• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss Eddie Carbone as the tragic hero of the play

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Discuss Eddie Carbone as the tragic hero of the play "One who is neither villainous nor exceptionally virtuous, moving from happiness to misery through some frailty or error in judgement." The above opening quotation is from Aristotle, which is his view of what elements a tragic hero contains. This essay will investigate the destiny of the main character Eddie Carbone also known as a tragic hero, as illustrated by Arthur Miller in 'A view from a Bridge' against Aristotle's view of a tragic hero. The play takes place in Brooklyn in a working-class Italian-American neighbourhood which is hooked by a social code. Eddie Carbone a husband and supposedly father who raised an orphan niece as a daughter due to a death bed promise. A longshoreman working on the docks, working hard in life that was hard; on the other hand a good man not intentionally trying to be mean, but the downfall to his life faces him when his niece falls in love with one of the immigrants, a young handsome man, which is hard for Eddie to cope as his inner thought of his love for the niece is too much that he does not admit but is persistently protective as he is obsessed with her and is scared of anyone stealing her, in other words it shows his jealousy. Eddie seems to have an obsessive love for his niece Catherine which he covers up and puts the situation across that he is responsible for what she does; the truth is he doesn't want her to be in the company of other men or lose her to them: "Katie, you are walkin' wavy! ...read more.

Middle

Eddie moves from happiness to sadness when Beatrice's illegal immigrant cousins arrive from Italy as Catherine and Rodolpho seem to be attracted to one another, and start dating, and this worries Eddie greatly: Eddie: They must've seen every picture in Brooklyn by now. He's supposed to stay in the house when he ain't working. He ain't supposed to go advertising himself. Beatrice: Well, that's his trouble, what do you care? If they pick him up they pick him up, that's all. Come in the house... [Comes to him, now the subject is opened]: What's the matter with you? He's a nice kid, what do you want from him? Eddie: That's a nice kid? He gives me the heeby-jeebies. Beatrice [Smiling]: Ah, go on, you're just jealous. Eddie: Of him? Boy, you don't think much of me. The dialogue used here consists of many rhetorical questions, and the use of colloquial language and an unusual word choice is used 'heeby-jeebies.' This therefore tells us a great deal of what Eddie actually thinks and how strongly Eddie seems to be in love with Catherine, but does not admit this at any point in the play, but he is concerned about Catherine and the fact she is with Rodolpho. He can not bear this, and his jealousy puts an affect on why he finds Rodolpho not right. Beatrice proves that Eddie is jealous but he comes in anger and shows how he can be jealous of someone like Rodolpho who sings on the decks with a whole song out his mouth, with motions. ...read more.

Conclusion

Thanks. [He dials.] I want to report something. Illegal immigrants.Two of them. That's right...' The author creates the use of irony and shows how Eddie's passionate opposition to the marriage between Rodolpho and Catherine forces him to make this decision to report them up. It is ironic as his actions backfire and he loses his own honour and respect in the neighborhood. Also Eddie told the story of Vinnie Bolzano as if it was a terrible thing, but Eddie is in the same situation. Episodes after episodes occur of Eddie trying to cope with his inner violent reaction until he commits what his neighborhood consider the most shameful of crimes. This is a feature of a tragic hero as they always die in some way at the end. In this play Eddie dies by Marco coming back for revenge but Eddie approaches Marco with a knife, since Marco is strong, he turns Eddies arm and kills him with his own knife. The importance of the knife still in Eddies possession shows that he brought his own downfall, and the traces of his fingerprints are on it, shows he committed it himself. The image created is he brought his own death on himself, through his own error in judgment. Therefore Eddie is a tragic hero as he is not intentionally evil, his weakness of letting Catherine go causes him to suffer and move from happiness to misery eventually a wrong decision to his own death. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Miller essays

  1. Why and How Does Eddie Carbone Change As The Play Progresses? What Leads to ...

    However, Miller hadn't, throughout the whole book, outlined the incestuous nature of his desires. What I had concentrated on was how he had fallen for something he couldn't have, due to age, his marriage and the respect that would've stayed best the way it is.

  2. Who is responsible for the death of Eddie Carbone?

    She comments to Rodolfo: "I can tell when he's hungry or wants a beer before he even says anything". In Act one Catherine is very na�ve and behaves the wrong way towards Eddie; she acts more like a wife to him than Beatrice does.

  1. 'Eddie Carbone, like all tragic figures, is responsible for his own downfall.' Explain how ...

    Alferi for legal advice but Eddie found that there was only one solution, which he came to by himself, was that he had to phone the immigration Bureau to inform them the whereabouts of Marco and Rodolpho. As Marco and Rodolpho are arrested Marco spits at Eddie and threatens to kill him.

  2. Analyse the ways Arthur Miller presents Eddie Carbone as a tragic hero whose downfall ...

    food onto the plates", This type of behaviour is mainly shown by younger children when they do something to displease their parents and illustrates how strong the bond between Eddie and Catherine is. Eddie is trying to stop Catherine from growing up which is impossible, he is fighting the inevitable and this will only end in misery.

  1. Eddie Carbone is the hero of A View from the Bridge to what extent ...

    Beatrice has reacted very aggravated towards Eddie because of the trouble he has caused that has built up throughout the novel, she explodes with anger. Repeating the phrase shows how Eddie has pushed other close characters towards him to limit.

  2. Is Eddie Carbone a tragic hero?

    is very admirable and respectable. Another respectable and admirable thing he has done is accepting two 'submarines' (illegal immigrants effectively) and if he is caught with them he will be fined. Again pops up the money issue where he is putting his money at risk for two people he has

  1. In a poor Italian community of Brooklyn, the Carbone family consists of three members, ...

    He tries to get the law involved to stop Catherine and Rodolpho's marriage. Frustration builds in Eddie, when Alfieri tells him that the law can't do anything about it. He also tries violence, by teaching Rodolpho how to 'box'. Marco, however, takes immediate note of this and comes to his brother's aid.

  2. How far can Eddie Carbone be described as a tragic hero?

    In the past tragic heroes were often were based on real and well known historical characters, each writer would alter these characters or the story slightly so as to send out their own didactic message, so as to warn or teach the audience not to make the same mistakes the characters has.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work