• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing two film versions of Macbeth, Roman Polanski's 1972 film and Michael Bogdanov's 1998 film.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Macbeth: Act 3, Scene 4 'The Banquet Scene' Interpretations on Video Macbeth, one of Shakespeare's greatest plays, has been portrayed in various different ways on film: in the more traditional style of Roman Polanski's 1972 film and in the more contemporary 1998 film, made by Channel 4 and directed by Michael Bogdanov. One of the most interesting scenes in the play is the 'Banquet Scene' in which King Macbeth is publicly and supernaturally confronted by his sins - the ghost of his former friend Banquo, who was present when first Macbeth learned of his destiny from the We�rd Sisters. Macbeth feels that Banquo knows too much and suspects him for the murder of King Duncan as shown by 'and I fear/ Thou played'st most foully for't'. Macbeth's only answer is to have Banquo murdered by paid assassins. Since the murder of Duncan, Macbeth has entrenched himself in even more murderous means of achieving his aims - such as the murder of Banquo and the murderers - the ends justify the means in a very machiavellian way. In Roman Polanski's film, the Banquet Scene is interestingly cut up into four separate consecutive scenes: firstly the beginning of the banquet, with all the customary entertainments, then Macbeth leaves the room to speak with the murderers, and the murderers are dispatched, next the main 'Banquet Scene' followed with the Macbeths in bed. ...read more.

Middle

The next 'mini' scene is the Macbeths in their bed after the night's festivities. The room is flooded with an eerie blood-like red light, reminiscent of the dawn, which may signify that the Macbeths are still plagued with insomnia. It is also an omen still believed today: 'red sky in the morning, shepherd's warning'. By dividing the scene into four separate parts, Polanski emphasises the continuity of the Macbeth's life despite their supernatural and bloody predicament. In Michael Bogdanov's Channel 4 version of Macbeth, he tries to create a version that is more palatable to the audience the film caters for. By setting it in a contemporary world, he creates a modern-day Macbeth, using imagery of the twentieth century to clarify certain points in the text. The scene is set in a huge room with a cathedral-like quality, it seems to be in a state of faded grandeur: perhaps reflecting the dereliction caused by the expensive war that begins the play. In place of the altar, if the room was a cathedral, is the throne of Macbeth - a comment on Macbeth's crime of regicide (believed to be a crime against god). The dress is extremely formal, modern-day White Tie. ...read more.

Conclusion

The versions differ also in that in the 1972 version the ghost appears only once, in a broken up sequence, whereas in the 1998 version the ghost appears twice in a more textual, sophisticated manner. The 1972 version remains literal and staidly conventional throughout the film. In my opinion, both films are equally effective. The 1998 version portrays the all-important 'Banquet Scene' as a contemporary dinner party that goes horribly wrong, and the horror-movie quality of the ghost gives the film a really good way of expressing the play in all its glory. The 1972 version remains mostly faithful to the text and to the original staging of the play and is as Shakespeare would have wished his play to be staged. The sheer, unadulterated goriness of the ghost piques most viewer's interest, and the traditional costume as well as the breaking up of the scene give the film a more realistic sequence, instead of the 1998 sophisticated, and yet carefully staged acting. Both films are, however, very well directed and staged and give a really good interpretation of the text, which is enjoyable to people who have both read the text and those who have not. Francesca Lewis UVS, English Coursework Essay. 1.11.02 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Macbeth essays

  1. Macbeth Film Comparison

    This is most probably because of the action-packed nature of the film. Therefore the camera follows the action intensely- for example following the witches around the graveyard. This gives the audience an adrenalin rush- especially in the action scenes where the audience can perceive themselves to be taking part in the violence.

  2. Lady Macbeth's Character in Macbeth.

    [View Saved Essays] Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are basically good people who make an ill judgement. It is unfair for Malcolm to describe them as "this dead butcher and his fiend - like queen". In the beginning they are respected people who share a loving relationship.

  1. Orson Welles' version of the opening scene of MacBeth has some major differences than ...

    The contents that are placed into the cauldron are all unnatural unchristian things. Welles is able to show how the witches have control over some things in nature by showing us a part of the scene where the witches place their hands into the boiling water.

  2. Compare and contrast two different film versions, of Shakespeare's Macbeth.

    Polanski does have some text omitted and introduces some extra props and scenes during the film. He introduces a scene of wild animals, fighting bears and dogs, and also the bird of pray on the ghost of Banquo's shoulder to reinforce the theme of violence and brutality.

  1. A comparison of the Dagger scene, Act 2, Scene 1, from 'Macbeth' as presented ...

    The audience instantly knows what Macbeth is seeing, and we do not have to guess or work out what it is he is talking about. At this point in the play, Macbeth is left alone with his guilty conscience as he struggles with a vision of an imaginary dagger in

  2. With reference to the written Macbeth text, to the R.S.C's 1967 production and the ...

    original, but again I feel this was effective because it gives us a sense of their ability to see the future. Throughout Polanski's film he has alot of different scenery, which are typically Scottish and are very affective to convey how the weather changes throughout the play in relation to what the characters are feeling or saying.

  1. Write an analysis of two different film interpretations of 'Macbeth' exploring dramatic qualities, social, ...

    The director's use of the national lottery shows the social hardship and poverty that many families have to go through on the estate. And it seems as though, by playing the lottery and winning a fortune it is the only way out of the hardship.

  2. Task: Compare and contrast the repersentation of women in "Macbeth" and the two film ...

    Earth, and that God is the most powerful being, so if you defied the King it was as if you were defying God. He believed so much in witchcraft, evil of the Devil and the divine right of Kings that he wrote a book about it called Demonologie.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work