• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

DID MALVOLIO DESERVE TO BE TREATED SO HARSHLY?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Twelfth night Did Malvolio deserve to be treated so harshly? The story of twelfth night is formerly the story of two twins, - Viola & Sebastian, who become shipwrecked, &, both believing the other is dead, adopt new lives in this foreign country. Viola, however, perhaps sensibly considering the 1600th view of women, decides to dress up as a boy, - coincidently, she looks extraordinarily like her brother Sebastian. Viola gets herself a position in Duke Orsino's court. Duke Orsino has, in fact, fallen in love with the countess Olivia, who's brother & father have recently died. It is in Olivia's household that the part of the story that we will be focussing on happens.. We meet some new characters there: Feste - Who is the court Jester Fabian - One of Olivia's household. Maria - Olivia's waiting woman Sir Andrew Aguecheek - Who is Sir Toby's companion. Sir Toby Belch - Olivia's uncle. Malvolio - Olivia's head Steward. Malvolio, as you will probably find out is extremely narcissistic, very bumptious, often complacent & has a lot of contempt. It is excruciatingly easy to see exactly why he is disliked, but, during the play, the other characters, during a particular awkward scene, are pushed just that little bit too far by Malvolio & plot their revenge. The revenge on Malvolio is devised mainly by Maria,(Olivia's maid), but with the help of Sir Toby, Sir Andrew, Fabian & Feste. The plot is too get their own back on Malvolio by a devious trick. What happens is that Maria, who's handwriting is extraordinarily like that of the countess Olivia's, writes a love letter as sorts, to "the dearly beloved." - In it she writes about the one who she adores, & commands, that, if her feelings are returned, then the one to whom the letter is addressed should show it in "their smiles", by wearing yellow cross gartered stockings, & by making it obvious that "the dearly beloved" is above everybody else, even those higher than themself. ...read more.

Middle

He has seen no sign of Olivia having any interest in him whatsoever, & already, he is narcissistic enough to believe that he could ever end up being her husband. At last he finds the letter. Here, in some ways, it can be argued that Malvolio deserves any fate that comes to him as a result of what the letter may contain as he never should have opened it in the first place. It is addressed to "to the unknown beloved, this, & my good wishes" - The letter is not addressed to him, it doesn't say his name, there is no indication whatsoever that it is even meant for Malvolio, & yet, still, he automatically assumes it is meant for him. If he wasn't so contemptuous, then he never would have opened the letter, & he wouldn't be in the situation he gets himself into at the end of the play. The letter, also, has Olivia's wax seal on the back of it, &, it is in what Malvolio believes to be her handwriting. If he was true to his job, & if he were to do the right thing, he would automatically go & hand the letter in, - Like he should do. Unfortunately, he does not. Fabian comments on the letter: "What dish o' poison has she dressed him!" - He is trying to say that Malvolio walks straight into the trap they had set him, but, if he hadn't been so arrogant, it never would have worked. The letter reads "Some are born great, some achieve greatness, & others have greatness thrust upon 'em" - Malvolio of course, takes this an indication that he will become "Count Malvolio" - Anyone else, would not believe anything so ludicrous. The letter orders Malvolio to "Be opposite with a kinsman, surly with servants; let thy tongue tang arguments of state; put thyself into the trick of singularity......remember who commended thy yellow stockings & wished to see thee ever cross gartered" - The letters ...read more.

Conclusion

He is a lovable character, whom you feel incredibly sorry for, & the director has made it so you feel more empathy towards Malvolio, - connecting you more to the play. I think that he, at least, believed that Malvolio was done wrong. After looking at both viewpoints on malvolio however, I'm still not exactly sure what I believe. I do believe that MAlvolio was far too arrogant & contemptuous & really did need somebody to bring him back down to earth. I believe he did need a lesson teaching him, but I'm not sure Sir Toby & Maria went about it the right way, &, even if they did, - I think it went too far! At first, I think the letter was an amusing joke, gulling Malvolio into self humiliation, but think, after they nearly convinced him he was mad, & locked him up, I think it went way too far! I don't think you should be able to just play with people's feelings that way. I am sympathetic to Malvolio & believe it went too far, but on the other hand, I do, of course realise that anybody in the 15th or 16th century, at the time when the play was written wouldn't have had as much sympathy. They would have loathed Malvolio's puritanical ways, - after all, the puritans did go on to get Christmas cancelled! - The idea of anybody being able to convince another that they were mad would have made them laugh out loud & they would have found it extremely amusing. In conclusion, I believe that Malvolio was treated too harshly, but I do, of course, see all the different points of view, & believe that he was extremely contemptuous & self righteous, & for that, he needed bringing back down to earth! ?? ?? ?? ?? Twelfth Night Course-work Kathy Raison Twelfth Night Course-work 4T ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Twelfth Night section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Twelfth Night essays

  1. Does Malvolio get what he deserves, or is it a joke gone too far?

    to quieten the gentleman. "Mistress Mary, if you prized my lady's favour at anything more than contempt, you would not give means for this uncivil rule: she shall know of it by this hand" Sir Toby, Maria and Feste (who had been slighted previously by Malvolio)

  2. What exactly is the purpose of Feste in 'Twelfth Night'?

    time, and, like the haggard, check at every feather that comes before his eye. This is a practice as full of labor as a wise man's art, for that he wisely shows is fit, but wise men, folly-fall'n, quite taint their wit' (3:1:50-58)

  1. In Twelfth Night, what are your Impressions of Malvolio and do you think he ...

    My lady bade me tell you that, though she harbours you as your kinsman, she nothing allied to your disorders. If you can separate yourself and your misdemeanours, you are welcome to the house. If not, an it would please you to take leave of her, she is very willing to bid you farewell."

  2. Was Malvolio mistreated in Twelfth Night?

    So gathering from this information I am satisfied to claim that characters from many novels and plays are generally stereotyped to be of a character other that themselves just for the fact that they are from a particular race or have a particular belief.

  1. Twelfth night - Feste says to Olivia, Maria and Malvolio 'better a witty fool ...

    This is what Feste had noticed about Malvolio. Throughout the play Feste and Malvolio show their characters to be very different. The largest difference between them is that Malvolio shows himself to be a strict puritan (at least on the outside) whereas Feste is, in every way, against puritanical beliefs.

  2. What is Orsino's attitude towards women and how does this change during the course ...

    sees her as being the answer to all problems, 'She purg'd the air of pestilence.' Orsino exaggerates his love for Olivia; he says he loves her 'with adoration's, with fertile tears and groans of love.' This makes Orsino seem as if he is obsessed with Olivia.

  1. How does Shakespeare manipulate the audience to dislike Malvolio towards the beginning of the ...

    This shows the audience this character can be played with for amusement, as Sir Andrew is only indicating the beginning of the song, however, 'Hold thy peace' meant to be quiet, and Feste interprets this literally saying he cannot begin if he has to be quiet!

  2. Twelfth Night - Consider Shakespeare's portrayal of Malvolio throughout the play and say how ...

    This speech tells me certain things about Malvolio's personality. Firstly he is angry at all of them for disturbing Olivia, who he is very protective over. Secondly, he is angry at them for getting drunk, something that he does not approve of being a puritan. He does not understand why anybody would want to get drunk and makes fools of themselves by singing and acting merry.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work