Death of the American Dream

Death of the American Dream

In Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, all the characters are, in one way or another, attempting to achieve a state of happiness in their lives. The main characters are divided into two groups: the rich upper class and the poorer lower class, which struggles to attain a higher position. Though the major players seek only to change their lives for the better, the idealism and spiritualism of the American Dream is eventually crushed beneath the harsh reality of life, leaving their lives without any meaning or purpose.

Tom and Daisy Buchanan, the rich socialite couple, seem to have everything they could possibly desire; however, though their lives are full of material possessions, they are unsatisfied and seek to change their circumstances. Tom, the arrogant ex-football player, drifts on "forever seeking a little wistfully for the dramatic turbulence of some irrecoverable football game"(Fitzgerald pg. 10) and reads "deep books with long words in them"(pg. 17) in order to have something to talk about. Though he appears happily married to Daisy, Tom has an affair with Myrtle Wilson and keeps an apartment with her in New York. Tom's basic nature of unrest prevents him from being satisfied with the life he leads, and so he creates another life for himself with Myrtle. Daisy Buchanan is an empty figure, a woman with neither strong desires nor convictions. Even before her loyalty to either Tom or Gatsby is put to the test, Daisy does nothing but sit around all day and wonder what to do with herself. She knows that Tom has a mistress on the side, yet hesitates to leave him even when she learns of Gatsby's devotion to her. Daisy professes her love to Gatsby, yet cannot bring herself to tell Tom goodbye except at Gatsby's insistence. Even then, once Tom pleads with her to stay, Daisy quickly changes her mind and ultimately leaves Gatsby for a life of comfort and security. The Buchanans are the ultimate examples of wealth and prosperity, the embodiment of the rich life of the American Dream, yet their lives are empty, unfulfilled, and without purpose.

This is a preview of the whole essay

Though Myrtle Wilson makes an attempt to escape her own class and pursue happiness with the richer set, her efforts ultimately produce no results, and she dies, a victim of the very group she sought to join. Myrtle tries to join Tom's class by entering into an affair with him and taking on his way of living, but in doing so, she becomes vulgar and corrupt like the rich. She loses all sense of morality and is scornful of people of her own class. Her constant clothing changes signify her dissatisfaction with her life - she changes personalities every time she changes her dress: "with the influence of the dress her whole personality had also undergone a change. The intense vitality... was converted into impressive hauteur"(pg. 35). She treats the elevator boy in her apartment building with disdain: "Myrtle raised her eyebrows in despair at the shiftlessness of the lower orders. 'These people! You have to keep after them all the time.'"(pg. 36). It is evident that although American democracy and principles are based on the concept of equality among people, social discrimination does still exist, and the divisions between classes cannot be overcome. Myrtle strives for a new life for herself, yet she is corrupted by the supposedly 'better' group and finally falls victim to it.

Jay Gatsby's idealistic view of Daisy Buchanan creates a conflict for him once he is confronted by the reality. Over the course of five years, Gatsby has built Daisy up in his mind to be the perfect woman, someone that the actual Daisy could never measure up to: "no amount of fire or freshness can challenge what a man will store up in his ghostly heart"(pg. 101). Daisy cannot help but fall short of Gatsby's dream, and so Gatsby is disappointed that the woman he loves does not exist as he imagines her to be. Though Gatsby is rich, he is of the lower set, and he attempts to join the upper class with Daisy. His desire for a better life stems from his faith that anything is possible if he puts his mind to it, which is also a part of the American Dream. However, Gatsby's dream collapses when he fails to win Daisy and is ultimately rejected by the higher social group. No ill-gotten wealth can help him and though a bullet from George Wilson's gun kills him physically, Gatsby dies spiritually when Daisy chooses Tom over him. The failure of Gatsby's ideals is directly related to the failure of the American Dream in that it is destroyed by reality, in this case by the reality of Daisy's rejection. Without his dream, Gatsby has nothing, no fire to keep him going, no direction, and no purpose.

Throughout the novel, Fitzgerald shows the collapse of dreams, whether they are dreams of money, status, or simply of happiness. The biggest collapse, however, is of the American Dream. The failure of the American Dream is unavoidable, not only because the reality of life cannot compare to idealistic dreams, but also because the ideals are usually far too perfect to be paralleled in reality. Dreams give purpose to life, something to work toward, an end to the road. Without dreams one's life has no meaning, as shown in the fates of Gatsby and the Buchanans. Their lives become empty and hollow without the presence of some ideal. Gatsby is a prime example of the failure of the American Dream. Though he has become successful in life, all his wealth stems from illegal sources: "he... bought up a lot of side-street drug stores here and in Chicago and sold grain alcohol over the counter"(pg. 141). Gatsby seems to think nothing of earning his money by illicit means, though that practice goes directly against the principles of the American Dream. Nick comments on this failure of the American Dream in his narrative descriptions of the characters, where all the immoral people have the money and the moral ones are the poor lower class. The American Dream is something all people work toward to some extent, yet it is doomed to failure as its ideal conflict with the reality of life. Although it is an admirable goal, it is an unobtainable one. The American Dream is just that - a dream.

Peer Reviews

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

sydneyhopcroft

24th of Feb 2012

Quality of writing

The Quality of Written Communication is very good as well. There is evidence that the candidate is very adept with the use of English and a wide range of vocabulary which has been spelt correctly in all circumstance is used. There are no grammatical or punctuational errors either.

Level of analysis

The Level of Analysis is of an extremely high standard. This candidate can expect to score a very high A grade for their response, which is both informative and insightful, picking apart the characters and their feelings towards their dreams from various parts of the novel. I think this candidate missed a trick when analysing Gatsby and not mentioning Carraway's conclusion of his character on the final page: "he [Gatsby] seemed so close to his dream that he could not fail to grasp it. But it was already behind him", which refers to what the candidate has wonderfully commented on - that the Daisy Gatsby wants no longer exists - she has changed and mutated from the immaculate vision he has cherished in his mind for five years ("no amount of fire or freshness can challenge what a man will store up in his ghostly heart"). Nonetheless, this is an exceptional essay showing a great depth of understanding of Fitzgerald's character and his writing style, with an astute use of adjectives to perfectly document their explanations, backed up with appropriate sources from the text. One major irk I have with this response though, is that the candidate has neglected to mention George Wilson. As stated in the fantastic introductory paragraph, it is not just the wealthy and the newly wealthy who have dreams - the lowest of the low in society also have dreams and whilst there is commentary and sufficient analysis on Myrtle Wilson, there should at least be an appreciation of what George represents - the dead carcass of the poor society - living on the ashes of the richer populations' squandering of luxuries, his physical fixation to the barren underbelly of New York shows how, even those most deserving of the American Dream; those who have slaved and slaved for years to provide not only for themselves, but for their family (Myrtle in this case, as George had been saving up to take her away from the Valley of Ashes, but she died the day before he was planning to tell her), will never change their position in society - Tom leads George on by making him believe he will buy his car, but he only visits to see Myrtle - this false hope again highlights the facetiousness of Tom Buchanan, but also the helpless... 'loyalty', if you like, the poor hold the rich to in order to believe, for a brief moment, that they could ever join them in luxury.

Response to question

This is an exceptionally strong response to a question that asks candidate to discuss how the American Dream manifests itself in every one of the characters, as well as discussing how, regardless of how beguiling it's luminescence might be, all the dreams built upon it's foundation turn to rubble. The candidate makes a sensitive recognition of how dreams are presented in the novel, which characters dream of what and to what extent and cost do they achieve their dream, if at all. This is a very well-structured response, considering the dreams of three of the biggest characters in the novel.

Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn