• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12

Compare the Ways in which John Steinbeck and Thomas Hardy Explore the Theme of Loneliness in Of Mice and Men and The Withered Arm

Extracts from this document...


Compare the Ways in which John Steinbeck and Thomas Hardy Explore the Theme of Loneliness in Of Mice and Men and The Withered Arm The two books have one clear element in common. The two authors, Steinbeck and Hardy, give us a great outlook on loneliness in its many forms. They communicate their ideas and thoughts to us in a very similar manner, despite being from very different times and walks of life. Of Mice and Men, is set and was written during the Great Depression of the United States of America in the early 1930's, in the Salinas Valley of California, tells us the story of George Milton and Lennie Small. The two migrant workers, bound together by an unusual and sure friendship, are in pursuit together of the "Great" American Dream - their dream. They will have their own land, be their own masters and no longer have to answer to anyone, and finally live in peace. On the other hand we have The Withered Arm, set in the early 19th Century as one of Hardy's Wessex Tales, where he lived all his life. Hardy tells us the tale of a young woman, Gertrude Lodge, as she begins her new life. However, things are not what they should have been as Gertrude is afflicted with an unknown blight, her happiness both threatened and later destroyed. She is not completely alone - her plight is intertwined with that of Rhoda Brook, who carries a great pain in her heart and a great power, or perhaps a curse, that not even she realises. The two texts are each set in the same rural environment as that of their authors, both bringing us the tale of so many people struggling through their lives as best they can. In Of Mice and Men we see that every man, and woman, has their own dreams, their own obsessions to pine away for, to imagine and envisage when they are so often so lonely - each has their own thoughts, their method, of escapism from the reality they live in. ...read more.


are being dishevelled, the one thing she believes herself to truly hold is mishandled, and so she pulls away, expressing her distress. Lennie panics and does the only thing that his simple mind can think of - resist, and so he grips hold of her tighter, unwilling to let go, he is confused and frightened and understands nought of what is happening. He fears that if George were to find out that he had made someone unhappy and done wrong by them he would abandon and discard him, fearing disapproval if his actions were ever discovered; and so he clamps his hand over her mouth, hoping that none would hear the noise. He grips even tighter as she struggles all the more desperately in the pain that his awesome strength is causing her, and he jerks and shakes her body in response, in an attempt to silence her. In this he succeeds, but to an extent that he never intended - he unwittingly breaks her neck. Yet again Lennie has caused great harm without ever realising it possible, and this time the outcome is greatly worse. She was always alone, always without somebody, even those closest to her appear to have wished against her happiness; John Steinbeck signifies this to us by never naming Curley's wife - she was never important to the person, and the people, that she should have been. As soon as she finds someone that was conceivably different, perhaps wasn't like all the others, she takes it all too far too soon, without thinking of the consequences. As a result she loses everything. The story ends in the pursuit of Lennie, George goes after him with the other men for he cannot let them get to him first and it is here that we are reminded of Candy's words upon his own companion, his pet dog, "I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. ...read more.


His fear of disapproval forces him to take a life without ever intending to. It is upon George's shoulders to end the story, for there is only one possibility - he must end all his hopes, condemn himself to being alone with his guilt, every chance that they had together and those around them found upon their arrival for he must take Lennie's life to save him from misery. This pressure from American society and the unbending rules on what people should and shouldn't be causes so much dissatisfaction and unrest, leaving everyone feeling hopeless and alone, that they have been brought up to believe. They thought they had a chance, and they found nothing. The Withered Arm, on the other hand, is set in a world of tradition, of British society and its harsh social structure. In everyone's mind there is desperation to conform to the rules and agree that unless you are upper class, or in the case of the women - married, you are no one. Rhoda isolates herself from all others in her desperation to become someone, Farmer Lodge's wife, and be counted and in doing so sentences herself to a life of loneliness, and starts much more for many others. For Gertrude there is a desperation to be what the materialistic views of those around her tell her to be, and in her search for this she ends up isolating her self even more than before. The young son, who nobody ever really looks to care for, there is isolation of a different kind and through no fault of his own. His parents never truly acknowledge him as their son and this ultimately ends in his tragic death. For Farmer Lodge, it is his materialistic conformism that causes many problems, and he isolates himself from all others in this story until the end, where it is he and Rhoda left and doomed to each be utterly alone for their sins. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Steinbeck section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Steinbeck essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How is the theme of racism and loneliness shown through the character of Crooks ...

    3 star(s)

    of his character, but the reader knows that his unbeaten attitude is just an act, and that he has accepted the discrimination he is exposed to every day, because he confesses his loneliness and jealousy of the friendship between Lennie and George.

  2. How does Steinbeck present the relationship between George and Lennie in

    Contrasted to these two characters is Lennie, who almost seems a part of the natural world as he is described in animal farms. In fact, one of Lennie's dreams is to go and live by himself in a cave. Maybe this would be the only way in which the natural

  1. How does John Steinbeck present the theme of loneliness in his novel 'Of Mice ...

    I feel that Candy makes a very important quote when he gets over the murder of his dog this being 'I shouldn't ought to of let no stranger shoot my dog.' Candy has lived on the ranch for a long time and has also known the itinerant workers for a

  2. How does John Steinbeck use George as a symbol of good friendship in ...

    companion to take care of him, help him get through problems or anything. George killing Lennie at the ending of the story was more proper because it at least gave Lennie the decency to die with some peace, loyalty, happiness, reassurance, and comfort rather than by the workers in which

  1. Analysis of Loneliness in Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men

    George confronts Lennie about separating the puppy from his mother saying: "take this pup back to the nest. He's gotta sleep with his mother." Lennie always needs comfort and closure and gets this from animals. He was brought up by his aunt Clara, but she soon died.

  2. Of Mice and Men

    The itinerant workers are caught in a trap of loneliness - they never stay in one place long enough to form permanent relationships. Even if such relationships existed, they would probably be destroyed by the demands of the itinerant life.

  1. Why I think Candy was added by John Steinbeck to his book

    When Lennie is killed, George is left all alone. George is also a very brave man but not because he risked his life or put himself in danger. George's bravest act in Of Mice and Men was shooting his long-term companion, Lennie. George was both reluctant and determined to shoot Lennie.

  2. Of Mice And Men --- How does Steinbeck present the relationship between George and ...

    over-planning and generally having an exceedingly pessimistic view of Lennie's capabilities; however, as the reader finds out in the final section, George knows Lennie better than Lennie does himself and manages to predict all of his downfalls, from the attack on Curley to the doing-something-bad to Curley's wife in the final section.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work