• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing two poems 'Island Man' and 'Blessing'

Extracts from this document...


Essay- Comparing two poems 'Blessing' by Imtiaz Dharker and 'Island Man' by Grace Nicholls are set in different cultures and countries. 'Blessing' is set in a poor Middle Eastern country, and the poem is set around the bursting of a water pipe. 'Island Man' on the other hand, it set in London. It is based around a Caribbean native who is reminiscing about his old life, as he wakes up to go to work, in a cold and Busy London. The title 'Blessing' in the context of this poem, is ironic, because the events described in the poem are both a blessing, and a reminder of the poverty they have. It also describes the 'water pipe bursting' as a blessing, which is usually a word to describe a short and ephemeral moment. This is effective because it informs the reader that this water is a rare occurrence, and will not last long. This contrasts with the meaning of the title 'Island Man' for several reasons. Firstly, 'Island Man' could be taken in the literal sense, meaning what he is 'a man from the Caribbean'. ...read more.


In 'Blessing', the mood could be taken as negative all the way through, with some positive irony being used, in 'the sudden rush of fortune'. This is ironic because the 'fortune' is usually associated with a good thing, yet a 'sudden rush' usually does not last long, symbolising the short time that this water will last for. Also, the 'fortune' that the people are getting, is really not very much, compared to what the word 'fortune' is usually associated with. These poems again differ by way of the perspective taken by the poet in each poem. In 'Island Man', it is describing an event in the past, as if it has happened, and the character and poet are looking back at this. On the other hand, 'Island Man' is describing a moment in the present, and the poet has questioned what will happen when the water runs out, meaning that this poem is looking forward into the future. In 'Island Man 'Grace Nichols has used positive imagery such as' blue surf 'and' emerald Island' to describe the Caribbean morning, creating a vibrant image, and showing that the island man has not forgotten what it is like back home. ...read more.


The rhythm runs fast in stanza three, which relates to the flowing of the water, and the people running to get some in panic. 'Blessing' also has religious connotations, in the title, and lines eleven twelve, with 'roar of tongues' and 'congregation'. This creates religious imagery, and also implies that the bursting of this pipe is perhaps 'a gift from god'. The verse form in both of these poems relates in some way or another to water flowing or dripping. In 'Island Man', the way the lines are structured is similar to the building up and crashing down of waves. In 'Blessing', having the stanzas get longer and then with a shorter one at the end symbolises the build up to the bursting of the pipe, and then the short lived flow of water. Both of these poems have strong effects on the reader. 'Blessing' creates a sympathetic feeling towards the people, who the pipe has burst for. 'Island Man', encourages the reader to imagine what it is like for the man stuck working in London, by creating several distinct images of both the Caribbean and London, making it easier to distinguish and identify the differences between both, and how the man must be feeling. Amy Barton. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. GCSE Essay Cultural Poems

    'Wipe your fingers on your jeans, spit a little on the floor: it's in the bone'. If you look at the first part of the quote, it says, 'Wipe your fingers on your jeans' this suggests that there is nothing for you to wipe your hands on, so you should wipe them on your jeans.

  2. RS Thomas comparing cynddylan and lore

    "It needs more than a rain hearse, wind-drawn, to pull me off the great perch of my laugh" here Thomas inherits a certain amount of light hearted cockiness in the character of Job. He will simply laugh at how nature's weather conditions fights with him on a daily basis but yet nothing has got the better of him.

  1. War Poems

    Here Wilfred Owen is trying to say that the soldiers were blind, drunk and deaf. Of course we know that he doesn't mean this in the literal sense, but it's very effective to emphasise bad the circumstances were for the soldiers.

  2. english literature

    The transformational model of his Dynamics was correct, but it was the reader who does the transformation and not the text. The text was only a raw material. So Holland arrives at the deduction that people who have fantasies after his previous assumption that text embody fantasies.

  1. Poetry often has an underlying social and moral message. How are the social issues ...

    This plays with the idea because it's saying the bin-men are physically above the Mercedes but then makes us think maybe it could be taken metaphorically and that the bin-men are perhaps above the couple in the Mercedes as they might not be as rich or glamorous as the couple

  2. Different Cultures And Traditions

    I will try to impart with you the knowledge which I have learnt about the language of this text. Many may say that the words are quite simple but the thing which is hard about the language in this text I the inner meanings within these words which means there is a meaning within a meaning.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work