• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the poems "Long distance" and "My Grandmother."

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Poetry Coursework Compare the poems "Long distance" and "My Grandmother." What impressions do the two poets give of the main characters in their poems? "Long distance" and "My Grandmother" are poems that explore the feelings and emotions of the main characters as a consequence of someone they knew dying. "Long distance" written by Tony Harrison describes the affect of death of a mother on the father. "My Grandmother" explores the relationship between the grandmother and speaker, focusing on the feelings between the grandmother and the speaker. Both these poems are interesting from the fact that the main characters can only be distinguished from personal perception. Consequently, the poets portray different impressions of the main characters. Initially, it can be argued that the main characters of the two poems, are the son and granddaughter from "Long distance" and "My Grandmother" respectively. The basis for this perception is that Tony Harrison utilised his poems to explore his working class childhood and family life. Also, Elizabeth Jennings exercised her poems to reflect the difficult personal experiences in her life. However, it can also be argued that the main characters of the two poems are the father and grandmother from "Long distance" and "My Grandmother" respectively. ...read more.

Middle

In the same way, in "Long distance" the father could not risk his sons "blight of disbelief," this signifies that the father became absorbed in preserving his wife's memories, unable to move on. In an analytical sense, this illustrates that the main characters both had obsessions that absorbed their lives, perhaps creating sympathy in the reader for them. Also, it appears that the grandmother and father do not need human company, as they attempt to preserve what is dear to them. This paints a desolate image of them to the reader, Furthermore, both the grandmother and father seem to be vulnerable at some point. In "My Grandmother" the grandmother becomes "too frail to keep a shop," this illustrates her susceptibility as she can no longer maintain her beloved possessions. Similarly, in "Long distance" could not risk the son's "blight of disbelief," this illustrates that the father's feelings were vulnerable and he does not want his son to shatter his hopes, ending his grief. Thus, the main characters draw sympathy from the reader due to their vulnerability, also making the reader more susceptible to the deaths in the poems. Additionally, the main characters experience loss in both poems that affect them emotionally. ...read more.

Conclusion

The word "knew" is written in italic and the sentence is almost sarcastic. This portrays the son's disapproval towards the father denial. Similarly, in "My Grandmother" the granddaughter "once refused to go out" with the grandmother and the grandmother's "wish was not to be used like antique objects." This shows that the granddaughter rejected the grandmother, because she disapproved of the way the grandmother treated everything a on a superficial level, like the antiques. The impression created of the son is that he could be inconsiderate towards his father feelings. The impression that is associated with the granddaughter is that she was "afraid," arousing sympathy and consideration in the reader. In conclusion, both poems follow individuals who cannot come to terms with something. In these two cases, it is guilt, in the poem "My Grandmother" and grief in the poem "Long distance." The different versions of main characters both ignite different impressions in the reader. Furthermore, the poems use a variation of different and similar themes to create a certain affect on the reader. Impressions of the main characters such as sympathy and callousness are exposed to the reader. Therefore, the poems can be perceived as a person's movement towards closure and the method in which they handle their suffering, creating different impressions as their struggle progresses. 1 Sharif. Mostafa ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Love Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Love Poetry essays

  1. Dover Beach and Prayer Before Birth - Explore the issues and ideas that both ...

    An example of a lengthened vowel sound used by Arnold is: 'moon-blanch'd land, withdrawing roar.' On the other hand, 'Prayer Before Birth,' has a much quicker, pacier movement which is conveyed by the structure. Whereas there is an evenness and natural rhythm to 'Dover Beach, 'Prayer Before Birth gradually increases in intensity.

  2. Compare Long Distance 1 and 2 by Tony Harrison, and My Grandmother by Elizabeth ...

    The first line is split into two short sentences, which gives the effect of grumpiness that Tony Harrison is trying to portray about his father. Tony Harrison's speech is written in normal writing, but the father's is colloquial. This represents how much Harrison has changed from his father.

  1. Analyse, Long Distance by Tony Harrison, I Shall Return and The Barrier both written ...

    The strong use of colour enables the reader to imagine quite easily the setting as well as McKays love for his homeland. The second quatrain, again describes the atmosphere but this time the setting. He describes how he would relax and what surroundings helped him achieve this feeling.

  2. comparison of the poems: "The sick equation" and "Long distance"

    In "The Sick Equation" Brian Patten personifies his house, as if it's an angry person. It is very predictable that his parents' bitterness and constant fights would affect him in the future. Brian Patten is particularly affected by his parents' incorrect up-bringing; we get the idea that he has no

  1. Analyse an Compare the themes of loss and isolation in Long Distance (Harrison), The ...

    The first concept i'm going to explore is the tone through out all three of the poems.The tone in Looking for Dad is generally guilt and more of confusion as the little boy in it thinks it all his fault that his mum and dad are arguing but its not.

  2. 'The Sick Equation' - Brian Pattern

    The well known phrase 'Home sweet home' gives the image of home as a blissful haven for people, however Pattern uses this phrase to show the irony of his home and how he was unhappy when he was there. Lines seven and eight show that the emotional pain in his

  1. Compare and analyse themes of loss and isolation in looking for dad and the ...

    up in divorce, which meant he was very lonely Throughout the poem, Patten expresses his anger by using strong words such as 'raw', 'hate' and 'pain'. He is angry at his parent's influence on him as it has left him a helpless man with no one to love.

  2. A poet claims that he wrote poems, "to preserve things" that he had seen, ...

    The meaning within the poem is the preservation of the sublime and of perfection. The persona in the poem is Kubla Khan, representing God, and his creation is "the stately pleasure dome" in "Xanadu", symbolic of God's Garden of Eden/Paradise.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work