• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the way in which two writers, from different centuries, adapt the genre of the ghost story. Comment on which you think is most successful and why.

Extracts from this document...


Compare the way in which two writers, from different centuries, adapt the genre of the ghost story. Comment on which you think is most successful and why. The two ghost stories "The Call" written by Robert Westall in 1989 and "The Superstitious mans story" written by Thomas Hardy in 1894, both create suspense and mystery to engage the reader's attention though they have been written in different centuries. When Westall wrote "The Call" in 1989-some 100 yrs after "The superstitious mans story" was written, society was much more doubtful about the truthfulness of the issue of ghosts and therefore the story would have to be more persuading over its realism. Ghost stories provide us with different ways of thinking about death and dying. They help us explore our uncertainties about the supernatural and whether there is any form of life after death. Ghost stories use our fear of death and the unknown to create suspense in the reader. ...read more.


In the call the first sign of oddness occurs when Harry Lancaster the Samaritan who is sick is determined to make his Christmas eve call, one in which he has made for decades on end without problem. This begs the question- why is he so eager to get there? "He tried dosing himself with all kinds of things; swore he was still coming. Was desperate to come", a complication arises when Meg answers the first call of the night from a lady "He's going to kill me. I know he's going to kill me" this is the first sign of death in the story, and this is important because death is a very typical ingredient of a ghost story. Before the first call both Meg and Geoff are happy and jolly because of it being Christmas Eve," It was just happiness", but after the call, the cold voice of the woman makes Meg and Geoff feel frightened in a way, "Meg put the phone down wearily, and suddenly shivered". ...read more.


The superstitious mans story ends with the death of William Pivette and the supposed sight of him dying at the same place where his son died. When William Pivette died a mill moth flew out of his mouth as to symbolize his soul escaping. The sight of William dieing at the same place as his son symbolizes him missing his son and wanting to be with him. From having read both stories very carefully I feel that "the call" by Robert Westall is better, it creates more suspense and mystery for the reader. "The call" also seems more genuine as it has modern day possessions mentioned in it for example the telephone, which created most of the drama. Both of the stories make the reader want to read on and learn more about the characters but the authors of both "the call" and "superstitious mans story" leave the readers guessing. The "superstitious mans story" seems too short to create much tension or suspense unlike "the call" which has modern day things like the telephone mentioned in it which creates plenty of tension. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE War Poetry essays

  1. Analyse and compare 'Remember', 'Up-hill' and 'Looking Back' by Christina Rossetti and 'Afterwards' by ...

    She is unsure of herself and her destination and so naturally her fear causes her to question so much. In 'Looking Back' she sees death as a time of reflection - a reflection of one's achievements and mistakes. She feels that it is the time for evaluation as it is the final thing left to do before parting away.


    Hence a counterattack meant to privilege the event, the actual instances rather than the laws that account for their formation. A still deeper rift results from the humanist's inability to translate the descriptive into the normative without the mediation of value judgments.

  1. Compare and contrast the ways in which writers present their attitudes to the First ...

    In the last stanza there is a direct appeal to the reader; 'Come along lads'. The language in general in this poem is quite informal. The poet uses colloquial words and phrases like 'Lads' and 'It won't be a picnic'.

  2. Quarry Bank Mill in Styal differed widely from other textiles mills in the area

    They were fined for things such as whistling, breaking windows or being late. At Styal fines were paid by children doing over time in their dinner breaks. A serious offence was to run away which caused a lot of inconvenience.

  1. In her short story

    The harshness of the weather reflects the harshness of the weather reflects the harshness occurring in her life. Her marriage to Preston is in one sense a good thing as she will now be able to provide for her son, Gregory.

  2. Show how the writer uses the form of poetry to protest against a situation ...

    Whereas Donne personifies Death Thomas does the opposite he describes death as "the dying of the light" and purposely seems to make death into something that people have no warm feelings for, night which is dark and unknown, a thought that is not at all comforting.

  1. Compare and contrast the way the poets portray people in ' a London fete' ...

    They took control of the dogs and praised them with claps, (Clapt the dogs), and then take the badger back to the village to show every one. 'And clapt the dogs and bore him to the town' The dogs were clapped to show that they have done well, and the badger was bore to town.

  2. Coursework Compare ‘Blackberry-Picking’ and ‘Death of a Naturalist’ By Seamus Heaney.

    This poem is trying to convey the feeling that when you are young you do not think that things will change but as you get older and you begin to fade you realize that nothing lasts. The 'Death of a Naturalist' is similar to the theme of 'Blackberry-Picking' because it

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work