• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing the short stories, "An Arrest" and "Napoleon and the Spectre"

Extracts from this document...


Read An Arrest and Napoleon and the Spectre. Compare and contrast these texts focusing on their effectiveness as mystery stories within the short story genre In the 19th century short stories dramatically increased in popularity due to their appearances in magazines and newspapers, the fact that printing was much more widely available was another factor that helped increase the popularity for the short story. Short Stories were also a good source of income for authors as writers would have received a good amount of money for publishing their stories in various pieces for public viewing, by appearing in such pieces vast amounts of people would have been given the chance to read them. Cliff hangers and twists are often portrayed in the genre of short stories. The basic elements of a short story include a beginning, in which the reader is thrown into action. The tension contained in the story rises to a high extent and the end usually consists of a cliff hanger or twist. High tension is usually sustained throughout a short story, as opposed to novels. Short stories can often be didactic and seek to tell a moral truth. ...read more.


Bront� has been effective in the way she created a mysterious feel about the story as the reader is left guessing till the end. Alike Napoleon and the Spectre, Bierce has also been effective in conveying a suitably tense atmosphere allowing the reader to feel uneasy. He explains how susceptible Orrin Brower is by describing the difficulty of his task, "got no weapon," building the suspense and allowing the reader to feel anxious. This is extended when Bierce uses "bloodhounds," allowing the reader to assume the prospect of vicious dogs on Brower's tail and the reality he faced. The mysterious atmosphere is emphasised when Brower is alone with the unknown character, "they entered the town, which was all alight, but deserted." Comparing to Bronte, Bierce uses much less description when referring to the ghost The presence of the supernatural is hinted when Bierce describes what is in the sight of Brower, "saw the visible embodiment of Law lift its arm and point," this is an example of the gothic conventions. A combination of short and long sentences steps up the climax of the story, ".....him. ...read more.


This ending backs up the moral meaning of justice held throughout. In comparison to the ending used by Bierce, I was rather disappointed in Napoleon and the Spectre, since the mystery built up in the story does not end with a major incident. The length of the paragraph also adds to the straightforwardness of the finale, "the Emperor immediately fell into a fit of catalepsy, in which he continued during the whole of that night and the greater part of the next day." Personally I think that Bronte was not very effective in concluding her story as it lets the reader down. In conclusion I found both stories well constructed and effective, however I found An Arrest more effective as a mystery short story. Since, although it was short and concise, Bierce has been very effective in displaying the tension and providing a climatic ending which satisfies the reader. I thought that in general Napoleon and the Spectre was quite effective in providing suspense and mystery however I feel that Bronte could have allowed the atmosphere around the Spectre to seem more threatening. I also think that she could have given a more successful ending since I did not find it convincing which did not live up to the story. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Charlotte Bronte section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Charlotte Bronte essays

  1. Explore the use of the supernatural in ‘Jane Eyre’

    There are no ghosts in 'Jane Eyre' yet every phase of Jane's life is preceded by an image within her imagination depicting a supernatural visitation as though from another world. There are many small examples of this foreshadowing throughout the book, such as Helen Burns' death.

  2. With close attention to content, style and themes, examine the ways that Henry James ...

    them when she says 'there were moments when I knew myself to catch them up by an irresistible impulse and press them to her heart'. Her obsessive nature over the children builds up until she fights Quint for Miles' soul and 'with a single bound and an irrepressible cry' she had 'sprung straight upon him'.

  1. Grim ghost story.

    "Well these three look very well behaved to me. I shall take all of them...That is if you don't have other people wanting to take them away." "On the contrary, Mr Lambert, not one person has enquired about them. It's very hard for them take more than one away, considering that many have their own to bring up and feed."

  2. Prologue - Keith Johnson was a short man with close, iron-grey hair, and the ...

    He considered paintball was a sport reserved especially for adults who couldn't make the Territorial Army, and shot each other with Dulex paints. Still after 4 weeks in Team 2, the paintball practice, was just a couple hours of fun in the obstacle strewn room, compared with the more rigorous weapons training.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work