• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing 'How Do I Wish To Go?' and 'Let Me Die A Youngman's Death' by Roger McGough

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparing 'How Do I Wish To Go?' and 'Let Me Die A Youngman's Death' by Roger McGough -Aj Orena S4L (23) 'How do I wish to go' and 'Let me die a Youngman's death' is showing an example of two poems of similar content being entirely different. This essay is going to compare and distinguish those similarities and differences between these two poems. First, I will talk about the similarities, then, I will move on to discuss the differences. An easy first similarity is the contents of both poems. Both poems are discussing the ways of how people want to die. The similarity is already observable from the title itself. In 'How do I wish to go?' it is separated into 4 stanzas, in which each stanza is talking about different situations of people dying. However, 'Let me die a Youngman's Death' produces 5 stanzas, in which he describes three situations of when, where and how he wants to die. In addition, it also mentions some ways of how he doesn't want to die. Another similarity is that the poem is set in the 1st person voice. This is shown throughout the whole of both poems. ('Flames gripping my skirt', 'I achieved my final goal' from 'How do I wish to go?' ...read more.

Middle

On the other hand, in 'Let me die a Youngman's death', there are 5 stanzas with lines varying from 5 to 7 lines and words from 25-36 words. As you can see, the margin of number of lines and words in 'Let me die a Youngman's death' is a lot wider than 'How do I want to go?'. Also, there are punctuations in 'How do I wish to go?' in every line while in 'Let me die a Youngman's death', there are no punctuations at all and sentences go to the next sentence without a punctuation. This concludes that 'Let me die a Youngman's death' is more disorganized compared to 'How do I want to go?'. This may imply that 'How do I want to go?' is more planned, in terms of how he/she wants to die. We can also find this conclusion from the content. In 'How do I want to go?', all of the 4 situations describes ways in which he/she is planning his/her death. They are from war ('lying on the ground', 'with my helmet at my side'), from a planned suicide ('outside the embassy, flames gripping my skirt'), and others. Meanwhile, in 'Let me die a Youngman's death', it talks about ways in which he is dying from an accident. ...read more.

Conclusion

On the other hand, in 'Let me die a Youngman's death', the style of language is colloquial and the author seems to be having a conversation with a bunch of his friends over some drinks. In conclusion, as mentioned, there are a couple of differences and similarities that can be found between these 2 poems. Although looking for similarities is a tad more difficult, the similarities are also very important. We found out that both of these poems are a little bit disorganized, with 'Let me die a Youngman's death' being more disorganized. These poems were made this way for a purpose. For example, we gathered that these poems were made 1st person so that the reader would understand and believe the poem more. We also gathered that the tone of 'How do I wish to go?' is serious and the content is about sacrificing for something or someone. However, in 'Let me die a Youngman's death', the tone is more witty and it describes wild, crazy and 'Hollywood' action deaths. Both poems are excellent examples of content and form being well matched. The imagery that is produced by both poems are wonderfully clear and beautifully made and with a bit of knowledge, quite easy to understand. Both poets brilliantly carved each stanza word by word so that each line had purpose and what cannot be doubted is the beauty and power of the poem. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE War Poetry essays

  1. The theme that links my three chosen poems, 'Cold in the Earth', 'TheToys' and ...

    To me, a 21st century reader, it also shows how serious it is, because a person who wishes to commit suicide is deeply troubled and needs help. So in conclusion, Emily Bront? approaches the subject of death in an up-front way.

  2. Dickinson's BECAUSE I COULD NOT STOP FOR DEATH

    (L 179) These letters reveal a pleasure in the "soft" spring of the South, and in the "elegance" and "grandeur" of the great plantation of Mount Vernon. "We have had many pleasant times, " Dickinson told Mrs. Holland, "and seen much that is fair, and heard much that is wonderful

  1. On the Tombs in Westminster Abbey, Death the Leveller, Ozymandias, My Busconductor and Let ...

    victories will at some point cease to matter as shown by the line, "strong nerves at last must yield." The message in both the poems at this point is exactly the same in that they teach us that the fate that awaits us all is death.

  2. Roger McGough is both a serious and humorous poet. Demonstrate this from the poems ...

    crucifix still clenched in her fist, branded into dead flesh, the sign of a cross'. The poem is sad in nice way though. The other short poem that fits into both categories is ' 40 - love', which is a rather simple poem, but the message is put across easily.

  1. Discuss the impact that the place in which people die and the type of ...

    her family did not see her death as bad but more as a release from the long drawn out life of medical intervention she would have gone through if she had not have died early. Many people who die in their own homes die suddenly either from an unexpected death

  2. The poem's "Nooligan" by Roger McGough and "Street Boy" by Gareth Owen are two ...

    Just you look at me man Gareth has used that technique intentionally to characterize the street boy as an attention-seeker. "Street Boy" wants the reader to pay full attention to him and focus on him before starting the verse. Furthermore, "Just you" is a type of a threatening phrase which

  1. Does the death of the body constitute death of the person?

    separate the notion of a dying donor and the needs of an organ recipient. There is clearly a differentiation between death as an event for physicians and death as a process for those grieving, which highlights the ambiguity of a dead body and dead person.

  2. Virginia Woolf's essay "The Death of the Moth" - review

    By using the moth as a metaphor for humans, she shows that the way the moth lives its life is a model for human life. Her overall use of brevity, both in her language and the physical structure of the essay, serves to both convey her ideas and to provide

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work