• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison Between 'Before You Were Mine' And 'Stealing'

Extracts from this document...


English Coursework Comparison Between 'Before You Were Mine' And 'Stealing' After reading 'Before You Were Mine' once I found it hard to understand exactly what this poem is about. But after reading it several more times, I think it is about Duffy Standing in Georges Square and trying to think or imaging what her mother would have been doing at that moment or place, ten years before she was born. I did not seem to get any clues about where Duffy is until the third stanza. 'Before You Were Mine' also seems to indicate that Duffy's mother could have died because she says "Your Ghost Clatters towards me". But her mother could still be alive and Duffy is just describing a ghost of her mother's former self. I knew who the persona was from the title and the first line, because she talks about herself and where she is. I think that this poem is almost a merge of and a story. This makes the story of the poem even more clear and stronger. The story, which I think is in this poem, is Duffy describing her mother's life ten years before she was born. ...read more.


There is a very big change in the mood of the poem when Duffy says "My loud possessive yell". This is quite an aggressive sentence and it seems out of place in this poem because this poem has not had any other reference to aggression or maybe to reality. This could suggest that Duffy is dreaming or she is imagining it to her liking. After this point in the poem, the mood is more modern and cold. In the previous stanzas, although it was in the past, it seemed as though I could see the images, which Duffy described. But in the last two stanzas I found it harder to generate the images in my mind. Maybe this is because the images are described vaguely or with less detail. The best stanza seems to be comprised of her best memories and gives the idea that 'Before You Were Min' could be in memory of her mother. This could be linked the point that I made earlier saying that 'Duffy's mother could have died'. In 'Stealing', the main theme seems to be cold and lonely. The story of the poem is about someone, probably a boy, who steals a snowman from a garden, and does not see the same snowman when he builds it again. ...read more.


In 'Before you were mine' there was a change in mood about half way through this is different from 'Stealing'. "As cold as a slice of ice" is another example of coldness, because ice can feel sharp because it so cold, but a slice can of ice can actually be sharp. The persona seems to be malevolent or evil because he says, "part of the thrill was knowing that children would cry in the morning" This also goes with the main theme, which is one of coldness or meanness. This says that the character of the persona is maybe evil or mean by nature and does not now it. He could also want the children to have a life like him, which refers to my earlier point. There is not a very strong theme of the past or time in this poem. It is not like 'Before You Were Mine' the last few lines may suggest that the persona has stolen another snowman or something which he wants to be his friend. For example, a dog or a cat. I have said this because at the end he says, "you don't understand a word I'm saying, do you?". As in before you were mine the persona seems to be talking to somebody who isn't there. Jerome Fanfare 8th October 2000 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Carol Ann Duffy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Carol Ann Duffy essays

  1. Explain how Carol Ann Duffy conveys her feelings towards the subjects of the two ...

    The form of both the poems is entirely diverse from one another. 'War Photographer' is written in four regular stanzas, which helps to emphasise the regular, monotonous pattern of the photographer's job.

  2. Discuss the ways in which Carol Ann Duffy explores the theme of alienation in ...

    "Girls" is a one-word line in The captain of the 1964 Top of the Form Team and serves to suggest what the young narrator might be pre-occupied by: or annoyed by! In Stealing the speaker repeats "I" several times, possibly illustrating the character's egotism.

  1. Duffy sometimes creates a character for the speaker of her poem - What methods ...

    the impression that they haven't been quite as honest as they should have been to one another up to this point. She then reiterates what she is doing again, by saying, "Not a cute card or a kissogram", "I give you an onion".

  2. War Photographer - This poem is the only one by Ms. Duffy.

    Stealing This poem (based on a real event) is written in the first person. The speaker in it is very obviously not the poet. Carol Ann Duffy writes sympathetically in that she tries to understand this anti-social character, but he is not at all likeable. What she shows is not so much an intelligent criminal but someone for whom theft is just a response to boredom.

  1. Duffy's Style

    There are four line verses, with the additional one line of the offering of the gift to the unseen person. The poem has no clear argument however a series of observations are made linked by the theme of love. There are disjointed phrases and single word sentences, for example, 'Not a red rose or satin heart' and 'Here'.

  2. We have been instructed to compare two different poems both written by the same ...

    The alliteration used here is a 'T' sound. Not as much alliteration and assonance as the first stanza, but the effect is the same. In this third stanza the thief confesses that he often steals things that he simply does not need.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work