• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the characters of Mr. Grycefrom Barry Hines''Kestrel for a knave' and Mr. Squeers from Charles Dickens' 'Nicholas Nickelby'.

Extracts from this document...


Sean Martin Compare the characters of Mr. Gryce from Barry Hines' 'Kestrel for a knave' and Mr. Squeers from Charles Dickens' 'Nicholas Nickelby' During the course of this essay I will be comparing the teaching methods, school conditions and general demeanor of Mr. Gryce, a secondary school headmaster in the 1960's, and Mr. Squeers who controls a boarding school for disabled and unfortunate children in the 1830's. Both schools are set in Yorkshire. Mr. Gryce is an experienced teacher with 35 years in his profession, although he is seen as a well experienced teacher he is also at or past the suggested retirement age, and some would consider him unfit for the demanding job. In all schools throughout the world the main point in attending is to receive an education, but Mr. Gryces' is different. The reason for going to his school is to learn four things, 'Discipline, decency, morals and manners.' On the other hand, Mr. Squeers had no teaching experience before he started running his boarding school. The only reasons he started teaching were for the money and secondly the power that he could be sure of gaining even if he and his wife had to steal for it. ...read more.


Like Mr. Gryce he too has no respect for the pupils and also shows no intentions of listening to them. His love of money is sometimes inhuman, 'The worthy lad pocketed the eighteen pence with a most business like air.' The eighteen pence was a child's pocket money, which he ordered his wife to take. Not only is he a thief, but also he has no respect for any human, dead or alive. 'Oh said Squeers, Cobbey's grandmother is dead, and his uncle John has took to drinking.' Any human with a slight sense of respect would have at least tried to show some sympathy towards the boy, but with Squeers basic need for money and power this does not fit into his life. Squeers' 'practical mode of teaching' is laughable, we are told that his teaching experience is little, but if he is to build up a decent reputation then he should at least be able to spell window, 'W I N win D E R winder.' After he has taught the boys to spell a word incorrectly, he then makes his case for being a bad teacher go from bad to worse, he makes a pupils clean a window, once again saving him money and giving him power over that pupil. ...read more.


the government became aware of it to. Soon after the tripartite system changed to the comprehensive system of today. The comprehensive system is there to give all pupils equal opportunities; Barry Hines was trying to say that a person's life should not depend on the result of an exam taken at the age of eleven. Barry Hines succeeded. Charles Dickens, the author of 'Nicholas Nickelby' wanted a complete reform on education. He knew what a shambles it was. With his newspaper articles which the book started of as, he raised awareness to many people, more often than not educated people, that the system was badly run and that people like Mr. Squeers and places like Dotheboys Hall do actually exist. He was believed to have based the story on a newspaper article he had read were the guilty man was trailed from similar circumstances to Mr. Squeers. Many years after Mr. Dickens brought this major fault to peoples attention others started pointing it out to, and on the year of his death, his aim was achieved. In 1870 the Education Reform Act was put into place to stop criminals like Squeers from being in the education system. Charles Dickens also achieved his aim. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Barry Hines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Barry Hines essays

  1. Comparisons between A Kestrel For A Knave and David Copperfield.

    I think Hines does this to add comedy to the novel and to lighten the mood after the drudgery of Mr Gryce. Yet, Sugden is similar to Gryce in the way that he treats Billy. After the match, which he blames Billy for losing, he gets his revenge.

  2. Kes affected Billy's life in many ways, for good and for bad

    "Well then, you get paid don't you?" "Yes Sir. But I have to gi' it to me mum. I'm still paying her for my court fines, like instalments every week." Even though Billy is in trouble for not bringing his kit; it still shows that he is responsible for paying his fines.


    In the playground, MacDowall, another student, tries to bully Billy by insulting his mother but Billy defends himself and is supported by Mr Farthing. He bullies the bully back to show him how it feels to be bullied. Mr Farthing is a different kind of teacher he actually listens to what Billy has to say.

  2. Compare the ways the Education system is depicted in "HardTimes" by Charles Dickens and ...

    Gryce's system is one of failure, the boys have failed their 11+ and therefore will be subjected to an education lacking in opportunity and a life of manual work. Gryce talks at the pupils rather than to them as their opinion is not valued and they rarely have a chance to explain themselves.

  1. In Kestrel For A Knave, Hines presents most of Billy's schooling, and his teachers ...

    During school, Billy refuses to participate willingly and is uninterested in work. But Hines shows us during Billy's exploits out of school that he has the aptitude to learn and the ability to demonstrate his know how. He uses his own time, researching Falconry and reading books, to acquire as

  2. How Are The Relationships Between Teachers And Pupils Presented In Chapter 8 Of 'Whispers ...

    The two quotes above show that Billy is being verbally abused and proves that Sugden thinks he's too thick for his age. It's quite an insult actually. The second quote shows that Sugden is picking on Billy while Billy's struggling to keep warm.

  1. Investigate the ways in which Barry Hines explores Billy's life in 'A Kestrel for ...

    I feel sorry for Billy as its not only his mother who takes out her anger on him. Jud is very violent towards Billy throughout the story and there is never any brotherly love shown between them. I believe that one of the reasons why Jud behaviours the way he

  2. How does Billy's tall story in "A Kestrel For A Knave" and "The Poor ...

    Throughout the book Jud aims allsorts of taunts and jeers in the direction of Billy. This particular one after Jud sees that Billy has 'obtained' a book on Falconry "What's tha want that for when tha can't read?" - Jud Billy's mother is no better either.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work