• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the ways in which two writers have constructed a tale of the supernatural, and consider how effective they are as short stories. Choose two from The Monkey’s Paw, ‘The Signalman’, and ‘The Red Room’.

Extracts from this document...


Essay task: Short stories, especially ghost stories, were popular in the Victorian period. Compare the ways in which two writers have constructed a tale of the supernatural, and consider how effective they are as short stories. Choose two from The Monkey's Paw, 'The Signalman', and 'The Red Room'. A Short Story is a condensed fictional narrative, usually in prose. It typically concerns a relatively small number of characters involved in a single action with one thematic focus. Short stories are aimed at exciting, in the reader, a single emotional response. The novel, by contrast, typically presents many characters more leisurely developed through several interconnecting story lines and conflicts and evokes a multiplicity of emotional reactions. There are many advantages and disadvantages in writing a short story. The main advantages are firstly that you get to the action quickly. This allows just the right amount of description. It focuses on two or three characters, so it can concentrate on their feelings in an intense way. The settings are focused on one setting or location in an intense or claustrophobic manner. In addition, the action is built up quickly. Such stories usually suggest rather than spell everything out, and often have a disturbing factor in them. ...read more.


The cutting itself is described in great detail. 'On either side, a dripping wet wall of jagged stone, excluding all but a strip of sky.' This, explicitly, gives the idea of a very desolate, depressing area. It is expressed by the 'hero' that, when he went down into the cutting, he '...had left the natural world': therefore entering a supernatural world. This little quote prepares us for the prose to come. The signal box is not described in great detail, however it tells us what it contains: a bell and a book where, on several occasions, he makes notes. However we get the idea that it is very simple and plain. Although Charles Dickens' setting is following that of most short stories, it is well planned and, I think, a very good idea. The characters in 'The Red Room' are very varied. For a start there are more than probably you would expect in a short story. At the start, we have three: An old man with a shrivelled arm; an aged woman who unnerves our 'hero'; and the 'hero' himself. The central character is apparently very brave and doesn't believe that the room is haunted, '...it will take a very tangible ghost to frighten me'. ...read more.


This contrasts with the Red Room because whereas in this story the twist comes at a predictable time and we could have guessed the ending, the 'hero' and his explanation of the haunted room are very unforeseen. In conclusion, both are very well written short stories, and first-rate ghost stories. Both have their similarities, and their differences. The result of this is two very different stories; nevertheless, you can link aspects between the two. However, I do have a preferred narrative. My choice of the two is 'The Red Room', written by H. G. Wells. I like this one more because I think it is more enthralling. I was able to get into the story more while I was reading this one, rather than 'The Signalman'. I felt that I could share the thoughts and experiences with the characters. I am keen on the plot line. I love the way the room is described: although no great deal of details has been given, enough has been described so we can picture the room in our mind's eye. Our imagination is left to fill in the blanks. I think that Wells has done a great job with this story, and I suspect that a significantly amount of thought has gone into it. ?? ?? ?? ?? Alex Maxwell 10 D 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Signalman section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Signalman essays

  1. How typical are 'The signalman' by Charles Dickens, 'The monkeys paw' by W.W Jacobs ...

    The characters from the 'The Red Room' are the narrator, the man with the shade, the old lady and the man with the withered arm. This gives a gothic effect to the story by describing them as old in the beginning of the story "I half suspected the old people

  2. Which is the more effective of the supernatural stories of "The Signalman" and "The ...

    When he does this it makes the reader think: Why is the supernatural figure here? As well as this the reader may also link the idea of supernatural figures to a murder or death of a major character, this creates suspense because the reader wonders where the murder or death

  1. An Appreciation of the Short Story ‘The Black Veil’ by Charles Dickens

    He introduces the main subject of the story, the woman in the black veil, and does so in an interesting, and somewhat amusing way. The main purpose of the boy is to add a wider perspective of the woman. He causes suspense and tension, as well as excitement from the

  2. Which of the Two Horror Stories: "The Monkey's Paw" or "The Signalman" Do you ...

    Even after his death Herbert plays a central role in the horror of the story. When Mrs White requests Mr White to wish their son alive again he says, "He has been dead ten days, and besides he - I would not tell you else, but- I could only recognise him by his clothing."

  1. The signal man and the Red Room are both pieces of unique gothic literature

    of dirt and the look of slime just like a dungeon or as the book puts it "this great dungeon" meaning really clammy, dark, dripping with mould and cracked, grey and boring walls of the valley. I imagine it a bit like the Grand Canyon but instead of having red

  2. Do Victorian ghost stories follow a formula? Explore the techniques Victorian writers use to ...

    Really, because the start of story starts randomly, we feel perplexed by it. Another interesting point is that the stories all use a first person narrative. In 'the Signalman', for instance: "I repeat my enquiry" This makes the reader feel that they are part of the story rather than just witnessing it happening.

  1. Comparing two short stories, "The Withered arm" and "The Monkey's paw", discussing what part ...

    story, "Monkey's paw is just a bit of what you might call magic perhaps." The story suddenly changes from a family in their normal lives playing chess to a family who suddenly fear the unknown - the monkey's paw. From then on, the supernatural just affects the characters more and

  2. The supernatural has existed as long as human life.

    The mysteriousness associated with it, makes the tale more exciting for the reader. The paw is an omen and the readers want to know and understand more about the magical powers of the paw. The monkey's paw is the focus of the supernatural in the story, its magical powers engage

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work