• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparisons of openings of Great Expectations - Novel and film.

Extracts from this document...


YEAR 10 MEDIA COURSEWORK COMPARISIONS OF OPENINGS OF GREAT EXPECTATIONS- NOVEL AND FILM In this essay I am going to compare the opening of the film with the opening of the novel. I will write about the differences and why changes were made in the film. Charles Dickens wrote Great Expectations in 1861, in the later years of his life. Dickens fiction is much inspired by a painful period in his life when his father was imprisoned for debt and Dickens, age 12, went to work in a blacking warehouse. His writing was very much a comment on the Victorian society in which he lived, in particular the hardships suffered by many working class children. In the first opening paragraph of the book, the character of Pip is established. I can tell this because it says, " so, I called myself Pip" in the first paragraph you find out his full name " Phillip Pirrip" and how he came to be called Pip. The first paragraph seems to reinforce who Pip is and this makes you think that he is probably the main character in the story and that he is very significant. Also in the first paragraph you can see that it is being written first person. ...read more.


Later on Pip watches the convict walk off and he is described as " hugging his shuddering body, clasping himself. As if to hold himself together." You go from feeling scared and resentful towards the convict to feeling sorry for him. Pip watches him " picking his way among the nettles and among the brambles." This sounds like a place that is unkept, overgrown, isolated a bad place to be. Pip says, " He was eluding the hands of the dead people." It is like the convict is close to death and it creates an unpleasant image. Dickens then uses a simile " like a man whose legs were numbed and stiff." This shows that the convict has probably been sitting and waiting on the marshes for a long time, this increases our feeling of pity. After the convict has left the story returns to the description of the landscape. It says, " The marshes were just a long black horizontal line" this gives the feeling of death and a colourless landscape. Then a metaphor is used " the sky was just a row of long angry lines and dense black lines intermixed." This again is pathetic fallacy as it creates an atmosphere of something brewing like a storm as though the next chapter in the story has some action in it. ...read more.


There are a few close up shots of Pip's sister, we do not know that this is his sister though. She shouts at him telling him she " brought him up by hand." This all makes you feel sorry for Pip. There is a low shot making the woman seem big and powerful, as she is asserting her authority on the small weedy child. There are quite a few similarities between the book and the film such as the graveyard setting and the convict. But there are also many differences such as the establishing shot. Also the film jumps to the second chapter when Pip says he went to see the carols, this does not happen in the book until later on. This has been done to interest the viewer, and the story has to be cut down, so the film makers take out the bits they feel are most important so they can move the film on more quickly. Other changes such as concentrating on a certain part of the convict adds dramatic suspense. This is however like Dickens use of alliteration and repetition to in force an important factor. I think that the book is more effective because with Dickens's brilliant descriptions and use of language, you can really let your imagination go and follow the story in your mind much better than the film. Louise Baldwin R7 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Great Expectations section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Great Expectations essays

  1. The opening graveyard scene of Charles Dickens ' Great Expectations' has become part of ...

    They are wearing traditions clothes for the time the book is set in. Pip's family are wearing quite poor clothes but they still have all the clothes they need. This tells the audiences that they have enough money for what they need.

  2. Diary entry 2

    She then ordered me to call Estella, whose name was as lovely as she was. As soon as Estella came into the room I was once again impressed by her beauty which made me feel a little more at ease.

  1. Compare 'The Darkness Out There' by Penelope Lively and 'Great Expectations'.

    Kerry is kind towards people; " ' Didn't know you were in the good neighbours ' ", polite and pleasant. Pip is also perceived as being content and good-natured; " ' I think she is very pretty ' ", Pip is kind when talking of Estella, even though she is nasty and diminishing to him.

  2. George Eliot criticised Dickens for 'encouraging the miserable fallacy that high morality and refined ...

    Kingsley wrote in his Sermons of the Times (1855) that 'I can say that I have seen among plain sailors and labouring men as perfect gentleman (of God's sort) as man need see...For recollect all, both rich and poor, what that word gentle-man means, it is simply a man who is gentle...'.8 Joe is certainly one 'of God's sort',

  1. Compare the opening of two different film versions of the novel “Great Expectations”.

    In the old version she is more malicious to him because of his class, but in this version they get on well at the beginning. I think that both the versions have done a good job on the acting styles, bearing in mind the time setting of the films.

  2. Great Expectations' Comparisons and Contrasts BetweenChapters 1 + 39

    And so this is why Dickens and his books are so popular- because they create sympathy and empathy, two things that a good book cannot be without. Summary Chapter 1: Pip introduces himself to the readers. Pip goes to the graveyard. Pip meets Magwitch. Chapter 39: There is Bad Weather.

  1. How important is the role of the convict in Great Expectations?

    If you were rich then you got treated well whereas if you were poor you got treated badly; you were considered to be lower than the rich are. In this essay I will be examining how imperative the role of Magwitch is in Great Expectations.

  2. Compare the openings of Great Expectations and Of Mice and Men. How do the ...

    hillside bank and runs deep and green" The reference to Soledad is significant as it means loneliness in Spanish and is a major theme in novel. Here the present tense helps us think that we are there, the word 'green' makes it look healthy, urban and alive.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work