'Coral Island' had a 'pretty big connection' with 'Lord of the Flies', however, whereas Ballantyne's boys lead noble decent lives, Golding's boys progressively deteriorate - Compare the social, cultural and historical issues which underpin both novels.

Authors Avatar

Wider Reading – ‘Lord of the Flies’ and ‘Coral Island’

* Golding conceded that ‘Coral Island’ had a ‘pretty big connection’ with ‘Lord

of the Flies’.  However, whereas Ballantyne’s boys lead noble decent lives, Golding’s boys progressively deteriorate.  Compare the social, cultural and historical issues which underpin both novels.

At first sight, ‘Coral Island’ seems an extremely pompous and arrogant novel.  This, however, is because the book is being read from a 21st century perspective, whereas when Ballantyne wrote ‘Coral Island’ it was seen as a thoroughly enjoyable story.  This is because the book was written in the 19th century, when the people of Britain felt that they had developed an organised society where humans were at their best and flourishing.  As Ballantyne himself described the society:

‘Britons at the top of the tree, savages and pigs at the bottom.’

Looking at ‘Coral Island’ from a 20th century point of view, Golding analysed the book very critically and decided that it was an out of date, arrogant, false portrayal of society and that he could write a better book.  He sat down and wrote ‘Lord of the Flies’ to show the problems of human nature.  The island in the book was used just as a place to put his group of boys away from the adult world, but also had symbolic values linked closely to the theme of evil in man throughout the novel:

‘The island itself is a symbol of perfection and paradise, and the instant that humans arrive, a scar of destruction is left through the once perfect forest.  The island is also boat shaped, and looking out at the waves at a point on the island gives the illusion that it is moving backwards.  This symbolises a journey in which man is always moving on, but makes no progress in life.’

Join now!

As well as being linked to Golding’s beliefs, the use of the island also enabled direct comparisons with ‘Coral Island’.  Golding hated the tone and ideas of Ballantyne in ‘Coral Island’, and expressed his thoughts publicly on many occasions:

‘I decided to take the literary convention of boys on an island, only make them real boys instead of paper cut-outs with no life in them, and try to show the shape of the society they evolved would be conditioned by their diseased, their fallen nature.’

In ‘Coral Island’, the language and tone of the story is seen ...

This is a preview of the whole essay