• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing Metaphysical Poems: Donne and Marvell

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Name: Laura Caldwell Teacher: S.T St. Julie's Catholic High School Centre #: 34358 Date: Jul '10 Pre-1914 Poetry Essay Question: Compare and contrast 'To His Coy Mistress' by Andrew Marvell with 'The Flea' by John Donne in relation to the following question: 'From your reading of the two poems, to what extent do you feel that they are truly Metaphysical?' Both of these poems are Metaphysical in many ways. The term 'Metaphysical' refers to matters that are literally 'beyond the physical' - this is things such as God, heaven and hell, the soul and the meaning of life. They looked past visible life to discover the concealed beauty beneath. Much of their work contained an underlying Neoplatonist philosophy; they took the view that everything was an imperfect copy of something perfect, so in a way they shared that perfection and became beautiful. The Metaphysical poets were a group of British poets around the 1600s, who shared a similar way of investigating metaphysical concerns. These poets, however, did not label themselves as Metaphysical - most of them didn't even know each other. The writer Samuel Johnson gave them this title a lot later on, in his book 'Life of Cowley', where he recognised their style through subtle and sophisticated arguments, strange similes and metaphors, and their use of wit. Two notable poets from this group are Andrew Marvell and John Donne. Andrew Marvell was the son of a Church of England clergyman, and John Donne was a preacher from a Roman Catholic family. ...read more.

Middle

He says that 'yonder all before us lie/ deserts of vast eternity', so he is trying to tell her that God will not reward if she keeps her virginity as he is not real. This is not metaphysical; he is simply trying to scare her into sleeping with him. It is a lot more effective than Donne's argument, however, as his attempt of persuasion is nothing but sophistry. An example of this is where he says 'mark but this flea', emphasising how small and insignificant the flea is. He then goes on to say 'mark in this how little that which thou deniest me is'. This quote is referring to her virginity, which she will not allow him to take, so he is basically saying that her virginity is only as significant as a tiny flea. This is obvious nonsense, as virginity is clearly a big thing, and it mattered even more around the time these poems were written than nowadays. Also, the two objects are completely unrelated, as there is really no link between loss of virginity and a flea. This shows how nonsensical Donne's argument really is. This is not Metaphysical is there is no reference, or hidden reference, to anything non-physical. Out of the two poems, To His Coy Mistress is seemingly much more non-specific. In The Flea, Donne keeps the same theme all the way throughout the poem, making constant reference to the metaphorical flea, right from the first line 'Mark but this flea' all the way through to the last line 'as this flea's death took life from thee. ...read more.

Conclusion

These major and minor premises are effective because they give a good argument, and they make an argument much more persuasive by making a point and then justifying it. In The Flea, we notice that the woman in the poem is a lot more argumentative against Donne's argument than the subject of To His Coy Mistress is towards Marvell. This may be because Donne insults the woman throughout the poem, calling her 'cruel and sodaine'. At first it seems as if she is genuinely annoyed, however if looked at in more detail, we can see that maybe he is just criticising her in a playful flirty way, and her response may be a playful way of replying. Marvell, however, uses flattery to persuade his lady, by referring to her as 'lady' and states that he would spend thousands of years admiring each part of her if he could, which is obviously very flattering towards the subject. This seems more effective than Donne's argument, but in fact The Flea is probably more persuasive in this sense as there is a kind of teasing and joking essence about the poem. Overall, I do not think that the poems are really metaphysical at all. There are metaphysical aspects on the surface, but these seem to only be there to cover up the fact that the two men want the women to sleep with them, and they think that using metaphysical imagery is the best way to persuade them because they are both seemingly religious women. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparisons section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparisons essays

  1. Compare 'To His Coy Mistress' by Andrew Marvell with 'To His Mistress Going to ...

    You get the feeling that he really believes it, he's really sincere, and although what he's saying isn't realistic, it is realistic that he believes this of his lover. The main difference is that "To his Mistress Going to Bed" is more romantic, even though some don't agree.

  2. Compare the way the theme of love is viewed and conveyed by the author ...

    The portrait of love as given in A Woman to Her Lover is the most comprehensive one, but still (and perhaps actually consequently) the hardest to define. Christina Walsh uses similar love as E. B. Browning, but tries to explain that it isn't the only love to be seen and

  1. Compare and contrast To His Coy Mistress and John Donnes The Flea and consider ...

    In The Flea the use of imagery is different to that of To His Coy Mistress because in the flea it is used as a visual image to allow the poet's partner to see what he is talking about and to be persuaded as it reinforces the narrators idea of

  2. A Comparison of how "To His Coy Mistress" and "The Flea" Present and Develop ...

    me first, and now sucks thee, And in this flea, our two bloods mingled be; This frustrates the persona because the flea has done what his mistress has resisted against performing with him; this shyness is also what Marvell's argument is based on.

  1. comparing John Dryden(TM)s The Fire of Lond

    to more of a human aspect as Byron starts to describe how humans as a population are coping with the disaster. We also get to see as in the 'Fire of London' how the perspective of the poem changes from concentrating on how all humans are coping to just a

  2. How and in what ways have the poets in this anthology conveyed the Macabre? ...

    Tennyson has done this because he wants the reader to feel like the Kraken and be uncomfortable. This shows a significant contrast to the abrupt start to the poem. The start of the poem grabs the reader's attention and then it slows down almost to a halt.

  1. How do Donne's sonnets differ from Shakespeare's sonnets? In your answer, you should discuss ...

    However, the way that he is different from Shakespeare is that Donne mentions himself in both of his poems, while Shakespeare does not. In "Holy Sonnet", he is asking God to "batter my heart", "o'erthrow mee", and "divorce mee". Due to this, the reader can relate to what Donne writes

  2. A Parental Ode to my son (Thomas Hood) and Upon my Son Samuel (Anne ...

    There is also an overuse of exclamation marks to indicate the heightened lines. The alternate, full rhyme scheme of the lines makes the poem flow. However, the rhyme scheme of the lines in brackets are more broken, giving the sense of the poet's frustration and broken concentration because of the boy being in the room with him.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work