Comparing "The Monkey's Paw" and "The Red Room" In this essay, I am going to compare "The Monkey's Paw" by W.W. Jacobs

Authors Avatar

Comparing “The Monkey’s Paw” and “The Red Room”

In this essay, I am going to compare “The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs with “The Red Room” by H.G Wells. I will examine how the writers create suspense in the stories. “The Monkey’s Paw” is about a paw that grants wishes. The White family ask for a first wish with humour while underestimating the paw and without taking into consideration what happened to the people before them. They are also not taking into account that the consequences will be disastrous. “The Red Room” is about an adventurous man who wants to prove that there are no ghosts in Lorraine Castle. In order for him to prove his belief, he had to go through a frighting once in a life experience that he himself generated automatically without even knowing it. These two stories are similar in their type, they are both horror and gothic stories and were set before the 20th century.

The setting of “The Monkey’s Paw” is a very typical type of setting, which is found in many other similar types of horror and gothic stories: “… the night was cold and wet,”. The fact that the story is set at night and additionally in bad weather conditions, grabs our attentions immediately. Using night and bad conditions for the setting at the beginning  of the story is a very common writing technique that most of writers utilize to build suspense from the begging of their stories to gain the interest of their readers, which will lead the readers to an eager of exploring and reading the story even further. Using night is also important for increasing the suspense and catching reader’s attention because most of us are afraid of the dark and especially that we can’t see what could be out there hiding, so our fear starts to generate and we start asking our selves about what could happen next.

The other factor about the setting of this story that creates suspense and must be taken into account is that this house is isolated and is “…out-of-the-way…”. The isolation is a very important factor that completes the horror scene perfectly, because if you are isolated you can’t get help if you faced danger and your loud screams will not be heard whatsoever. Most of us don’t like the feeling of isolation and wouldn’t prefer to be placed in such creepy places, so we get the feeling of how scary it will be in that place. We also build an image of how it looks like in that area and this is where we start getting scared and our suspense levels raise even while we start thinking of what will come up next.

The story “The Red Room” also creates suspense in a different number of ways. The main and important factor is the fact that it’s set in a “…castle,”. The story being set in a castle make it sound more like a traditional early 20th century gothic horror story. The reader finds it simple to blend in with the story and they easily imagine them selves in that place, remembering all childhood creepy castle stories. Another important factor, which is common for most castles, is once again the isolation factor. This factor raises our suspense levels very high and gets us started with thinking about all the terrible situation that the narrator might face.

Join now!

Another factor in this story that creates suspense is the mysterious “…red room…” and its description of being  a “…haunted room…”. This quote raises suspense rapidly because it adds more horror to the current unpleasant situation and also recalls the fear inside us of haunted castles and reminds us of frightening ghosts. The word “red” also reminds us of blood and of death and make us suspect that something dreadful might happen to the writer. It increases the fear and suspense levels inside to maximum levels but not quite to the top yet. At this stage, the reader now ...

This is a preview of the whole essay