Discuss, analyse and compare the original script of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, Act One, scene five with Baz Luhrmann's 1997 film version of the same scene.

Authors Avatar

Pre 1914 Written Drama Coursework

Romeo and Juliet

In this essay I aim to discuss, analyse and compare the original script of William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, Act One, scene five with Baz Luhrmann’s 1997 film version of the same scene.

‘Romeo and Juliet’ is set in Verona, Italy, and is believed to have been written around the late sixteenth century.  The timing and setting of the play would therefore suggest that costume, music and setting traditional to the time would be used.

On the other hand, Baz Luhrmann has taken a very different approach to the interpretation of the play.  This version is made to appeal to the modern audience and so has adopted all the elements of any other high budget, Hollywood blockbuster. The film is set in the created world of Verona Beach, taking on a typical American, Hollywood feel with skyscrapers and other modern buildings lining the streets of the city.  The fast pace, good-looking actors, and many twits to the story also add to that modern day, blockbuster feel.

‘Romeo and Juliet’ is one of Shakespeare’s most famous plays telling the tale of two teenagers from rival families (the Capulets and the Montagues) who fall in love. As the story unfolds, tragedy is all that awaits the couple, eventually leading to their own suicides.

Act one, scene five of the play sees a ball taking place in the Capulet residence, to which Romeo, along with other Montagues, attends.  It is here that he meets Juliet and they fall in love.  I have divided the scene into seven sections making it easier and more manageable to analyse and compare the two versions of the scene in detail.

Join now!

The first scene begins with a conversation held between four servants of the Capulet family clearing away from the feast that has just taken place, and making preparations for the ball ahead.  The conversation held consists of two servants complaining about how little the others are doing to help them, Potpan in particular.

        “ SAMSPON : Where’s Potpan, that he helps not to take away?

                He shifts a trencher? He scrapes a trencher? “

Once the characters have established Potpan’s whereabouts, Sampson, who is clearly in charge of the servants, gives them instructions as to what to do ...

This is a preview of the whole essay