• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Consider how relationships are presented in Harmonium by Simon Armitage and Praise Song for My Mother by Grace Nichols

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Consider how relationships are presented in "Harmonium" by Simon Armitage and "Praise Song for My Mother" by Grace Nichols In both poems, a sense of nostalgia and reminiscence is conveyed; they are written in the past tense which leads to a state of reflection and acknowledgement. As a reader, one can immediately capture this notion, when reading "Praise Song for My Mother", as the title itself has very traditional African connotations - it marks a celebration or tribute of someone's life. Whereas Armitage titles his poem "Harmonium" which is what the poem is physically about but also is symbolic of the relationship between him and his father. Armitage introduces the poem with an anecdote; this evokes a feeling of reminiscence. It contains very physical descriptions - "Shadowy porch of Marsden Church" - this establishes the setting for the reader and perhaps portrays Armitage as being entranced by the church; he appreciates very minute details. However, when describing the "Farrand Chapelette", it was described using the idiom "gathering dust" which has a double meaning - it was physically accumulating dust but also it was coming of age. ...read more.

Middle

Fathoming derives from the Anglo Saxon era and means to embrace - the water embraces many sea creatures and therefore sustains life which is essentially a quality of her mother. But it can also mean to reason out problems - this relates to the idea of a store of knowledge. Armitage gives sunlight agency as it can "beatify saints and raise the dead". This catholic connotation brings about positivity to the church as images of saints are lifted above ordinary people. However, this is contrasted by the destructive power of the sunlight as it weathers the "aged" wooden case of the harmonium and the "fingernails of its key". Armitage personifies the keys to draw a parallel with his dads' "smoker's fingers". Further damage included "one of the notes lost its tongue" which means sound is lost. Armitage then paints an image of a traditional organist who wears "grey, woollen sock". This inspires an idea of how old the harmonium and its battle with time. Armitage describes the motion of pedalling and uses repetition to support the onomatopoeic effect/. Nichols also uses repetition as she starts the second stanza with "You were". ...read more.

Conclusion

As the stanza continues, Armitage makes reference to "father and son" and is talking about him and his father - this increases the feeling of nostalgia as it was him and his father who had sang as choir boys. It is in the fourth stanza where Armitage's emotions become apparent. He makes very delicate comparisons with his father and the harmonium - "dotted thumbs". After this, Armitage how him and his father would "cart it away" - in doing so, the harmonium is described as a valueless item. He personifies the harmonium by describing its "back" similar to how a person would be placed in a coffin. Armitage mentions how his dad belittles his own death. His dad describes his body as "freight" which is monosyllabic and brings heaviness to the comical aspect of his dad. Armitage cannot respond to his dad's cynical humour and has "lost his tongue". This represents the difference in character between the two. In contrast to the sad mood conveyed in "Harmonium", Nichols ends the poem with words of wisdom from her mother - "Go to the wide futures, she said". This reinforces the idea the mother is looking over her and is wise. ?? ?? ?? ?? Ridhwan Ahmed ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparisons section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparisons essays

  1. morning song and catrin comparison essay

    The nakedness of the baby makes the others in the room feel more comfortable because they're all dressed.

  2. Seamus Heaney : Comparisons

    The last line is also shows like at the beginning Seamus Heaney's relationship with the windeby girl as it says 'My poor scapegoat'. However the next stanza takes a different approach rather than beauty, as it carries on the idea of the relationship between Seamus Heaney and the windeby girl

  1. Post-1914 Poetry Comparison How do Plath in Morning Song and Clarke in Catrin suggest ...

    The clearness could perhaps be due to the fact the mother had been waiting for the notes, and therefore her ear was tuned to the noise as she was waiting to hear the cry that would indicate to her that the baby was alive.

  2. Poetry Comparsion of 'Island Man' by Grace Nichols and 'Blessing' Imitaz Dharker

    his home in the Caribbean whereas the people in 'Blessing' have no chance of leaving their home for a better life because they have no money to do so. The "Island Man" is infinitely better of than the people in 'Blessing', they must live each day as it is and do not have the luxury of daydreaming.

  1. How is the idea of identity presented in Agard's 'Half Caste' and Dharker's 'This ...

    argued that this is referring to Dharker moving country and leaving her nightmares behind her. Enjambment is used in both poems, although maybe they are used for different reasons. In half-caste there are multiple reasons. Agard uses a lot of enjambment and this could be because he wants to demonstrate

  2. "The Song of the Old Mother" is a poem set in the Victorian era.

    "And then I must scrub, and bake, and sweep." The relationship between the mother and children is a conventional one. The mother works while her children get on with life, and she seems happy with this.

  1. Belonging "Love Song of J.Alfred Prufrock" "As You Like It"

    and self justifications "there will be time" that in turn are the factors that prevent him from ever belonging. The personification of death "I have seen the eternal footman hold my coat and snicker" epitomizes Prufrock's life, illustrating death has seen how pathetic Prufrock's life is, with him nothing more than a bystander in life, causing death to "snicker".

  2. Comparing Nettles and Praise song for my mother

    The word ?again? shows that this is a continual thing and that Scannell is powerless to stop it. Nichols? poem also has references to the future. The last line is the voice of the mother, who is telling her daughter, through and imperative/ command ?go? to go into her future

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work