• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison of two versions of Romeo and Juliet (Act 3 Scene 1)

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparison of two versions of Romeo and Juliet (Act 3 Scene 1) I am comparing the same scene (act three scene 1) from two different versions of the play Romeo and Juliet written by William Shakespeare. The Zefferelli version which is set in Verona, Italy in the Tudor times and the Luhrman version which is set on Verona Beach, America from the present day. The clothing worn by the actors are very different in the two versions. In the Zefferelli version all the actors wore tights and Tudor clothing whereas in the Luhrman version the clothing is much more modern. The Montague's wear loud colourful shirts, jeans and are pretty laid back; the Capulet's wore black suits, steel heel shoes and look like a mafia gang. The two different times that the versions were set are shown by certain things that happen in the play. Such as In the Luhrman version all the actors use guns whereas in the Zefferelli version all the actors use swords, all though the language is kept the same in both versions the weapons are called swords. The fight scene also shows differences in time such as in the Zefferelli version, when Romeo goes after Tybalt he chases him on foot whereas in the Luhrman version he chases him in a car. ...read more.

Middle

Tybalt doesn't like the fact that Romeo doesn't want to fight. He tells him to "turn and draw" which is a saying often used in western films it means they both turn there backs, tack a certain amount of steps forward then turn and both shoot. In the Luhrman version he punches him, kicks him and much more until Romeo starts to bleed shouting at him to "turn and draw" whereas in the Zefferelli version Tybalts just tells him to "turn and draw". Romeo still doesn't want to fight, after all their family now, although no one knows this apart from Romeo and the audience. This is called "dramatic irony". This causes a much more tense audience as they can't wait to see what happens next. So instead of fighting Romeo tells Tybalt to "be satisfied" In the Luhrman version Romeo pulls out he's gun while saying this whereas in the Zefferelli version he just shakes Tybalts hand. In the Zefferelli version the humour is high and Tybalt puts he's hand in the water as if to say Romeo has germs and everyone laughs, when he takes he's hand out of the water he splashes Mercutio who is still bathing in the fountain, this is were Mercutio decides to fight, after all, Romeo won't. ...read more.

Conclusion

In the Zefferelli version he chases after him on foot whereas in the Luhrman version a car chase breaks out. When they meet the sense of fair play goes out of the window Romeo just wants to kill Tybalt. In the Luhrman version the two cars crash and Tybalts gun falls out, they then fight for the gun, in the end Romeo gets the Gun and shoots Tybalt repeatedly. Whereas in the Zefferelli version they both draw their swords and they fight, at one stage in the fight Romeo loses he's sword. Usually the fight would stop due to fair play not this time other people even try to stop the person getting the sword back to Romeo. Then Tybalt loses he's sword and they have a scruff on the floor then Tybalt gets he's sword back and is just about to kill Romeo when Romeo picks up a sword and stabs Tybalt in the heart. Romeo then realises what he has done and says "I am fortunes fool" and runs off". When the police arrive on the scene all is tearful for Romeos parents and Tybalts too. But in the end the prince has had enough of these public brawls and banishes Romeo. We still watch Romeo and Juliet even though it was written so many years ago, this is because the moral of the film is that gang wars are bad, the world would be a better place without wars. Scott Pearce 11A ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Comparing two versions of Romeo & Juliet (Zefferelli and Baz Luhram).

    At the party in the new version, he is performing as a drag queen, this helps us get an idea of this characters personality, we see that he is lively, energetic and one of those people who has no enemies.

  2. A comparison of the Zeffirelli and Luhrman versions of the 'Romeo and Juliet' Film

    He is not there and therefore not killed. Both films have Romeo find out that Juliet is 'dead' and he rushes back to her tomb in both. In the Zeffirelli film Shakespeare's order of events are followed where Romeo is dead well before Juliet wakes up.

  1. Compare and contrast the way act 3 scene 1 is presented byFranco Zefferelli and ...

    The humidity of the scene is pivotal because it causes Mercutio to climb into a fountain to cool off, thereby providing an opportunity for Tybalt to splash him, and start the fight that results in both their deaths Both directors use a very hot setting.

  2. A Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet.

    Mercutio looked stunned for a few seconds, but then he started to whistle and everyone laughed again. When Romeo stepped in and Mercutio got stabbed, Tybalt looked horrified. As Mercutio staggered around, the crowd of Montagues were all laughing, thinking that he is messing about and pretending to be wounded.

  1. A Comparison Of Luhrman's and Zeffirelli's film Versions Of Romeo And Juliet

    The music has no lyrics and hints at a romantic film. The city looks very old and historic. This gives the impression of how a city would have looked in Shakespeare's time. Unlike Luhrman's, Zeffirelli's has no sound effects or people in the opening scene.

  2. Romeo & Juliet - comparison of film versions

    When Juliet talks to her father, she begs, pleds, she really means what she says and the way she says it, she knows that she needs her family. Her father doesn't want to listen to her, he just throws insults at her, he doesn't give her a choice, or a chance to speak.

  1. Compare two film versions of Romeo and Juliet

    Lady Capulet misinterprets this and thinks that Juliet is weeping for Tybalt, her cousin, who was murdered the night before by Romeo. Juliet's mother is very unaffectionate here, as she says to Juliet who is obviously deeply upset, ' What, wilt thou wash him from his grave with tears?

  2. How does director Luhrman Engage the Modern Audience in his Film Version of William ...

    Luhrman uses an extreme close up on Romeo's face to show the fear and regret he feels for what he has just done. This also brings the audience closer to the character; they feel sorry for him. In the build up to the fight the hand -held camera effect helps to bring the audience in to the fight.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work