• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing the presentation of Harker in Dracula and Walton in Frankenstein

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Jonathan Harker and Robert Walton clearly play important roles in their respective novels, and this is particularly shown by their status as narrators. Indeed, their importance is further emphasised by the fact that both characters provide both the opening and closing narratives in their novels. Whilst both characters play narrative roles within the novels, there is a key difference in the way in which the reader must interpret their narratives: whilst Walton plays only a minor role in Frankenstein, Harker's role in Dracula is much larger, and so his views are likely to be biased. Indeed, at one point Harker's reliability as a narrator is seriously questioned when it transpires that he is 'suffering from a violent brain fever'. By allowing the reader to doubt Harker's versions of events, his reliability is, ultimately, enhanced when it is revealed that his narrative was entirely accurate. Walton only plays a small physical role in Frankenstein, and so Shelley clearly believes that he is less likely to be seen as a biased narrator, and the need to emphasise his overall reliability is not present. ...read more.

Middle

The rhetorical features used also help to persuade Margaret, in terms of the plot, and the reader, in terms of narrative technique, that Walton truly knows that visiting the North Pole will be a difficult expedition, but one which he will find very spiritually fulfilling. The emphasis on accurate reportage of meticulous detail which is so important for Stoker to establish early in Dracula is not as important for Shelley, as Walton is simply seen to report the details as told to him by Frankenstein; Walton's own observations play only a relatively small part in the narrative, compared to the crucial observations made by Harker. Harker's position in the novel of Dracula is crucially important, as it is his character who finally defeats the chief antagonist, and, indeed, it would not be unreasonable to see Harker as the chief protagonist of the novel. However, this position is very different to that played by Walton. Whilst both characters play an important part in the epistolary narrative of each novel, Walton's narrative function is very much more important that his function as a part of the plot. ...read more.

Conclusion

Similarly, Walton eventually abandoned his life-long ambition to reach the North Pole for the benefit of his crew, despite the fact that this leaves him 'ignorant and disappointed'. Whilst it is clear that he was under duress to do so because of the threat of mutiny amongst his crew, it would perhaps have been possible for him to insist that they continue, and so risk the lives of his crew. Instead, like Harker in Dracula, he shows compassion and decides that it is better not to risk the life of innocent human beings for his own ends. Harker and Walton clearly play important roles in their respective novels, and have many similarities in terms of their characterisation. However, due to their differing functions within the novels as a whole, we see that Stoker and Shelley make their own characters to serve their given purpose, which inevitably leads to many differences in the two characters. Because of their appropriate characterisation, Walton and Harker, both central characters in their respective novels, fulfil their roles very successfully. By S Howard ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Bram Stoker section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Bram Stoker essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How does Bram stoker manipulate audience response to Jonathan Harker and Dracula in his ...

    5 star(s)

    So Bram Stoker is hinting to the audience that Dracula wasn't as cruel as he seemed. I think he is trying to make the audience slightly sympathetic towards him. The phrase "passed from our sight", is used to describe Dracula's death, Bram Stoker wants us to view Dracula as a

  2. Discuss the ways the filmmakers have presented the story Dracula.

    Because of this effect people may be interested in the film and will want to understand about the supernatural forces that surround Dracula. Religion is focused on at the beginning of the film so that the audience can see that religion is Dracula's weakness.

  1. Discuss possible answers to this question with reference to at least two critical or ...

    241). This sexual innuendo restores the Victorian balance of sexual penetration from the female domain back its accepted station within the male domain. Showalter interprets the killing as a gang rape, done with "impressive phallic instrument" (p. 181). "Those serial transfusions which, while they pretend to serve and protect 'good women,'

  2. "The Gothic is concerned primarily with representing transgression and taboo, there is nothing more ...

    Due to technological advances the growth of mass consumption of literature Gothic novels were over printed by mass producing commercial presses. The distribution, via retail and circulating libraries, was also cheap. This led to a rise in independent publishers (like William Lane's Minerva Press)

  1. What boudaries does the vampire threaten? Discuss possible answers to this question with ...

    In order to rectify Lucy's condition she is sexually overpowered by her fiancee Holmwood; he penetrates her to death with a stake through the chest, a staking which is overtly sexual in interpretation, as "the thing in the coffin writhed; and a hideous, blood-curdling screech came from the opened red lips.

  2. "Gothic fiction is erotic at the root" according to Punter. From your reading of ...

    Walpole placed his novel in Italy in the middle ages and set it in a castle complete with dungeons, battlements, cloisters, galleries and trapdoors and consequently it met all the requirements of the gothic novel. The popularity of this novel spawned a multitude of others within the same genre.

  1. Dracula Is One of the Most Important and Influencial Novels of Its Genre, Why, ...

    Three men, Arthur Holmwood, Dr. Seward, and Quincey Morris have recently proposed to Lucy. Out of the three she chooses Arthur to be her happy fianc�. Mina and Lucy go on a vacation together to Whitby, a quaint seaside town.

  2. Are Dracula and Atticus portrayed as heroic for breaking society’s taboos?

    Do heroes exist? Or are they just special people to a minority who they have affected? Therefore being no different or better than every other person alive. Using this understanding of heroism, I will try to match both Dracula and Atticus's personality and actions to my definition of heroism to find if either of them are heroic.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work