• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the differing views on love from the poems 'A Woman To Her Lover', by Christina Walsh, and 'When We Two Parted', by Lord Byron

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The poems 'A Woman To Her Lover', by Christina Walsh, and 'When We Two Parted', by Lord Byron, both deal with the subject of love. However each poem portrays a completely different view of love, confronting and challenging the issues raised. Both poets endeavour to leave a lasting impression on the reader and a particular person who is, or was, close to their heart. Therefore, the construction of the poem is vital. The meaning of AWTL is powerfully conveyed through the poem's structure. Walsh has assembled a potent argument, trying to persuade her lover to see her in a certain light. The first three stansas use negative imagery to of a slave, an angel around the house and an object of sexual desire, all of which are unpleasant stereotypes of women. The final stansa reveals her terms for a happy future. This construction allows the argument to be built up until the climax after the turning point of the poem. Giving the bad news first means that in contrast the good news seems even better. WWTP is similarly four stansas long, although it was originally five because the stansa removed was seen as inappropriate because it named an ex-lover. Byron is not trying to construct an argument, instead he is either trying to convey his grief and confusion of losing a loved one or make his ex-lover feel guilty. ...read more.

Middle

Walsh, whom we presume is the woman, clearly does not want to be a 'bondslave' or 'servant' to her lover. She does not feel that marriage should be hard work carried out 'In drugery and silence', expressing feminist views against this perception of women as a man's personal slave. Walsh then moves to another extreme in the second stansa, again rebuking sexism and negative stereotypes of married women, at the end remarking 'If that be what you ask, fool, I refuse you'. She shows her free spirit once again while confirming that she is not a 'wingless angel' who desires to be sat upon a pedestal and worshipped. God-like imagery, such as 'heaven sent', 'golden' and 'worship', is used to reinforce this idea. Finally, Walsh states that she does not want to become her lover's object for sex. She uses vaguely sexual imagery such as 'clamourous desire' and her body being supple for his 'sense delight'. Women are not made for men's physical pleasure; if this is the opinion of her lover he will never become her husband and deserves no woman - 'Not for you the hand of any wakened woman of our time' The imagery of the final stansa is in the same semantic field. It portrays equality through comradeship, living and working, loving and dying together. ...read more.

Conclusion

I think WWTP is an effective poem. While reading it I certainly pitied Byron in having to suffer alone. It must be difficult to regret what happened and yet feel so upset that he believes that if they meet again, it might be in the same way that they parted. This poem could be seen by some as a comfort, that other people have done and do suffer in similar ways. Knowing Byron's "Bohemian" lifestyle, and how he presumably recuperated from his loss, there is a light at the end of the tunnel. I find Byron's account of love depressing, as it suggests no love is forever and one has to get over loss. Therefore, I prefer AWTHL. I like the imagery Walsh used and its importance to the construction of her argument. I was impressed that a woman of that period was standing up for her views and stating what she wanted from life and her man. She expresses these views effectively in her responses to the stereotypes of the first three stansas. Dealing with the subject of love in a positive light and asking for equality to ensure a happy marriage makes her argument appear extremely reasonable. I like the way that the meter in WWTP allows the poem to be read easily, but overall I find Walsh's poem is much more encouraging and necessary as it can give men an insight into how women feel! Meter - metre Stansa - stanza ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Love Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Love Poetry essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Comparison Of Love Poetry:Remember by Christina Rossetti, How Do I Love Thee? by Elizabeth ...

    4 star(s)

    Furthermore, vocabulary you would usually associate with loss are used to describe the failings of the partnership such as 'grieve' and the "knell to mine ear". Similarly in Remember the imminent departure of Christina Rossetti invites the use of deathlike language to make sure the reader knows that she is leaving this world for the 'silent land'.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    I think that although the 'First Love' and 'When We Two Parted' are different ...

    3 star(s)

    It is used to explain that their love would never again be rekindled. Alliteration is used solely to emphasise the cruel deception the writer felt. In 'First Love' John Clare uses alliteration too. He uses it to pin-point feelings, and to relate to the reader, 'And blood burnt round my heart'.

  1. I have been analysing several poems recently they are: When We Two Parted by ...

    This may be because he can't let people know he knows her, or because he thinks he can't talk to her anymore. Ironic lines are used as they are the same as the opening lines but for completely different reasons.

  2. Compare the language and form used to express lost love in 'La Belle Dame ...

    the stanzas: '...sedge wither'd from the lake,' This is repeated in the last line, along with: 'and no birds sing' these open and close the poem, this is very effective for the tone and also the mood of the poem, as the narrator, who is talking to a 'knight at-arms',

  1. Examine and compare the views of love in three Shakespearean sonnets

    Love is not at the mercy of Time, though its rosy lips and cheeks Come within the compass of his sickle. Love does not alter with hours and weeks, But, rather, it endures until the last day of life If I am proved wrong about these thoughts on love Then

  2. Analysis of 'A woman to her lover' by Christina Walsh

    'Woman' represents she is an early feminist in a male dominated society. The issue of rights for women first became prominent during the French and American revolutions in the late 18th century. In Britain it was not until the emergence of the suffragette movement in the late 19th century that there was significant political change.

  1. Love and Loss

    The third stanza in "When We Two Parted" tells about his feelings when he hears her name. In the first line he says "thy vows are all broken" indicating to the reader that she has broken all of her promises to him and that he has been let down by her.

  2. Love & Loss - analyse and compare two different love and loss poems written ...

    This sonnet also describes how normal and down to earth his mistress is, which is odd, especially during the Elizabethan and Victorian era when women were unrealistically idealized in poetry. The ordinary beauty and humanity of his lover are important to Shakespeare in this sonnet, and he deliberately uses stereotypical love poetry metaphors against themselves.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work