• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing mental pictures of place in Island Man and Blessing

Extracts from this document...


Comparing mental pictures of place in Island Man and Blessing Nichols uses words to create pictures of two places in 'Island Man' as she contrasts the Island Man's dream of his homeland, a peaceful, idyllic Caribbean island with his reality of a new home in London. In contrast, Dharker sets her poem in one place in an Indian community where the 'municipal pipe bursts.' However, she also uses contrast to depict the place as being hot and dry with the temporary blessing of the water running free. Whereas the tone in 'Island Man' is rather calm and peaceful as he is dreaming of his island and waking to 'the sound of blue surf', the tone in Blessing is rather excited and positive, almost celebratory as it describes how silver crashes to the ground / and the flow has found/a roar of tongues. Nichols uses alliteration or sibilance to create a smooth, soothing sound of the sea whereas Dharker uses rhyme to describe the rushing water. Despite the chaos that ensues, this makes it seem as if this was somehow meant to be and its unity reflects the unity of community in this place. ...read more.


'Blessing' also uses a simile to imply that it is a dry place where nothing ever grows, 'The skin cracks like a pod.' A pod stores food and cracks open to dispense it; however, the fact that it is skin being described shows that people are mal-nourished or experience under-developed growth due to the lack of water there. The structure of 'Island Man' reflects and contrasts the fact that the Island Man is inhabiting two places at once: the island of his dreams and the reality of his 'London day.' In the middle he begins to drift into consciousness and thus the natural pictures of the island or projected onto London so there is 'the grey metallic soar' of cars rather than the 'wild seabirds' and the 'steady breaking and wombing' of the sea surrounding the island, like a baby in the womb, as this is his birth place, is replaced with 'surge of wheels' as he is now on a sort of island in the middle of the North Circular. ...read more.


The personified and holy water sort of blesses or baptises the water yet the heat of the place is still emphasised with the fact they are 'screaming in the liquid sun' which suggests pain at living in such a hot place. Yet this negative aspect is overridden by the fact that the water is called a blessing; it is like a reprieve from suffering for the impoverished community. In conclusion, the two poems create effective mental pictures to describe the places by using contrasting visual imagery as 'Blessing' mixes hot and dry and 'Island Man' clean and polluted, exotic and dull places. Both personify the key aspects of the places in that given moment such as the 'defiant sun' that replaces dull London and the 'liquid sun' as the blessing has triumphed and managed to cool the Indian village for a while, as eventually the liquid Sun will equally triumph to make the village dry again. Both poems describe the best aspects of the places: Island Man is very nostalgic whereas Blessing celebrates a present moment where people are enjoying something that we have everyday as a religious ceremony or a blessing that unites a community in celebration. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparing poems section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparing poems essays

  1. Blessing and Island Man

    Imagery is frequently used too, such as 'liquid sun' and this adds to the feeling of heat in the poem, helping us to realise how important the water is to the characters. Onomatopoeia is used in the line 'drip of it, the small splash' and this is used to give a clearer picture of what is happening in the poem.

  2. Essay on Poems from different cultures - Blessing and Island Man

    "ground" and "found" also rhyme, although these sections rhyme, there is no repeated rhyme through the poem, there is no pattern between the rhymes. These 2 rhymes are a line apart from eachother, but it rhymes again 3 lines later with these words "around".

  1. Compare and contrast the presentation of dreams in 'Island Man' and 'Blessing'

    The poem tells us that he wants to be in the Caribbean under the warm sun and with the calming sea but in the end he just wakes up to "another London day".

  2. Comparing and Contrasting Poems

    Further on in line 4 he tells us about the 'sack of rice'; we also know that rice is part of the staple diet in India and they harvest it before monsoon as we are also told that the people are 'peasants' it all fits together.

  1. We have to do our coursework on this topic and the five poems I ...

    The old woman fights with her neighbour because she throws stones at the old woman's white rooster and makes too much noise in her backyard. I think the old woman misses Jamaica and is quite lonely where she is now.

  2. Discuss how the settings in 'The man with the twisted lip' by Sir Arthur ...

    "The man with the twisted lip" relies strongly on the generalised impression of a high class Victorian man. It is original and surprising to read a story that goes against this, claiming that not all these glamorous high class families are perfect.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work