• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Concentrating on act 3 scene 1 of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, how effective do you think the Zeffirelli and Luhrmann film versions are in relation to your own interpretation of the play?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Concentrating on act 3 scene 1 of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, how effective do you think the Zeffirelli and Luhrmann film versions are in relation to your own interpretation of the play? Shakespeare's tragic tale of "two star-cross'd lovers" has survived centuries of political and social upheaval to become one of the most popular and well-known plays of all time. Both Zeffirelli and Luhrmann have seized this opportunity to put their stamp on a literary landmark. It is important to recognise the original context before examining the film versions. Shakespeare set the play in the 16th century, in the Mediterranean city of Verona. Zeffirelli adapted his 1968 version to the 13th century, in the dry, dusty streets of pseudo-Italia. Luhrmann took an entirely different approach with his 1997 film, with a mixture of futurism and kitsch that leads us to doubt the exact era, whilst incorporating the Italian setting into a place of his own devising, Verona Beach. In this way Luhrmann could manipulate the text to suit the setting, while gaining the empathy of both his demanding "generation-x" audience, and the more critical students of the original play. This scene is pivotal to the rest of the play, as without it there would be no tragedy. ...read more.

Middle

Zeffirelli places heavy emphasis on the heat of the day, directing Mercutio to mop his face with a handkerchief. The humidity of the scene is pivotal because it causes Mercutio to climb into a fountain to cool off, thereby providing an opportunity for Tybalt to splash him, and start the fight that results in both their deaths. Zeffirelli is aided in setting his scene by Benvolio's line "for now these hot days, is the mad blood stirring". The Shakespearean connotations of madness are very different to present-day, and "madness" (any unusual or socially unacceptable behaviour) was attributed to everything from diet to climate. Therefore it would have been perfectly reasonable at the time to conjecture that Tybalt is "mad" because of the heat. Luhrmann interprets the role of fate as religious destiny, with the continuous appearance of icons of Christ and the Madonna at pivotal moments in the film. There is also the heavy irony that is typical of Luhrmann's other films, in that these images appear on the most unlikely objects (i.e. guns). The film also implies that Romeo's fate is synonymous with Christ's. At the end of act three scene one Romeo cries, "I am fortune's fool". ...read more.

Conclusion

Zeffirelli remains true to the play in this respect, making Mercutio's death scene a very moving moment. The Zeffirelli film lingers on the irony of Mercutio's words, "Ask for me tomorrow and you shall find me a grave man," where, although the audience understand the gravity of the situation, Mercutio's companions believe him to be acting, until he is actually dead. The Zeffirelli version is very true to the Shakespearian text, both in and portrayal and characterisation. The youth and innocence of the characters draws the sympathy of the audience, making the tragedy all the more poignant. However, it fails to challenge any preconceptions about the play, adhering to the usual interpretation of the themes and characters. Luhrmann injects a controversial aspect to his characters, seizing on the ambiguity of many events that occur within the original stage version to make his mark on the play. The flamboyance of his Mercutio made his death all the more ironic, in that the character had a degree of invincibility about him. My interpretation of the play ties in closely with the Zeffirelli version. However, saying that, I believe the Luhrmann version was a far more entertaining screen adaptation, being accessible to everyone, regardless of whether they had read the play or not. Mass appeal is, ultimately, what films are about, and Luhrmann has incorporated all the aspects of a blockbuster with the timeless appeal of Shakespeare. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Compare and Contrast the two Film Versions of Act 3 Scene 1 in Romeo ...

    In this case the fight was not taken seriously and was not a fight to the death but rather a fight to show each other's skills. This strongly reflects the 17th century context as the public in that era enjoyed sword play and would have been delighted with this lengthy,

  2. What do you think are the dramatic functions of the opening scene of Romeo ...

    We know that this feeling of hate is mutual very early in the play and the fact that we see the servants declaring their revulsion towards members of the opposite households shows us how much the bad feeling has spread we also see a bit later on in the scene

  1. With particular reference to Mercutio how far do you think that Zefferelli and Luhrmann ...

    Mercutio is one of the most unique characters in Shakespeare. In Romeo and Juliet his language is always powerful, imaginative and, at times, beautiful. Mercutio is Romeo's friend and, therefore, he is neither Montague nor Capulet. Consequently, he has not been born into a feud and does not need to uphold an "ancient grudge."

  2. Study Romeo and Juliet in the play that takes their names. Do you think ...

    Romeo is then astonished to learn that Juliet is a Capulet: 'Is she a Capulet? O dear account, my life is my foe's debt.' Juliet is also dismayed to learn that Romeo is a Montague: 'My only love sprung from my only hate, too early seen unknown, and known too late!

  1. How Does Shakespeare make the events of Act 3 scene 1 inevitable from the ...

    It also foreshadows of how Mercutios' love of fighting and for defending Romeo, and how Romeos love of Mercutio gets him killed in Act three, scene one. Shakespeare also shows a much darker, violent side to love, as well as love as a perfect ideal: "If love be rough with

  2. Consider how the dramatist's work is developed, modified and enhanced by the Zeffirelli and ...

    They refer to Capulet maids in the manner of rape and taking their 'Maidenheads', having them 'thrust against the wall', which could be taken as being polite. In the times this play was set, refuse and waste was deposited into the streets out of windows, and therefore the safest place

  1. Show how Shakespeare uses Act 3 scene 1, to develop key aspects of plot, ...

    Also at the beginning of the scene it states "Verona. A public place." This also relates back to the civil brawls previous in the play and gives an indication that another may occur in this scene. The atmosphere at the beginning of the scene is noticeably irritated and this is

  2. The scene I am studying is Act 3 Scene 1, which I think is ...

    and Romeo dies now but the Prince changes his mind so the play carries on. In my opinion this particular scene is good because it is full of action and it is more exciting than the other scenes, it makes the audience wonder what is going to happen next and draws them in.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work