• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing and Contrasting- "A Stench of Kerosene"& "Looking for a Rain God" examine ways the writers create drama and tension and comment on the authors attitudes to the customs they describe.

Extracts from this document...


Comparing and Contrasting- "A Stench of Kerosene"& "Looking for a Rain God" examine ways the writers create drama and tension and comment on the authors attitudes to the customs they describe. To what extent are the customs responsible for the deaths in the two stories? In this coursework essay I will compare and contrast the following short stories: "A Stench of Kerosene" by Amrita Pritam and "Looking for a Rain God" by Bessie Head. Analysing language I will also comment on the authors attitudes to the customs they describe and how each of the authors create tension and drama within their respective short stories. Drama and tension are created dramatically in both of the stories by the extreme nature and severity of the deaths. In "A stench of Kerosene" the first we hear of Guleri's suicide is when Bhavani returns home after his evening at the fair in Chamba. He says in a flat voice "Guleri is dead". This is a powerful short sentence and it makes the reader anxious to find out how Guleri dies because the death is left in a shroud of mystery. We are later told Manak's wife Guleri dramatically takes her life by soaking her clothes in kerosene; burning herself in the ignited flames neighbouring her body. Drama is created by the sheer extremity of her actions. ...read more.


Manak then responds by saying "My Mother..." The ellipsis signifies that Manak is trying to say something that will reveal why he doesn't want her to go to the fair. We later discover he doesn't want Guleri to know of his Mothers plans for a second marriage. Presumably as he doesn't want to ruin Guleri's visit to her old Village she enjoys so much. After this conversation Guleri asks other questions asking why Manak can't attend the fair but Manak remains solemn and does not answer. He is unable to admit to his Mothers plans which he feels obliged to stick to and is consequently saddened by. He may also be worried about Guleri's reaction. Secondly in "Looking for a Rain God" Tension is created by the circumstances and setting of the story. We are informed in the early part of the story that a drought has covered the land where are living. We are also informed that some men "hung themselves to death" because they could not endure the unbearable heat. This sentence along with others describing the extreme heat creates an ominous mood this in turn creates Tension. This is because the reader understands the events that have been occurring and are now braced for any extreme events to come. Therefore tension is created as we almost expect something tragic to happen before we become deeply involved in the story itself. ...read more.


I believe that although the reader quickly blames Manak's mother for the death of Guleri, there could be a whole range of possible alternative interpretations. Some readers may believe that if Guleri had not have reacted so drastically as she did and accepted that Manak was complying with his customs she may not have dramatically committed suicide. Other readers may argue that Guleri should have the right to have been told that Manak was to marry a second time while she visited the fair in Chamba. These readers may believe that it was maybe Manak's fault Guleri kills herself. Maybe Guleri feels ashamed and humiliated by her husband as he doesn't tell her a life changing event that is going to happen. Readers may state that the person who's life would be most affected by the second marriage would be Guleri. Therefore Manak should have faced his fears of his mother and left his cowardness in the past behind him? Finally although we assume that Bessie Head is most definitely against murder and sacrifice we understand in the last line of the story she can appreciate why it still occurs in our civilised world up and to this day. In her story she states the other villagers "could have killed something to make the rain fall". This makes the reader understand the dire situation the villagers were coping with and how Ramadi's family cracked under pressure first. The punishment the husband and granddad received saved other possible tragedies in the village. Henry Courtier 10T ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Callum and Sephy's Emotional Journey

    fairy talk as he hasn't heard form Sephy since the night they spent together and tomorrow she was to leave for Chivers. When he runs into Jude, they talk about everything that's happened and Jude offers Callum to join the Liberation Militia.

  2. Comment on how Amrita Pritam conveys Indian culture in 'A Stench of Kerosene(TM) giving ...

    Her daily chores are described as being to stay at home to feed the cattle, cook food for her parents-in-law and handle all the other affairs to do with house work, as would a servant normally do. Traditionally the woman is seen as a slave who has no feelings and

  1. GCSE Essay on Tension in "Turn of the screw"

    I remember as a most pleasant impression". This peaceful setting lulls the reader into a false sense of security, however at the back of our minds is the idea from the prologue that the story will be horrifying which makes the reader suspicious of the circumstances surrounding the following events; thus creating an atmosphere of tension.

  2. Compare and contrast the mother-daughter relationship in 'A Taste Of Honey' by Shelagh Delaney ...

    "Have I ever laid claim to being a proper mother." This quote shows that she is not hypocritical about herself, which in a way is a good thing. However, there is nothing positive about Helen's approach to motherhood. Unlike Cathie's Mother who blames herself, Helen points her finger at Jo: "It's your fault..."

  1. Revenge- A fictional story

    'And who are you?' thought Helen. She immediately changed her thought on the new neighbour just because of these four unnecessary rude words, but being the kind hearted angel she is, she didn't want to create a scene and carried on the conversation. 'I am Helen and this is my Husband, Michael Peterson.'

  2. The Trouble with the Birlings and Gerald Croft is they Confuse Respectability with Morality ...

    However the Inspector's arrival shows that Gerald is not so much like Mr Birling that he has totally forgotten all his moral grounds and on some levels he is still a good person. The point is he still has the potential to turn into Mr Birling and I believe the

  1. Shakespeare Coursework - Henry

    After the Battle, Henry is told of the number of dead- 4 gentlemen and 25 other men. He then gives the victory to God "Take it God, For it is none but Thine." And orders hymns of praise to be sung and the dead to be buried showing his piety

  2. Sins of the Past

    Defoe shouted at Reynolds, "now is not the time!" Reynolds saw the killer running down the stairs behind them, "run!" The five of them ran with Taylor's body out of the plane and onto the snow. They took him across the snow to the Z600-X. They put his body in the cabin along with the pale Alexander.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work