Comparisons of love in "A rose for Emily" and "Sweat"

Authors Avatar

September 25, 2006

Comparisons of love in “A rose for Emily” and “Sweat”

          When we think about love, we usually associate it having positive effects on the lives of individuals.  But as portrayed by William Faulkner in “A Rose For Emily and by Zora Neale Hurston, in “Sweat”, the effects of love can be deadly.  In “A Rose For Emily”, Emily’s love causes her to kill to keep, and in “Sweat”, Delia’s love causes her to kill to let go.

        Because she grew up under a very strict set of laws, Emily comes into contact with very few men.  Actually, the only man that has any influence in Emily’s life is her farther, who she loves very much.  As a direct result of her father’s protective nature over her, Emily grows inseparable from her father.  So when her farther dies, his death sends Emily into a deep depression.  One day Emily meets Mr. Homer Barron, who after dating for a short while she falls deeply in love with.  Emily falls in love with Homer because besides her farther, he is the only man she has every spent any time with.  Emily sees Homer as a father figure, which directly causes her to fall so deeply in love with him.  When homer tells Emily that he intends to leave her, Emily does not understand how to handle this news.  Not completely recovered from the death of her father and deeply in love with Homer, Emily is unwilling to let another man she loves leave her.  Emily kills Homer, puts him in their bed, and sleeps next to his dead body every night.  Although we may view this of the behavior of someone who is psychologically ill, Emily sees this as totally normal.  If Emily’s father let her socialize with members of the opposite sex more at a young age, she would not have become so easily attached to the first man she interacted with.  Although Emily’s father is to blame for the majority of her suffering, Emily is not totally innocent.  After her father’s death if Emily would have been open to enjoying life and meeting people, she would have met numerous male friends and wouldn’t have attached herself to just one.

Join now!

        In Zora Hurston’s story “Sweat”, Delia’s resistance to leave her husband demonstrates how much she loves him.  Every since the second month of their fifteen year marriage, Sykes began beating on Delia.  Other than her love for him, there is no other possible explanation for Delia to remain in a relationship for fifteen years and take the abuse that she takes.  Delia stays with Sykes even though she knows he cheats on her.  Not only does he cheat on Delia but Sykes uses Delia’s money, because he has no job, to buy things for his mistress and to pay for ...

This is a preview of the whole essay