• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing the depiction of women in literature. The two pieces I am comparing are, Shakespeares Romeo and Juliet and Hardys novella, The Withered Arm

Extracts from this document...


Rhoda, Gertrude, Nurse, Lady Cap, Juliet. At the mercy of men. Jack Wilson 12z Ms McGarry I am going to be comparing two pieces of literature. Both of the pieces have their similarities but at a glance they would not seem that similar. One is a play written in 1600`s and the other is a novella written in 1880`s. The two pieces are of very different genre, one is a play written for the stage and the other is a novella written in episodic chapters. I am going to be paying special attention to the women in each piece, not just the women but how they react and respond towards men. One of the pieces is set in "Fair Verona" and the other is set in "Rural England". The two pieces I am comparing are, Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet" and Hardy's novella, "The Withered Arm" Rhoda is a milkmaid and is the first character we meet in the story. At the start of the story Rhoda starts to appear that she is poor, hardworking and is trying to earn a living, "Shows marks of the lady on her, as I expect she do". ...read more.


The whole society revolves around men. Rhoda and the Nurse both bring up children and are similar as they are both lower class. I think that Rhoda has more morals than the nurse, I think this because when Rhoda in offered money by Farmer Lodge she says no and doesn't accept it and refuses, but when the Nurse is offered money by Romeo she doesn't hesitate to take it. Both Nurse and Rhoda are man-less, the Nurse is a widow and Rhoda is out of a relationship. I think Hardy and Shakespeare just made characters and didn't think about the fact that they were at the mercy of men, I think this because this was the norm when they were written and it would have been shocking if a woman didn't obey her husband. Gertrude is married to Farmer Lodge which has made Rhoda seem very jealous because she wants to find out what Gertrude is like, what she looks like, what is her personality like, so Rhoda sends her eight year old son to find out. Her eight year old son wears rags and tatty old clothes this is because Rhoda does not have enough money to buy clothes for her son and herself "She is not tall. ...read more.


We know that both Juliet and Gertrude are very pretty and are both described with natural imagery, "Rosy cheeked, Tipsy topsy" and "snowy dove". Men judge both of the girls on their appearance so it is very important for them to look good. I think Gertrude and Juliet are at the mercy of men the most, I think this because they both end up dieing because of their men, they are victims of love. Hardy is an omniscient narrator. Because of this it really helps to see how bad Rhoda and Gertrude are at the mercy of men. We can hear their inside monologue and this makes it very easy to understand his characters and get inside their head. Hardy and Shakespeare both create weak and vulnerable woman who are at the mercy of men, these woman deserve our sympathy. I do agree with that statement, the female characters base their live around men and would do anything to please them. I think the only exception is the Nurse, she is past her day of revolving around men, she still talks about sex a lot but I think she isn't as obsessed with her looks as the other four women. I think that both authors create interesting characters and they are defiantly at the mercy of men. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Of mice and men

    bet" as if to say what Curley had to offer wasn't good enough when that's what nearly all women wish they could have. Her marriage to Curley was an escape from loneliness which seemed to have failed. As she was an attention seeker she used her sexuality to her advantage

  2. Romeo and Juliet Monologue

    Poor Romeo he must be distraught. If Tybalt and Romeo were in a brawl then, Romeo may have only been trying to save himself from being slain. That's why he killed Tybalt. After all, one of them had to take their last breath to conclude the brawl.

  1. To what extent are Shakespeares plays a product of the Elizabethan theatrical context in ...

    Another factor which Shakespeare's players would have had to contend with would have been having very little time to rehearse. This is because the population of London was much smaller then, so people would have got bored of the play quickly; so new plays took place frequently.

  2. A comparison of two adverts- Skoda Fabia and Citroen C4

    They sets the scene based on the wants of its target market however. The men want a cool, 'hard as nails' speedy car whereas women are happy with a car that is homely, reliable, and full of sweet and lovely things (as the slogan, and the advert suggests).

  1. Romeo and juliet essay

    Even when his suggestions turn out to cause more problems, such as Juliet taking the potion, this is not because of Friar Lawrence's doing, but simply the work of fate. Friar Lawrence also does not deserve to be punished because he is not an antagonist in the play.

  2. Violence and conflict are central to Romeo and Juliet. Explore Shakespeares presentation of this ...

    Benvolio tries to encourage Tybalt to stop the fighting, but Tybalt doesn't believe that Benvolio's intentions were to stop the fight. "What, drawn, and talk of peace! I hate the word, as I hate hell, all Montagues, and thee: Have at thee, coward" this leads Tybalt and Benvolio to also start fighting.

  1. Men and women in Shakespeares play, The Winters Tale

    The relationship between Polixenes and Hermione is one that is cemented by their mutual love for Leontes. This is likely to strike a cord with modern audiences just as it would have done in Shakespeare's time. However, opinions about female sexuality were different in the seventeenth century as women's sexuality

  2. Romeo & Juliet

    She is calling upon Romeo and telling him that she loves him so much that she would give up her family for him. Keeping their love a secret caused Romeo and Juliet to turn to other people for help and often these people gave the wrong advice or just betrayed them.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work