• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Contrast and Comparison between the Poems, "Two Scavengers" and "Nothings Changed"

Extracts from this document...


Contrast and Comparison between the Poems, "Two Scavengers" and "Nothings Changed" "Nothings Changed" was written by Tatamkhulu Afrika, a mixed race child with fair skin, who was later adopted by a white South African family who brought him up as though he was white, and he only found out about his origins as a teenager. Tatamkhulu lived in a multi-cultural area called District Six, which was destroyed by the white authorities. He feels strongly about this kind of racism towards the black people despite the fact that he has fair skin. In the actual poem, the poet is telling the story from his own experiences in first person. "Two Scavengers" was written by Lawrence Ferlinghetti. The poem highlights the differences between rich and poor and the working classes, as well as democracy and equality. The poem itself is written in third person and based around a couple of Bin Men and a couple of 'beautiful', rich people. Then, at the end of the poem seems to ask whether America really is a democracy. "Nothings Changed" is set in District Six, based in South Africa. The poet describes District Six as harsh-land, but also goes on to explain that he still feels that it's his home and it's still amiable and natural. I know this because he says, "amiable weeds" on line 8. This is a contrasting sentence because weeds are usually a symbol of bad things, so to use the word amiable to describe them is distinguishing. Socially, there is a separation of race. ...read more.


The black people cannot do the same things as the white people, who seem to be better off money-wise, or at least not in the same way. We are shown this when the poet describes the contrast between the 'whites only inn' and the 'working man's caf�'. The ideas in "Two Scavengers" are to do with the extreme divisions between rich people and poor people in a supposedly egalitarian society, and the effect these divisions have on how people perceived each other. "...the two scavengers up since four am / grungy from their route," this quote encourages us to sympathise with these Bin Men who work anti social hours and who become dirty and smelly as a result. The specific detail (4 am) and the word 'grungy' makes us pity them. The quote, "...the cool couple," does not describe the pair in as much detail as the Bin Men, as the poet is less interested in them. He uses a clich� in this sentence, the cool couple, which is probably what they think of themselves. And finally, the quote, "as if anything at all were possible / between them..." makes me think that the poet would like to believe that the two pairs he describes really could be friends - but the 'as if' tells us he knows that is only imaginary and would probably never happen. He feels that democracy hasn't succeeded because communication between the rich and poor is still impossible. The tone of voice in "Two Scavengers" is that the poet is more on the side of the Bin Men, and is less interested in the "cool couples" side. ...read more.


"Nothings Changed" is set out in six stanzas, each of eight fairly short lines. This kind of regularity in the layout creates a sense of control and shows us that the poet is very clear about what he is feeling. But, within that pattern, the length of the sentences varies from a whole stanza to just two words. To create impact and effect he also uses short harsh lines and words, such as, "It's in the bone" and "small round hard stones click." Ferlinghetti uses repetition in his poem. Individual words are repeated, for instance, "elegant" (lines 8 and 9) and "scavengers" (lines 16 and 26) as well as phrases such as "as if" (lines 29 and 33). In conclusion, "Nothings Changed" and "Two Scavengers" both examine the differences between American democracy and the South African democracy. The poetic devices used are similar in both pieces but both have very different effects on the reader. I found that he way Tatamkhula Afrika structured his poem with short harsh lines was effective because it made things stand out and got the point across quicker. It also gave us a better idea of how the poet is feeling. I also liked the way he wrote the poem in the present tense like he was reliving the experience. In "Two Scavengers", I like the way Ferlinghetti laid out his poem and still made it coordinate with meaning of the poem. And also, the way he started a new line when there was a pause in the speech I found very effective and unlike many other poems. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Lawrence Ferlinghetti: Two Scavengers in a Truck, Two Beautiful People in a Mercedes section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Lawrence Ferlinghetti: Two Scavengers in a Truck, Two Beautiful People in a Mercedes essays

  1. Compare 'Nothing's Changed' with 'Two Scavengers in a Truck', showing how the poets reveal ...

    However, it is clear that Ferlinghetti feels strongly about the divisions (whether in positive or negative light) that wealth can bring, as throughout the poem, he continually contrasts the two 'garbage men' and the 'beautiful people'. For example, in the first stanza, he illustrates the difference in physical height between

  2. Compare the ways in which the poets present characters in

    Accordingly, this gives the impression that the mother loves and cares for her children to the extent that she puts their safety before her own. The father is a "sceptic" and "rationalist" so he is not superstitious whereas the peasants are because they say things such as "with every movement that the scorpion made his poison moved in mother's blood".

  1. Compare how the two poets explore cultural issues in their work

    Also, it suggests that he is trying to control how he feels, e.g. by controlling his breathing. The sentences being used are also becoming more structured and more complex as he describes how he feels and how he knows where he belongs and where he doesn't belong.

  2. Comparing poems of different cultures

    suit with shoulder length long hair and sunglasses" and "the young blond woman so casually coifed". The poem moves to an vague conclusion. The two scavengers see the young couple, not as real people, but as characters in a "TV ad in which everything is always possible" - as if,

  1. What impression do you get from each of the two worlds in the poems, ...

    This shows how the poet feels when he sees his homeland. The second stanza has a repetition of "and" and it also shows that the poet feels the racial separation in this country in every bone in his body, eg "my feet know, and my hands, and the skin about my bones".

  2. nothings changed and 2 scavengers

    Black people were seen as second-class citizens, and had inferior living conditions. The poem expresses the author's anger about how he was treated and how black people where treated. In nothings changed the poet is comparing the Africa from when the whites where in power, to now when black people

  1. A comparison between the Poetic techniques of Ferlinghetti & Afrika

    Those are the main differences. However, there are other differences that are present: Ferlinghetti's poem is taken from a freeze-frame, basically meaning that a moment in time is taken, like a snapshot with a camera.

  2. Compare how Society is presented in 'Nothings Changed' and 'Two Scavengers in a truck ...

    change there standing, and 'close the gulf' between them by increasing there wealth and cleaning themselves up. This may never happen for the older man, which makes you feel sorry for him and wonder why he chose this job. The younger of the two bin men may be able to

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work