Comparing and Contrasting the Fringe of the Sea and Island Man

Authors Avatar

Comparing and Contrasting the Fringe of the Sea and Island Man

The first poem, ‘The Fringe of the Sea’ was written by A.L. Hendricks.  This is about a Caribbean man, he later in life moved to London. He expresses his feelings and thoughts about his love for his homeland, Jamaica.

The second poem is ‘Island Man’ written by Grace Nicholls and she is similarly from Jamaica and moved to London in his life, but he also talks about his thoughts and feelings in the poem, but not just about his homeland, but in London as well.

These poems are similar because they both talk about the author’s homelands. They both compliment Jamaica, and are written in a nonchalant way. But they differ when Island Man starts to talk about London comparing the two contrasting communities.

This essay will compare and contrast the different writing styles and content in the poems, through the use of imagery, usage of sound, structures, tone/mood and overall themes and mood.

The two Poems Island Man and The Fringe of the Sea both use similar imagery techniques but they also differ is ways.

The Fringe of the Sea uses multiple literary techniques to create images in the readers mind, this can be shown by A.L. Hendricks using Listing.                 ’Work, dive swim and play in it.’ The words show that he is very close to the sea, being that he enjoys being with it or working in it. It shows that he depends on it also as a way of gaining money via work.                                             A.L. Hendricks also uses personification to bring the sea to life.                         ‘It’s call and murmurs wherever we may be’. This brings a life to the sea, giving it a personality and a sense of life. He does this because Hendricks wants to give the sea nature and bring it to life as it were a being.                                            He refers to the fish in the sea as semi-precious stones, ‘turquoise mackerel’ this shows that he regards them as being important as they are his source of money and living, but they’re not as important as other things in life, such as his family or community. Hendricks also uses tripling when describing the sea ‘to row and sail and pilot over it’ it shows he uses it for transport, for his community it could be a link to other places that they need to use the sea to access their closest other villages or cities. He also uses tripling to show that he’s close to nature ‘Barearmed, barefoot, bareheaded’ he tries to get the point across that he and his people are close to nature, less covered up and more relaxed. The other point that he tries to portray is that he and his community do not like to be far from the sea, shown by the first and last ‘stanza’ where he says ‘we do not like to awaken far from the fringe of the sea, we who live upon small islands’ and also ‘all who have lived upon small islands want to sleep awaken close to the fringe of the sea.’ Hendricks puts this point in twice as he wants the reader to understand this point more, and he’s glorifying his homeland in this poem.

Join now!

In island man Grace Nicholls uses many other literary techniques to create images for the reader for example when she writes ‘small emerald island’. She describes her homeland as a precious stone as well, because she idolises her homeland and thinks that it is very important. She also uses a lot of repetition in this poem ‘groggily groggily’ and ‘muffling muffling’ show that she’s trying to get the point that it’s hard to wake up in a different community, rushed and hurried, where as in Jamaica there’s no rush or need to get up early, making life a lot easier ...

This is a preview of the whole essay