• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the ways that Heaney presents nature in Storm on the Island and At a Potato Digging. Compare this with Patrolling Barnegat and Sonnet.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare the ways that Heaney presents nature in "Storm on the Island" and "At a Potato Digging". Compare this with "Patrolling Barnegat" and "Sonnet". It was once said, 'We humans are full of unpredictable emotions that logic alone cannot solve.' -Something very similar to this is Nature. Poems which recall the experiences of nature are "Storm, on the Island" and "At a Potato Digging" which also relates to the poems "Patrolling Barnegat" and "Sonnet". Seamus Heaney was born in Northern Ireland in 1939, the eldest child in what was to become a family of nine children. Much of Heaney's poetry is centred on the countryside and farm life that he knew as a boy. "Storm on the Island" by Heaney is a poem which explores the experiences which the people who live on an island encounter when a catastrophic storm strikes. Correspondingly, Seamus Heaney's poem "At a potato Digging" captures the emotions and experiences of the Irish Potato famine. ...read more.

Middle

More to the point, military metaphors are used to compare the storm to an army Heaney therefore shows the destructive power of nature and challenges the idea that Island life is idyllic. The use of Onomatopoeia puts the reader in the place of the narrator with the intention of encouraging them to undergo the storm which takes place. Whilst "Storm on an Island" is made of explosive and loud words, the poem "At a Potato Digging" unlike "Storm on the Island" is made of sorrowful and simple words, "Centuries of fear and homage to the famine god..." Perhaps Heaney did this to portray the sorrowful and simple lifestyle of the Irish people during the famine. The purpose of Religious imagery in this poem may be to show how the Irish prayed for a good crop as they became so helpless they "humbled" their "knees" and began to believe that it's in God's hands. ...read more.

Conclusion

In the same way as "Storm on the Island" and "Patrolling Barnegat" this poem too, however Clare conveys a calm and untroubled face of nature. The structure of the poem "Storm on the Island" consists of enjambment to convey the desperation. This also helps the reader learn that nature can flows like the sea, or become "a tame cat turned savage". The whole poem is written in one long stanza possibly to take the shape of the vigorous crashing of waves continuously pushing back and forth. Conversely, in the poem "At a Potato Digging" the structure is made of five sections: the farmer working 'today' (the present), then the description of the potatoes itself, followed by the famine which hit Ireland in 1845-1850, the suffering, and finally when there's plenty of food. The rhyme scheme- ABAB in the poem make the poem rhythmic: the rhythm of how remorselessly the farmers worked. That fact that the poem has been written in the style of a ballad instantly shows there is a moral which Heaney intends to put forward. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparing poems section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

4 star(s)

Response to the question

This response addresses a wide range of poetic and linguistic devices the poets use in order to present nature. The two poems give to this candidate are Seamus Heaney's 'Storm on the Island' and 'At a Potato Digging', with the ...

Read full review

Response to the question

This response addresses a wide range of poetic and linguistic devices the poets use in order to present nature. The two poems give to this candidate are Seamus Heaney's 'Storm on the Island' and 'At a Potato Digging', with the option to compare with any two other poems from the Anthology. The candidate has opted for 'Sonnet' by John Clare and 'Patrolling Barnegat' by Walt Whitman - this shows the candidate has a basic understanding of thematic similarities and difference between these for poem, as all four heavily orientate around the theme of nature, with some delving further into how it affects us as humans as well as how we rely on it for agricultural means and for relaxation, depending on what the nature is. The candidate consistently focuses on the poems, though the comparisons are very mixed and are jumbled together with no cohesive structure - a higher ability candidate might dedicate 30 minutes of the 1 hour exam to comparing in detail the first two poems, then 10 minutes on each of the other two in slightly lesser detail (and also making comparisons to the either of first two), leaving 5 minutes at the beginning and end of the exam to plan a proof-read.

Level of analysis

The Level of Analysis is wholly representative of what should be expected of a GCSE candidate expecting a middle B grade. Rather than just comment on how each poem speaks of nature, as this is the very obvious link, the candidate delves further into their analysis and speaks of how nature is represented - violently in 'Storm on the Island'; romantically in 'Sonnet', etc. - and then speaks in fair detail of the techniques the poets use in order to achieve this representation. Commenting on the language Heaney uses in 'Storm on the Island' in order to create a violent, threatening force of nature wins the candidate marks for paying close attention to phrase like "spits like a tame cat turned savage". Although, to gain even more marks, the candidate might employ and even deeper approach and comment on the effect of individual words like "spits" and the connotation it hold - offensive, vicious, snake-like" and also the sound of the word; "spit" actually sounds like it's definition, as does "savage"; extremely violent. This kind of analysis is the kind that will win the highest marks and, as 'Storm on the Island' is one of the poems the question prescribes, then this depth of analysis is required (and also in 'At a Potato Digging', being the other prescribed poem) to achieve top marks. Lesser analysis is required for the other two that the candidate chooses.
With regard to the other poems, the candidate's approach to 'At a Potato Digging' shows an excellence contextual knowledge of the Irish Potato Famine and it's involvement in the writing of the poem. Contextual research is like written gold for examiners as it shows a candidate with the ability to conduct external research in order to improve the strength of their analyses. However, the candidate missed a big trick in that 'Sonnet' is the only poem of the for that, for the entire poem, describes nature as something beautiful. Though all the poems subtly suggest nature is something to be admired (the brute force of the "demonic" waves in 'Patrolling Barnegat'; the "huge nothing" of 'Storm on the Island'; the "centuries of fear" in 'At a Potato Digging"), 'Sonnet is the only one that speaks of an admiration of nature because of it's beauty. This was only briefly touched upon toward the centre-end of the essay and the link could've been made stronger. In doing this, the candidate might also have commented on how, by using sonnet form (fourteen unbroken lines and decasyllabic rhythm in iambic pentameter), he creates a deeply romantic connection to nature, with sonnets being the typical form of poems of extremely intense emotion - the very fixed, unrelenting rhythm and the block of fourteen lines makes his emotions just as intense and those felt on the other poems, so candidates should be wary of saying that the poem is more calm, because whilst there is no threat of death or famine, the poet's emotions are still very high.

Quality of writing

The Quality of Written Communication is average. Quite frequently the candidate makes spelling mistakes that could easily be rectified with a single proof-read. There are a few instance where grammatical inconsistencies such as "the Irish prayed for a good crop as they became so helpless they “humbled” their “knees” and began to believe that it’s in God’s hands" whereby a few commas would help clarify the meaning of the sentence, and there is a limited use of punctuation. In order to achieve the highest band of marks, candidates must write confidently; using a powerful range of vocabulary and an astute use of more complex punctuation like colon, semi-colons and parentheses.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by sydneyhopcroft 26/02/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparing poems essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The theme of father and son relationships in Digging and Follower

    3 star(s)

    and do whatever he needs them to do, Heaney admires the way he does this. The use of complex farming vocabulary is used when Heaney says, 'And fit the bright steel-pointed sock.' And 'At the headrig.' The use of these words points out the fact that Heaney admires his father's

  2. Australian Identity as evident in the poetry of Judith Wright.

    faced while building the nation whereas 'Bora Ring' explores the consequences of white settlement on the indigenous population. The history of Australia becomes a part of Wright, describing Australia as the 'high lean country/ full of old stories that still go walking in my sleep'.

  1. Prayer of a Black Boy.

    He shows freedom of how the spirits play o the night. By the writer using alliterations he makes an image of a ship throwing out like animals its crew "a ship on the

  2. In my essay I will be comparing the two poems nothings changed by Tatamkhulu ...

    it's her ancestors as well that have been through slavery and injustice. Just like the roots of a tree have different channels and can be very long, however they all do the same job. Then Tatamkhulu also shows this, but he does this in a slightly different but clever way

  1. Balance sheet by John Montague - In Romney Marsh by John Davidson - ...

    Montague goes on to say that due to this change the local culture has vanished taking along everything that was associated with it. This is the main thought in the 'loss' section of the poem. In the 'gain' section of the poem, we see the things that have replaced the old culture.

  2. Compare how Wilfred Owen uses the natural world to reinforce the suffering that the ...

    Another day of being inches away from death. Again this is a negative phrase but unusually, it is being negative towards something which isn't bloodthirsty and a killer. In the fourth stanza Owen describes the opening of gunfire onto the men. There is a dramatic change in pace in this stanza.

  1. Write an essay in which you compare and contrast The Earth on Turtle's Back, ...

    The people of the tribe are knowledgeable and keep an understanding of all types of people or creatures that may surround them; also, having an understanding on how to assist them when needed. Noticing right from the start that the lady that fell from the sky did not have webbed

  2. Compare and Contrast the poems

    "Rainbow spectrum" This has been used to show that in rainbow there is many different colours. This is referring to the black population. There are many different types of people but they are still all black. The poem it's self has not even been categorised as the tile is part

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work