Comparison between the Red Room and the Farthing House.

Authors Avatar

Comparison between the Red Room and the Farthing House

In the two stories that we have read each story explores the feeling of horror and fear. We are examining how each character in each story reacts to the ghost that they encounter. In each story the characters react very different to the different types of ghost that they meet. Well’s story of the ‘The Red Room’ boasts a young, very energetic and arrogant man who thinks that it

‘Will take a very tangible ghost’

to scare him, but panics when confronted with occurrences which challenge his scientific hypothesis. On the other hand Hill’s story of the ‘Farthing House’ reveals a timid yet experienced and mature woman who does not panic because she understands and feels sympathy for the ‘crying’ ghost.

 This seems to be a more direct and intense approach to the ghost. On the other hand the storyteller in the ‘Farthing House’ meets the ghost accidentally. This is brought about when her assigned room had a

‘Serious leak’

and so


The settings for both stories are very different; in the ‘Red Room’ the author has placed the storyteller in a very intense setting. In ‘The Red Room’ the storyteller is in a ‘castle’ which is very gloomy and dark, the characters are very old and untrustful as they were not cooperative and warning the storyteller, maybe trying to

‘Enhance the spiritual terrors of their house by their droning insistence.’

This castle was given the basic characteristics of being a very scary place, and set the platform for a very good horror, an example is,

‘The long draughty subterranean passage was chilly and dusty and my candle flared and made the shadows cower and quiver.’

On the other hand the woman in the ‘Farthing House’ was put in a very relaxed setting. The ‘Farthing House’ is very contemporary it had

‘framed photographs on a sideboard, flowers in jugs bowls.’

and run by polite people, to summarise the setting of the ‘Farthing House’ the storyteller says

‘Farthing house was run, warm and comfortable, and there was good, home-cooked dinner.’

As you can see it is a contrast to the ‘Red Room’

but are ghosts real? Or not. Susan Hill’s story is relating to people who believe that anything can happen, that are totally irrational, and they are lost in a world lacking faith and need some proper guidance. All this is my personal response to the stories, and I prefer ‘The Red Room’ because it was a complete story because it explains why the things happened in the first place. I firmly believe that there is reason behind everything that is happening, be it mental or physical. In conclusion the man in ‘The Red Room’ coped badly with the supposed ghost and so was mentally and physically broken down as a result of the intense setting, his age (experience), his firm belief in logic and science and aggressive ghost. But the woman coped well because she was placed in a very relaxed setting, where all the characters are women; this resulted in better understanding due to the inner bonding. The ghost which the women encountered was not aggressive as the one the man encountered, she also did not have a firm belief against superstition.

Join now!

How H. G. Wells, Builds and sustains tension

In "The Red Room".

The title "The Red Room" immediately attracts the reader's attention; it is symbolic but leaves unanswered questions. "What is the red room?" "Why is it red?" We associate red with fear and danger. Is this room dangerous? Overall, the title raises so much curiosity that it has an overwhelming effect, wanting us to read on and find answers to our questions.

The short story writer has to attract the reader and keep their attention throughout. In order for any story to work, tension has to be ...

This is a preview of the whole essay