novel as it is an epic and thrilling read. I think that the film version is very emotional, and the director Sinise portrays the novel in a different way, although the detail and description of the film can never compare with the original novel. You will find that in most cases the film cannot reproduce the same empathy and imagination used when the author first creates their masterpiece. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Steinbeck section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Steinbeck essays

  1. Prejudice Within The Novel Of Mice And Men.

    The quotation, "He's a nice fella,' said Slim. Guy don't need no sense to be a nice fella." This shows that although the workers realise that he is not on the same level mentally he is generally seen as a nice person that could not do any harm, just like a child.

  2. A comparison of John Steinbeck's novel 'Of Mice and Men' and the 1939 film ...

    They both focus on it enough for it to be emotive, but the technique is to focus on the emotions on Candy. The next scene is the fight scene between Curley and Lennie after Curley enters their bunk and fights with Lennie because "he doesn't like big guys".

  1. Compare the way that Charlotte Bronte and John Steinbeck show the theme of friendship ...

    Jane and Helen are seen as sisters, isolation has led them to become closer to each other. George and Lennie's friendship strengthens by the way that Lennie depends on and trusts George completely. They become so close that George is devastated when Lennie's death separates them.

  2. Discuss the theme of isolation and loneliness with reference to the characters in “Of ...

    He lets Lennie in though because he won't go away and starts talking 'at' him. Crooks has lots of possessions in his room, especially books, he had so much time to himself that he just read. We also see that Curley's wife discriminates against Crooks because of his colour.

  1. Analyse both the beginning and ending of Steinbeck's novel with the opening and closing ...

    His friend was the complete opposite '..., a huge man, shapeless of face, with large, pale eyes, with wide sloping shoulders; and he walked heavily, dragging his feet a little, the way a bear drags his paws.' The way he has described the way he walks shows his strength.

  2. Compare Steinbeck's novel with the1992 film version of 'Of Mice and Men'. In your ...

    been beaten hard by boys which mazes its way through the Willows and the sycamores. Just in front of the 'low horizontal limb of a giant Sycamore' there is a pile of ashes, which have been made by many fires.

  1. Is the film version of 'Of Mice and Men' inferior to the original novel.

    In the novel Curley's wife and Curley are never seen together, they are always looking for each other, the incident with Crooks is not included. In the film Curley's wife does not have red mules, and is not heavily made up, she is wearing white and pink this gives her

  2. Describe and comment upon the film "Of Mice and Men" (biased on the novel ...

    We first see what Lennie is really like when George and Lennie are in the train. George is mad at Lennie and Lennie does not realize that. From Lennie's ideas, voices and movement we can see he is like a grown up child.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work