• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the opening scenes from two versions of great expectations. Which version do you think is most effective for the audience?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare the opening scenes from two versions of great expectations. Which version do you think is most effective for the audience? Consider; chapter 1 from the novel Camera work Dickens, one of the best novelists of all time wrote many books campaigning for social justice and work was filmed many times as he was a very famous actor. Making a film like this would require much thought and there are many problems a Director would face for example the setting of the movie and what people expect from characters like expressions and speech. That's also true in films like Harry Potter, Lord of The Rings etc. where the Director has had to try and portray characters who are familiar to the people from the book in to the movie or maybe keep it simple or add touches of special effects. The first Great Expectations I saw was in black and white and was made in 1946 at about Christmas time. Surprisingly colour was available at the time but the director, David Lean chose to work in black & white. ...read more.

Middle

Magwitch leaves Pip, who runs back to the forge and the camera moves from the desolate marshland to a creepy house in the middle of nowhere and then leaving the viewers with a sense of sadness, the opening ends. The other opening we saw was made in 1999- half a century apart. It was directed by Julian Jarrold and was supposed to be for TV in about hour-long episodes. This gave the director a lot more time to reveal and unfold the plot. It opens with views of the English cornfields, contradicting with the opening of Dickens's Novel which was supposed to be Christmas time. Then slowly we get a sight of Pip who looks around confused about something and then sets off on a scary run. All this time, the camera has become the pursuer and as it transforms into a slow motion run you catch the child's fear and terror before he enters the graveyard. Compared to the first clip, this one makes no connection that he is in a graveyard and it seems like it's just some props which have been put up as it's in the middle of some cornfields and we see no sign of a church like in the first opening or any other graveyard. ...read more.

Conclusion

After that Pip wakes up from his 'nightmare' and the short clip ends. From reading chapter 1 from the novel and with the points stated, I think that the colour version is a better one. If we wanted to go by the novel, then David Lean's version is perfect for that as it gives us perfect views of the marshes with the gibbets and a bleak place with nettles as a graveyard which is how Pip described it in the novel. Also, Magwitch's speech and characterisation is the same as you would have imagined in the book with all the background sounds and gothic effects. On the other hand though, the colour version with the help of great special effects gives you detailed moments of each scene especially with the camera tracking shots of Pip and the slow motion. Julian Jarrold also uses the artistic licence to great effect by making Pip scream at his mother's grave and putting the most parts of his experience with Magwitch as a sort of daydream by Pip. The B&W version makes it more atmospheric and gothic but the colour one which is a blend of tradition and modern technology makes it very easy to understand ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Great Expectations section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Great Expectations essays

  1. In this essay, my intent will be to compare two film adaptations of the ...

    This causes tension and fear for Pip amongst the audience. Tracking is used to follow Pip. The camera is hand-held. While the camera is hand-held, it is shaking very much. The more it shakes, the faster we think the person or thing is running.

  2. Great expectations - Which two settings in 'great expectations' did you find most effective?

    times he washes his hands this shows how he is trying to escape the corruption that was ripe in the courts at the time of writing this novel yet the smell of soap is a way of trying to taint him not to.

  1. The opening graveyard scene of Charles Dickens ' Great Expectations' has become part of ...

    sky suggests it gloomy, if you didn't use lighting it would make it harder to tell. Being in black and white some people say it looks boring but I think it creates a misty atmosphere that adds to build the tension.

  2. How do David Lean and Julian Jarrold use film techniques to influence the viewers ...

    Lean does this so that the reader can understand more of Pip's background, so that the opening scene is less confusing and they can have an idea of the character behind the terrified boy. This again could show that he is trying to be true to the novel, as it

  1. Who Or What Do You Think Has The Most Influence on Pip's Development And ...

    Pip learns a great deal of things from Herbert. In many ways, I believe Joe and Herbert are much alike, in making sure that Pip has both feet planted firmly on the ground. When Pip was a mere child, it was Joe who loved Pip and raised him as his

  2. How does Dickens create an effective opening chapter in Great expectations?

    Remembering this, the adult Pip says "I believe they were fat, though at the time I was undersized for my years and not string" This begins to give the reader an image of Pips physical appearance. The fact that he is undersized and weak could be because due to the lack of money in his family he is underfed.

  1. Compare the opening scenes of two film versions of Great Expectations and review how ...

    The idea of the story was also a good idea because a marsh land gives the mind a felling of something getting swallowed up. This might reflect Pips old life getting swallowed up. The atmosphere in the novel overall is tense and scary.

  2. Compare the opening scenes of the two film versions of Great Expectations and review ...

    Joes mean nature. Before Pip steals the food he hides in his bed, the covers pulled over his head, hearing the prisoners promise that if he didn't return with a file and whittles, he would get his so called 'friend' to eat his heart and liver.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work